Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Hartville, OH
Founded in 1957, Yoder-Bontrager Insurance has served individuals, families, businesses, and churches for over six decades. As an independent agency, we prioritize personalized service by offering diverse insurance solutions tailored to each client's unique needs. Our team of experienced agents believes in listening first to understand client requirements, ensuring comprehensive coverage for homes, vehicles, businesses, and life insurance.Rooted in the Hartville community, we integrate faith-based values with financial stewardship, maintaining strong relationships with clients through attentive service. Our partnership with Erie Insurance since 1978 underscores our commitment to excellence in the Eastern United States and Great Lakes Region.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Church Insurance
Farm Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1957
Highlights and features
- We have over 60 years of experience serving Hartville and surrounding communities.
- Our independent agency status provides access to diverse insurance solutions from multiple providers.
- We prioritize personalized service through active listening and tailored policy recommendations.
- Our team maintains deep local knowledge of community-specific insurance requirements.
- Faith-based values guide our approach to ethical insurance solutions for churches and ministries.
What people say
Top notch customer service
Friendly hometown atmosphere
Great care for clients
Lifelong community members
Faith-based values
Services
Home Insurance
We provide comprehensive home insurance solutions for primary residences, seasonal properties, and rental units. Our policies protect against common risks while offering optional coverages like flood insurance, sewer backup protection, and identity theft recovery. With multiple carrier options, we help clients find affordable policies that match their specific needs.
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance covers cars, trucks, motorcycles, RVs, and watercraft with flexible coverage options. We offer competitive rates through multi-car discounts and home-auto bundling while accommodating drivers with varying records. Commercial auto policies protect business vehicles and fleets against property damage and liability claims.
Life Insurance
We offer term and permanent life insurance policies to protect families against financial hardship. Term policies cover specific periods for final expenses and debt protection, while permanent policies provide lifelong coverage with cash value accumulation. Our agents help clients choose appropriate coverage amounts and policy structures.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance packages protect diverse industries including contractors, retailers, manufacturers, and restaurants. Coverage options include general liability, property insurance, and commercial auto policies. We specialize in creating tailored solutions for small businesses, medical providers, and auto dealerships.
Farm Insurance
We provide specialized farm insurance for family-owned operations including dairy farms, hobby farms, and horse farms. Coverage includes property protection, liability insurance, and specialized policies for farm equipment, livestock, and agricultural systems. Our agents understand the unique risks faced by farmers.
People
Emily Bontrager-Manchester
Personal Lines Agent
Specializes in personal lines insurance including auto, home, and umbrella policies with a focus on client education.
Chris Minick
Personal Lines Agent
Experienced property and casualty agent helping clients protect their personal assets through comprehensive insurance solutions.
Paul Bontrager
Principal Agent
Leads commercial insurance services with expertise in property and casualty coverage for businesses of all sizes.
Joey Viscounte
Commercial Account Manager
Manages commercial insurance accounts while providing specialized support for business clients' risk management needs.
Jody Miller
Customer Service Representative
Delivers friendly customer support and policy assistance to ensure smooth insurance experiences for all clients.
Questions
What makes Yoder-Bontrager Insurance different from other agencies?
We combine over 60 years of local experience with independent agency status to offer personalized solutions tailored to Hartville community needs.
Do you offer payment plan options for insurance policies?
We work with clients to find affordable payment solutions, though specific payment plans aren't detailed in our public information.
Can I get insurance coverage for unique properties like cabins or hobby farms?
Yes, we specialize in customized coverage for seasonal homes, rental properties, and hobby farms with specific liability protections.
How often should I review my insurance policies?
We recommend annual policy reviews or whenever significant life changes occur to ensure continued adequate coverage.
Do you provide faith-based insurance solutions?
Our Mennonite values guide our approach, offering specialized church insurance programs and supporting faith-based organizations' unique needs.
Reviews (4)
Vanessa Rowe
Nov 21, 2021
Report
I am so glad I was recommended to Chris Minick for Home owners insurance! This was a first time purchase for me and his knowledge of the insurance business and friendliness made this a wonderful experience! He not only saved us two hundred a year on other quotes but made this quick and easy putting my mind at ease for our future! I highly recommend Yoder insurance company! Thank you again!
Yvonne Slaybaugh
Jun 05, 2021
Report
Chris Minick with Yoder Insurance in Hartville, OH helped me lower my car insurance rate. I had been trying to accomplish this for a year. He was timely in emailing me a comparison of my current policy and a new policy. The new policy was lower and he even lowered my current policy. During our correspondence I moved and needed renters insurance also. At this point we met to finalize the policies. He was courteous and took care of all my needs. I would recommend his services to anyone.
Lorene Skidmore
May 20, 2021
Report
Chris Minick is my new Agent and I cant begin to tell you what a great experience I had getting a very reasonable quote in a timely, professional manner! I saved $70 dollars a month by switching my Auto over to the insurance he recommended and got waaaay better coverage as well! If youre looking to get great auto coverage at a reasonable rate, then I highly recommend you give Chris a call!
Ehubbs
Apr 19, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Responsiveness,Value
Chris Minick at Yoder Insurance is very easy to talk to and always responded quickly. Great communication. I am a new homeowner and he made the insurance process painless for my home and auto. Highly recommend!
Chris Minick at Yoder Insurance is very easy to talk to and always responded quickly. Great communication. I am a new homeowner and he made the insurance process painless for my home and auto. Highly recommend!
