Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Jamestown, NY
Established in 1955, Greenlee Winchester has served Jamestown, Mayville, Findley Lake, Bemus Point, Cassadaga, and surrounding communities with personalized insurance solutions. Our approach prioritizes understanding clients' unique needs to design comprehensive coverage plans for individuals, families, and businesses. As active members of the community, we combine local expertise with a commitment to quality service, offering tailored homeowners, automotive, and commercial insurance products.Our team leverages decades of experience to secure competitive rates while maintaining a focus on transparency and client education. We specialize in addressing complex risks, including farm insurance programs that recognize dual residential-commercial properties. Through multi-policy discounts and partnerships with financially sound insurers, we deliver value-driven protection aligned with our clients' evolving needs.
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Automotive Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Farm Insurance
Rental Property Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1955
Highlights and features
- 60+ years of local insurance expertise in Chautauqua County
- Personalized coverage tailored to individual and business needs
- Specialized farm insurance programs for combined residential-commercial properties
- Multi-policy discounts for bundled homeowners, auto, and commercial coverage
- Largest auto insurer in western New York with competitive rate access
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Protect your primary residence or second home with customized policies covering structural damage, personal belongings, and liability protection. We offer specialized coverage for high-value assets like artwork and classic cars while providing multi-policy discounts for combined coverage.
Automotive Insurance
Secure comprehensive auto coverage for cars, motorcycles, and specialty vehicles including RVs and classic cars. Our policies offer liability protection, collision coverage, and multi-car discounts while addressing unique needs like seasonal vehicle storage and farm equipment transport.
Commercial Insurance
Safeguard your business with tailored liability coverage, workers' compensation, and property insurance. We specialize in farm packages, garage liability, and contractor-specific policies while offering competitive pricing through partnerships with top-rated insurers.
Farm Insurance
Address dual residential-commercial risks with integrated farm insurance programs covering equipment, livestock, and property damage. Our policies protect against crop loss, machinery breakdowns, and liability claims while incorporating specialized endorsements for agricultural operations.
Rental Property Insurance
Protect investment properties with policies covering structural damage, rental income loss, and liability claims. We offer tailored solutions for apartment complexes, vacation homes, and commercial rental units while providing risk management advice to property owners.
Questions
What types of homeowners insurance do you offer?
We provide coverage for primary homes, second homes, rental properties, and specialty dwellings like mobile homes. Our policies include protection for high-value items such as jewelry and classic cars.
Do you offer multi-policy discounts?
Yes, we provide discounts for bundling homeowners, automotive, and commercial insurance policies. Our clients typically save 10-15% through our multi-policy offerings.
Can you insure specialty vehicles?
We cover motorcycles, RVs, classic cars, boats, and off-road vehicles. Our specialists help customize coverage for unique transportation needs and seasonal storage requirements.
What commercial insurance options exist for farmers?
Our farm packages combine property, liability, and equipment coverage tailored to agricultural operations. We offer specialized policies for crop protection, livestock, and farm-related business risks.
How do you help businesses find competitive rates?
We leverage our status as western New York's largest auto insurer to negotiate favorable terms. Our commercial team compares multiple carriers to secure optimal coverage at competitive pricing.
Reviews (4)
Benjamin Nichols
Mar 02, 2021
Report
Positive:Quality
Been with them for years, always been treated well and will continue to stay with them.
Been with them for years, always been treated well and will continue to stay with them.
Getting Along Alone
Dec 27, 2019
Report
I have been with Greenlee Ins. since 1988. I have been ripped off for years because I didn't know they own the insurance they sell you, therefor, they make percentage of the expensive Insurance they sell you. They have ZERO interest to save you a penny because it affects their bottom line. I went to Brown & Brown Ins in Jamestown instead, and they were able to gut my rates in half and saved me $700 a year on the coverage Greenlee was over charging me on. Stay away from Greenlee Ins. They are a rip off and never try to find you a better rate. You will never hear from them if they could save you
Nicole DeVlieger
Sep 20, 2016
Report
Greenly is amazing have used them for about 10yrs would highly recommend them to just about anyone lowest rates i could find.
Steve Koestler
Jun 13, 2015
Report
Experience counts a lot when it comes to finding a insurance policy and in this regard Greenlee-Winchester Insurance Agency is hard to beat. They are one of the reliable and reputed family owned and operated insurance agency offering auto, homeowners, and commercial insurance.
