Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Grand Rapids Since 1850
Preusser Jewelers has been serving West Michigan and beyond for over 174 years, establishing itself as Michigan's oldest continuously operating jeweler. Founded in 1850 by William Preusser, our business combines a rich heritage with modern expertise in fine jewelry, diamonds, and gemstones. We specialize in custom designs, bridal jewelry, and in-house repairs, offering personalized service in a relaxed atmosphere. Our commitment to transparency in pricing and ethical sourcing ensures clients receive exceptional value. With a focus on building long-term relationships, we provide appraisals, consignment, and liquidation services to meet diverse client needs. Our team of skilled artisans and gemologists brings decades of experience to every project, whether creating bespoke pieces or restoring heirlooms.

As a family-owned business, we uphold the values of integrity and craftsmanship that have defined our reputation since 1850. Our clients benefit from our deep industry knowledge, including expertise in the GIA 4Cs diamond grading system and lab-grown diamond options. Located in Grand Rapids, we serve both local and regional customers seeking trusted jewelry expertise. Our dedication to customer satisfaction is reflected in testimonials highlighting our attentive service and ability to fulfill unique jewelry visions.
Services
Custom Designs Jewelry Consignment Jewelry Appraisals Bridal Jewelry Loose Diamonds
Highlights and features
  • We offer 174 years of jewelry expertise and heritage craftsmanship
  • Our in-house studio creates custom designs from concept to completion
  • Transparent pricing with ethical sourcing of diamonds and gemstones
  • GIA-certified gemologists provide accurate jewelry appraisals
  • Comprehensive services include repairs, consignment, and estate liquidation
What people say
Warm and welcoming Spotless repair results Incredible patience Transparent pricing Dream ring creation
Services
Custom Designs
Our in-house studio transforms jewelry visions into reality through custom designs. Clients collaborate with skilled artisans to create unique rings, necklaces, and heirloom restorations using ethically sourced diamonds and gemstones. The 4-6 week process includes design refinement and craftsmanship that blends traditional techniques with modern technology.
Jewelry Appraisals
Professional appraisals determine jewelry value for insurance, estate planning, or sale purposes. Our GIA-certified gemologists evaluate pieces using standardized grading systems, providing documented valuations that consider market conditions, craftsmanship quality, and material authenticity for both contemporary and antique jewelry.
Jewelry Consignment
We offer consignment opportunities for fine jewelry owners seeking market expertise. Our team evaluates pieces for resale potential, determines competitive pricing, and handles sales logistics while maintaining transparency about commission structures and expected timelines for different jewelry categories.
Bridal Jewelry
Specializing in bridal collections from renowned designers, we provide curated selections of engagement rings and wedding bands. Services include center stone selection, mounting customization, and ethical sourcing options for diamonds that meet GIA quality standards.
Loose Diamonds
Our inventory includes ethically sourced loose diamonds graded by independent certification bodies. Clients receive expert guidance on the GIA 4Cs (cut, color, clarity, carat) to select stones that balance quality and value for custom settings or investment purposes.
People
David
Owner
David, the current owner, continues the Preusser family legacy with transparent pricing practices and personalized service. His expertise in diamond valuation and commitment to client satisfaction have earned numerous testimonials praising his trustworthy approach to high-value jewelry transactions.
Debra
Customer Service
Debra provides exceptional client care with patient guidance through jewelry selections and repair processes. Her attentive service has been specifically praised in customer reviews for resolving complex repair issues and maintaining clear communication throughout transactions.
Questions
What jewelry services do you offer besides sales?
We provide custom design services, jewelry repairs, appraisals, and consignment options for selling fine jewelry pieces.
How long does custom jewelry creation take?
Custom designs typically require 4-6 weeks from initial concept to final delivery, depending on complexity.
Do you appraise inherited jewelry pieces?
Yes, our GIA-certified gemologists offer appraisal services for estate jewelry and heirlooms.
Can you help with diamond selection for engagement rings?
Our experts guide clients through diamond choices using GIA grading standards to find ideal stones.
What makes your jewelry store unique?
As Michigan's oldest jeweler since 1850, we combine heritage craftsmanship with modern ethical sourcing practices.
Reviews (5)
Tisha DeGiulio
Sep 22, 2021 Report
I went into a different GR local store to get my engagement ring fixed (they actually made my solitaire crooked and nicked a prong) so I went to Preusser Jewelers, and Im so impressed!! Debra is so sweet and easy to talk to, she listened to my concerns and made the process so easy. I went in 6 days later, and my ring is spotless!! The gentleman there is just as kind as Debra, and again he made it a very quick and easy process. My ring looks brand new, blindingly shiny, and youd never guess there was ever a nick in the prong! Thank you so much!! Will be purchasing my bands from here
D. K.
Aug 20, 2021 Report
I have been a customer of Preusser Jewelers for 30 years. I have purchased jewelry and have had custom jewelry made. I have had a beautiful medical bracelet made with engraving on the back and now am going to call to see about getting a medical necklace done. :) They have incredible patience and class and are never pushy. They help you pick out what is in your best interest too. When I think of Preusser, I think of the "class" of downtown Grand Rapids. Need I say more?
Megan Smith
Aug 18, 2021 Report
I cannot thank Caryn and Deb enough. We got my engagement ring from them and I could not be happier. They both dealt with me when something (completely out of their control) went wrong on my end, and calmed me down, and fixed everything right away. We ended up getting another diamond necklace as well as my engagement ring and they made the process so simple and easy. They got me the diamond(s) I wanted, let me choose from multiple ones, got me different settings to try for my ring and necklace. Just truly went above and beyond.
Caryn was my main point of contact and I am just so thankful for her
Unknown Unknown
Mar 16, 2021 Report
I would not recommend this place for an appraisal. I wanted to get my grandmas ring appraised and resized so that I could wear it. This was the first jeweler I went to. The short, dark haired lady told me that my ring was white sapphires and had a large synthetic dark red stone. She then went to her manager to ask for his/her opinion, which she came back and said her manager agreed with her appraisal. I went to two different jewelers after this because it did not sit right with me, both jewelers after this told me it was a garnet center stone with diamonds around the outside. Will not ever be
Nicki Sparks
Feb 04, 2021 Report
I had some gem stones given to me so I took them in for some ideas. I worked with Dave and could not be more pleased. He had great suggestions. Work was done in a very timely manor. And now I have some beautiful jewelry! Beautiful store, great service, very nice people!