Business Details
40 Years
experience
Authentic Mexican Dining Experience in Gillette
Casa Maya has been serving authentic Mexican cuisine in Gillette since June 1986. We designed our menu and atmosphere to provide an immersive experience of Mexican culture and culinary traditions. Our commitment to quality ingredients and traditional preparation methods ensures each dish maintains the integrity of its Mexican heritage. We specialize in Sonoran-style Mexican cooking that balances flavors without overwhelming spice, while still offering options for those who prefer additional heat.Every meal is prepared fresh daily using the finest available ingredients, a practice that has earned us recognition and awards from reputable publications like The Star-Ledger and New Jersey Monthly. Our restaurant has become a beloved local destination for experiencing traditional Mexican dining with family, friends and colleagues.
Services
Fajitas
Carnitas
Enchiladas
Tacos
Nachos
Quesadillas
Burritos
Tamales
Catering Service
Desserts
Details
- Year established: 1986
Highlights and features
- We use only the highest quality ingredients in every dish we prepare
- Our menu features authentic Sonoran-style Mexican cooking since 1986
- We offer an immersive Mexican cultural atmosphere with our dining experience
- Our fajitas are made with unique seasoning for distinctive flavor
- We've received recognition for exceptional food from The Star-Ledger and New Jersey Monthly
Services
Fajitas
Our signature fajitas feature marinated and charbroiled fillings served with warm flour or corn tortillas. Each order includes fresh guacamole, sour cream and our special Pico de Gallo salsa. Available with chicken, beef, pork or vegetables.
Carnitas
Slow-cooked pork marinated in garlic, pepper and tequila creates our delicious carnitas. Served with hot flour or corn tortillas to make your own tacos, accompanied by guacamole and sour cream for a complete flavor experience.
Seafood Dishes
We offer a variety of fresh seafood preparations including our Enchiladas del Mar with crab and shrimp in a creamy wine sauce, Camarones al Diablo with garlic and peppers, and our Fish Maya prepared with a unique Mayan sauce of capers and lemon.
Lunch Menu
Daily lunch offerings feature numbered dishes including Chile con Carne, Chile Relleno, Taquitos and Burritos. Each lunch entre includes a choice of black beans, chicken or gazpacho soup and the first basket of chips and salsa is on the house.
Catering Service
We provide catering for events with options including Nachos Rancheros for 8-15 people, Camarones al Ajillo, Quesadillas, Guacamole, Burritos and Fajitas. Available in half pan and full pan portions depending on event size.
Questions
What is Casa Maya known for?
Casa Maya is known for serving authentic Mexican cuisine in Gillette since 1986 with high-quality ingredients and traditional Sonoran-style cooking methods.
What types of Mexican dishes do you offer?
We serve a wide variety including fajitas, enchiladas, tacos, burritos, tamales, and special seafood dishes, plus traditional sides and desserts.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide catering with options for groups from 8 to 25 people featuring favorites like nachos, fajitas, quesadillas and seafood dishes.
Are your dishes very spicy?
Our Sonoran-style cooking features balanced flavors with mild to moderate spice, though we offer additional hot sauces for those who prefer more heat.
Do you have vegetarian options?
Yes, we offer vegetarian burritos, enchiladas, and our Burrito de Vegetales filled with zucchini, mushrooms, broccoli and peppers.
Reviews (7)
Jess
Dec 19, 2021
Report
Great food, the Carnitas are to die for, huge portion! Steak Ranchero was served rare and it was a huge portion! Had leftovers of both the next day.
Kit Garcia
Nov 25, 2021
Report
Really liked the food. An unexpected Gem on an awkward location. Parking is behind the two houses behind the restaurant and you kind of walk pass the front of the other houses to get to the restaurant. Accidentally found the parking lot. Service was great. Food was very good. Ambiance nice. Would travel here again.
Nik
Nov 18, 2021
Report
Food is outstanding. Best Mexican in the area. Its a small restaurant so there is often a wait but it is well worth it. A little on the expensive side but very good quality. Always happy with my experience here.
Pranali Kerkar
Nov 04, 2021
Report
Awesome authentic Mexican food and wonderful service. The owner is warm and welcoming and they do suggest great dishes from their menu according to your liking.
Dinesh Reddy Vakiti
Aug 21, 2021
Report
It's a pretty place. All the dishes we had were tasty. They have a good parking lot in the back. The only problem we faced was that the place is not pet friendly. So, we had to keep our dog in the car while we ate.
Brandon Locke
Jun 10, 2021
Report
A small Mexican restaurant with simple but delicious food. Staff is good, but the ambiance is amazing. This place is great for dinner with the family, a date for a loved one, or even a quick bite by yourself.
Susan Prisco Realtor
Feb 04, 2020
Report
Great Mexican food! Chicken with mole sauce was great. We also had the nachos super yummy. Everyone loved their dinners. Food was very good. Service was great. Atmosphere is authentic Mexican inspired. Fun place to eat. Good portions.