Business Details
Private Island Dining Experience
Rum Bay Restaurant has established itself as a premier dining destination on a private island, offering guests a unique culinary experience blending island traditions with American cuisine. Our commitment to fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and vibrant flavors is evident in every dish we craft, from succulent seafood to handcrafted burgers. With over 25 years of culinary tradition, we pride ourselves on delivering exceptional service in a serene, oceanfront setting that captivates both locals and travelers alike.Our dedication to quality extends to our signature Swamp Sauce, an award-winning condiment that embodies the spirit of island living. Operating seven days a week with no reservations required for smaller parties, we ensure effortless access to unforgettable island dining through our convenient water taxi service, while maintaining the highest standards of food safety and customer satisfaction.
Services
Island Dining
Water Taxi Service
Private Events
Award-Winning Sauce
Fresh Seafood
Handcrafted Cocktails
Open-Air Seating
Locally-Sourced Ingredients
Highlights and features
- We offer a unique private island dining experience with waterfront views
- Our menu features fresh seafood and award-winning Swamp Sauce
- We provide convenient access via scenic water taxi transportation
- We serve handcrafted cocktails with tropical flavors
- We maintain 7-day service with no reservation requirements for small groups
What people say
Incredible appetizers
Excellent recommendations
Wonderful service
Fantastic food
Beautiful views
Services
Island Dining
Experience exquisite island cuisine at our private oceanside restaurant. Our menu features fresh seafood, handcrafted burgers, and tropical cocktails in a serene setting surrounded by mangroves. Enjoy panoramic water views while dining on a secluded island accessible only by water taxi.
Water Taxi Service
Access our private island restaurant via scenic 15-minute water taxi rides departing daily from the mainland. Our convenient transportation service operates from 11:30 AM to 6 PM, with return trips available until 8:30 PM, ensuring seamless access to exceptional island dining.
Catering Services
Host special occasions at our island paradise with customized catering solutions. Our team specializes in creating memorable dining experiences for weddings, corporate events, and private gatherings, combining exceptional cuisine with breathtaking oceanfront scenery.
Signature Sauce
Take home our award-winning condiment that embodies island flavors. This versatile sauce enhances any meal and is available for purchase, allowing customers to recreate Rum Bay's distinctive taste in their own kitchens.
Fresh Seafood
Indulge in daily catches prepared with island-inspired techniques. Our seafood selection includes blackened mahi, seared grouper, and shrimp, all sourced from local waters and expertly prepared to highlight natural flavors.
Questions
How do I get to Rum Bay Restaurant?
Access Rum Bay via our water taxi service departing from Leverocks Restaurant at 7092 Placida Rd, Cape Haze. The 15-minute scenic ride costs $6 per person and operates daily from 11:30 AM to 6 PM.
What are the restaurant's operating hours?
We're open daily from 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM for lunch and dinner. The water taxi runs from 11:30 AM to 6:00 PM with the last return trip at 8:30 PM.
Is reservation required for dining?
We don't require reservations for parties under 10. Larger groups should call ahead to reserve water taxi space. Seating is available on a first-come basis.
What makes your seafood special?
We feature daily catches from local waters, including fresh mahi-mahi, grouper, and shrimp. Our seafood is prepared using island-inspired techniques that highlight natural flavors and quality.
Can I buy your signature sauce to take home?
Yes, our award-winning Swamp Sauce is available for purchase. This versatile condiment captures the essence of island flavors and enhances any meal.
What dining options are available for special events?
We offer private dining experiences and event hosting on our private island. Our dedicated team can customize menus and settings for weddings, corporate events, and special occasions.
Reviews (7)
Ginny Lumb
Jan 12, 2022
Report
The food is good but the patio needs a good cleaning. The umbrellas are black with mildew, the slots of the tables have quite a bit of old food stuck inside, the side entrance door is black with grease around the door knob, and the deck is dirty and greasy.
Mark Piatkowski
Dec 27, 2021
Report
Seated right away, but after a long wait we had to ask for a waitress. Waitress finally arrived and said it was the hostess fault she didn't know we were there, though we watched her tend to tables around us. Had to ask mgmt for our appetizer, then shortly after getting it the waitress arrived with someone else's food. She said it was the kitchen's fault; was very disappointed in the service. We live on the island and will only go back as a last resort.
Janet Mahan
Dec 18, 2021
Report
The host told us 10 minutes. We have gone back up every 15 and We are still sitting here 55 minutes later. Finally ordered at bar. The food was delicious..... but the bartenders are awesome
Sonnie
Dec 12, 2021
Report
So fun!! Great seafood!! The lobster was decadent! Highly recommend the tacos and the bartender is attentive and makes a great cocktail
Josh Trott
Nov 17, 2021
Report
Rum Bay is somewhere we always need to stop. There is nothing like a bucket of rum! The food is tasty, but the booze is where it's at. Beautiful views
Sylver Slusar
Oct 25, 2021
Report
Vacation Dinner our last evening in FL (10/10/21) We took a 60 sec. car ferry across the water to get to the restaurant (NOTE! We came in from the wrong direction, lol.) However, the restaurant was great! Food was outstanding and plentiful. Not used to shrimp that meaty, tender and flavorful. Our waitress was beyond exceptional (Lauren?). Anyway.... don't miss a chance for some great food & atmosphere in a great part of old Florida!!
Michael Merculieff
Oct 17, 2021
Report
We swung by here for lunch after, a morning of fishing. They have docks to tie your boat up and walk down a nice little board walk to the restaurant and bar. We had there sword fish, and Mahi Mahi. Both where really great. Will stop here next time we are boating in englewood again.