Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
39 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining in Northborough, MA
A.J. Tomaiolo's Restaurant has been serving authentic Italian cuisine to Central Massachusetts since 1987. Founded by Anthony Tomaiolo, our establishment is built on decades of culinary expertise and a commitment to using the freshest ingredients sourced daily. Every dish is prepared in-house with traditional sauted techniques, complemented by made-to-order service that guarantees quality and customer satisfaction.

Our dedication to excellence extends beyond foodwe offer a warm bar atmosphere, private function spaces accommodating up to 75 guests, and catering services for events of all sizes. With over 35 years in operation, our family-owned business continues to prioritize personalized service, ensuring every guest experiences the rich flavors and hospitality of true Italian dining.
Services
Italian Cuisine Private Events Take-out Service Full Bar Catering Services Wine Selection Dinner Menu Buffet Options Banquet Rooms Seafood Specials
Details
  • Year established: 1987
Highlights and features
  • We have over 35 years of experience in authentic Italian cuisine.
  • Our dishes are prepared daily with imported olive oil and fresh ingredients.
  • We offer made-to-order preparation for personalized dining experiences.
  • Our private function rooms accommodate events for 25-75 guests.
  • We guarantee customer satisfaction with every visit.
Services
Italian Cuisine
Our Italian cuisine features sauted entrees made with imported olive oil and fresh ingredients daily. We specialize in traditional dishes like Chicken Piccata, Veal Marsala, and Eggplant Parmigiana, served with house-made sauces. Our menu also includes seafood specialties, premium cuts of beef, and house-made desserts.
Private Events
We offer private event spaces for gatherings of 25-75 guests, including weddings, corporate events, and family celebrations. Our main dining room and separate banquet room provide flexible configurations with Italian-inspired ambiance. Full catering services are available for customized menus and bar packages.
Catering Services
Our catering services provide authentic Italian cuisine for off-site events. We offer buffet and plated dinner options with dishes like Lasagna, Chicken Marsala, and Eggplant Parmigiana. Menus can be customized for parties of 12-30 guests with wine pairings and service staff available upon request.
Full Bar
Our bar features classic Italian cocktails like Negronis and Bellinis, with premium spirits and wine selections. We offer 12 wines by the glass, including Italian Pinot Grigio and Chianti, alongside American craft beers and specialty martinis served in chilled martini glasses.
Take-out Service
We provide take-out service for our full menu, including appetizers, entrees, and desserts. Guests may order family-style meals or individual portions for pickup. Special dietary requests like gluten-free pasta are accommodated with advance notice through our online ordering system.
People
Anthony Tomaiolo
Founder
Anthony Tomaiolo opened the original Shrewsbury location in 1987 before moving to Northborough. He has over 35 years of experience in Italian cuisine, personally overseeing menu development and quality control. His commitment to authentic recipes and fresh ingredients shapes our restaurant's operation.
Questions
What are your dinner service hours?
We serve dinner Tuesday through Sunday from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM. The restaurant is closed on Mondays.
Do you offer gluten-free options?
Yes, most menu items can be prepared gluten-free with advance notice. We offer gluten-free pasta for an additional $2 charge.
Can I make a reservation?
Reservations are recommended and can be made by calling us directly at 508-393-5245 during operating hours.
Do you host private events?
Yes, we accommodate events for 25-75 guests in our main dining room and separate banquet space. Full catering services are available.
Are children welcome?
Yes, we welcome families and offer kid-friendly menu options. High chairs are available upon request at our host stand.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, debit cards, and cash payments for all services and merchandise purchases.
Reviews (6)
Wachira T. Sittikong
Jan 25, 2022 Report
Was referred by a great friend to try out this amazing hidden gem! Located in Northboro, A.J. Tomaiolos Restaurant hit all the spots! Looking for some fresh Italian dishes! Homey, delicious and absolutely fresh it was the perfect place for what we were craving! We had ordered the mussels in white wine sauce, a cheese pizza for our daughter, The seafood fra diavolo and the filet mignon with lobster ravioli with a brandy white wine sauce with extra sauted onions and mushrooms for my wife and I! Everything was absolutely amazing and delicious, prepared fresh and hot! Lisa the Bartender kept coming
Kelly Thayer
Jan 19, 2022 Report
I love the food here. Our service was extremely poor BUT i think its the world we live in now and I have patience for that. Places are short staffed and our server may have been new. I would still gladly go back to this local gem.
Denis F.
Dec 29, 2021 Report
Arrived just before closing time. Expected to be rushed a little bit, and that would have been okay. Nothing of the kind. As it was pretty late the restaurant was about empty. But the waitress let us know that she had to set up for the next day and we could take our time. Everyone enjoyed their meal, and the portions were ridiculous, but way too good to pack up and reheat! I had a veal chop that was likely the best I've ever had.

Can't comment on the deserts as we were much too full to even think about it. Wish we lived closer.
Marshall Horwitz
Oct 17, 2021 Report
The antipasto was a real treat. Excellent eggplant parm and veal francaise. Very reasonably priced. We did take out and the service was prompt.
John M.
Oct 13, 2021 Report
When we lived in Shrewsbury we ate here at least once (maybe twice) a week. We felt like family, but then it was time for us to move home to Belmont Shore, CA. I've said ever since that there is no good Italian food in Southern California. Our son was the victim of a violent crime in Worcester a number of years ago. We decided to have dinner here while he was still in the hospital. We were treated royally by the family. Thank you to them for making a horrible situation a little more tolerable.
Patty Erickson
Sep 18, 2021 Report
Service and food was awesome!! I guess they have been here for many years you can tell very clean and food was exceptional!!! Prices were average not to high worth trying! We will be back for sure!!!