Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
25 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Expert Dental Care in Shelbyville, IN
Founded in 2001, Blue River Dental has been dedicated to providing compassionate and efficient dental care to the Shelbyville community. Our practice combines advanced technology with personalized attention to ensure same-day appointments, immediate treatment, and a welcoming environment. Our mission is to deliver stress-free dental experiences through VIP-level service, cutting-edge tools like CEREC and CBCT imaging, and a commitment to whole-body wellness.

We prioritize patient comfort, offering services ranging from cosmetic enhancements to emergency care. With a team of experienced dentists and a focus on community involvement, we strive to exceed expectations through transparency, expertise, and genuine care. Our dedication to ongoing education and participation in professional associations ensures we remain at the forefront of modern dentistry while maintaining a judgment-free, patient-centric approach.
Services
General Dentistry Cosmetic Dentistry Emergency Dentistry Invisalign Restorative Dentistry Wellness-Focused Dentistry
Details
  • Year established: 2001
Highlights and features
  • We provide same-day appointments and immediate treatment to minimize wait times.
  • Our use of cutting-edge technology ensures faster, more accurate diagnoses and treatments.
  • We treat patients with genuine care and respect in a judgment-free environment.
  • Our team combines high-tech precision with a down-to-earth approach for patient comfort.
  • We actively give back to the community through local partnerships and scholarships.
What people say
Kind and professional staff Best experiences ever Super friendly and helpful 10/10 recommend Amazing staff
Services
Cosmetic Dentistry
Transform your smile with personalized solutions like veneers, professional whitening, and Invisalign. Our cosmetic services focus on enhancing aesthetics while maintaining oral health. Using advanced techniques, we ensure natural-looking results tailored to your goals.
Emergency Dentistry
Immediate care for dental pain, injuries, or urgent issues with same-day appointments available. Our team prioritizes rapid relief and restoration to minimize discomfort. Trusted expertise ensures effective solutions during critical situations.
Invisalign
Straighten teeth discreetly with custom, removable aligners that fit your lifestyle. Invisalign treatment offers comfort and convenience without compromising aesthetics. Advanced planning ensures precise, predictable results.
Restorative Dentistry
Restore functionality and appearance with crowns, bridges, and full-arch solutions. We use durable, biocompatible materials for long-lasting results. Advanced technology streamlines treatment for fewer visits and optimal outcomes.
Wellness-Focused Dentistry
Integrate oral health with overall wellness using biocompatible materials and preventive strategies. Our approach addresses systemic connections to promote long-term health. Personalized care ensures treatments align with your body's natural balance.
People
Dr. Carrie Pumphrey
Founder
Dr. Pumphrey founded Blue River Dental in 2001 after earning her dental degree from Indiana University. Active in professional associations, she combines high-tech precision with compassionate care, prioritizing same-day solutions and patient comfort.
Dr. Betsy Crandall
Dentist
Dr. Crandall serves Shelbyville since 2007 with a focus on compassionate, judgment-free care. A graduate of Indiana University, she emphasizes patient empowerment and stays updated through local study clubs and professional memberships.
Questions
What dental services does Blue River Dental offer?
We provide general, cosmetic, restorative, and wellness-focused dentistry, including Invisalign, same-day crowns, and emergency care tailored to your needs.
Do you handle dental emergencies?
Yes, we offer same-day appointments for urgent issues like pain or injuries to provide immediate relief and restore your smile.
What payment and insurance options are available?
We accept most insurance plans and offer financing through CareCredit and Alphaeon for flexible, budget-friendly payment solutions.
How do I schedule an appointment?
Book online instantly or call (317) 743-9258 for same-day or routine visits—our team ensures a quick, hassle-free process.
What sets Blue River Dental apart from others?
Our focus on same-day care, advanced technology, and personalized attention ensures efficient, stress-free visits in a welcoming environment.
Videos
Reviews (7)
James Ramsey
Nov 22, 2021 Report
They are super kind and definitely concerned more about your overall health then just selling you a procedure. All the staff have been very polite and great to deal with.
Beverly Hoeing
Nov 22, 2021 Report
They are the best at Blue River Dental! From the beginning of your visit to the end you feel cared for and its a special place! Never thought I would enjoy going to the dentist!
Lisa Taitt
Nov 20, 2021 Report
This dental office was amazing. I was asked detailed questions on health issues, sleep routines, and anxiety on paperwork website that they reiterated during the visit. They had amazing new equipment that really helped me visualize what they were seeing. Very responsive, very kind and it was an enjoyable visit to the dentist.
Tina Noah
Nov 18, 2021 Report
My husband and I really like Blue River Dental!! You get quality care and smiling happy faces. They are very through and patient. Would recommend them to everyone!!
Mona Bernard
Nov 12, 2021 Report
Excellent care and concern for all my dental care.Drs Carrie and Betsy, their entire stall are very friendly and caring.I have been a patient there for 20 years, they always make me feel at ease with their care.
Megan Smith
Nov 06, 2021 Report
Everyone is so incredibly friendly. Ive never had to wait very long once Ive arrived. They always answer any questions I have. I live 1.5 hours away but Blue River is still my dentist office because of the amazing staff.
Tammie Wilkerson
Nov 03, 2021 Report
Everyone that I had contact with at Blue River Dental was so nice and supportive. They treat you as a friend. I received dentures at Blue River dental and am very happy with them. Dr. Crandall was great, very encouraging and a great dentist!