Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Seville, Ohio
Established in Seville, Ohio in 1972, Plumer Insurance has dedicated over five decades to serving individuals, families, and businesses across northern Ohio. Our team combines more than 75 years of collective experience to deliver personalized insurance solutions, leveraging advanced technology for accurate comparisons and efficient service. We prioritize reducing client costs while closing coverage gaps through tailored protection programs. With a commitment to prompt claims resolution and ongoing policy reviews, we aim to build lasting relationships grounded in trust and expertise.

Our services span auto, home, life, health, and commercial insurance, alongside financial planning tools like annuities and retirement accounts. Backed by partnerships with leading insurers, we ensure competitive pricing and comprehensive coverage options. As a locally rooted agency, we emphasize community engagement and client education to empower informed decision-making. Our dedication to transparency, budget-friendly payment plans, and responsive support underscores our mission to protect what matters most to our clients.
Services
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance Health Insurance Commercial Insurance Umbrella Liability Business Property Business Liability Annuity Disability Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1972
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 50 years of local insurance expertise and tailored coverage solutions.
  • Our team combines advanced technology with personalized service for optimal efficiency.
  • We guarantee prompt claims resolution and ongoing policy adequacy reviews.
  • Budget-friendly payment plans and cost-saving strategies are available for all clients.
  • Our partnerships with top insurers ensure competitive pricing and comprehensive options.
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance policies tailored to individual driving habits, vehicle types, and coverage needs. Our solutions include liability protection, collision coverage, and uninsured motorist options. With access to multiple carriers, we ensure competitive rates while maintaining superior service standards for claims processing and policy adjustments.
Home Insurance
Our homeowners insurance offers customizable coverage for primary residences and investment properties. Policies include structural protection, personal property coverage, and liability safeguards. We specialize in risk assessment for northern Ohio's climate conditions while offering discounts for safety features and multi-policy bundling.
Life Insurance
We offer term life and universal life insurance solutions for income replacement, estate planning, and legacy protection. Our agents help clients evaluate coverage amounts based on financial obligations and family needs. We partner with top-rated carriers to provide competitive premiums and flexible policy terms.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial packages protect businesses with property, liability, and auto insurance tailored to industry-specific risks. We serve contractors, retailers, and service providers with customizable policies that include equipment protection, workers' compensation coordination, and cyber liability options for modern enterprises.
Financial Services
We provide annuities, disability insurance, and retirement account solutions including 401(k) plans. Our financial specialists help clients create diversified portfolios that complement insurance protections, ensuring comprehensive financial security strategies for individuals and business owners.
People
James Harris
Owner
James Harris, owner of Plumer Insurance, holds a Bachelor of Science degree from Kent State University. With over 25 years in property, casualty, and life insurance, he leads the agency's strategic direction while maintaining active client relationships.
Emma Bair
Insurance Agent
Emma Bair brings management and insurance expertise from the vendor side to Plumer Insurance. A Chippewa High School graduate, she specializes in personalized policy solutions while actively participating in community outdoor activities.
Jane Rych
Licensed Agent
Jane Rych, with 37 years in insurance, holds FLMI and CISR designations. Her dual experience in company home offices and agencies informs her expertise in personal lines coverage and client service optimization for Plumer's policyholders.
Darla Gordon Payn
Clerical Specialist
Darla Gordon Payn supports agency operations with clerical expertise, drawing from 17 years running a children's clothing store and 35 years managing Gordon Trucking Co. She contributes organizational skills from diverse business experiences.
Tyler Harris
Business Intern
Tyler Harris, a Kent State University business student, assists with administrative tasks while gaining hands-on insurance industry experience. His background in sports leadership and community engagement enhances client interactions at the agency.
Questions
What types of insurance does Plumer Insurance Agency offer?
We provide auto, home, life, health, and commercial insurance, along with financial services like annuities and retirement plans.
Do you offer business insurance solutions?
Yes, we provide commercial property, liability, and auto packages tailored to northern Ohio businesses across various industries.
Can you help reduce my insurance costs?
We analyze your coverage needs to identify savings opportunities through bundling, safety discounts, and carrier comparisons.
What if I need after-hours assistance?
Saturday appointments and extended hours are available by arrangement with our office staff.
How are claims handled?
We prioritize prompt claims processing with direct support to ensure fair, timely resolutions for all policyholders.
Reviews (1)
Mary Gavin
Aug 04, 2020 Report
They always help me find the best price they just aren't so good at getting back to you, you always have to get back to them