Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
29 Years
experience
Custom Jewelry Design & Restyling Chicago
Judith L Ansteth Jewelers represents decades of expertise in creating meaningful fine jewelry experiences. As a second-generation, family-owned business, we specialize in transforming personal stories into custom-designed engagement rings, wedding bands, and heirloom-quality pieces. Our Chicago-based workshop offers comprehensive services including jewelry restyling, diamond and gemstone selection, precision repairs, and professional appraisals by GIA-certified experts. With Andrea Mattei's dual mastery of graphic design and gemology, combined with Judith Arnell's pioneering industry contributions, we deliver personalized craftsmanship in a relaxed setting. Our commitment to quality is demonstrated through meticulous attention to detail in both one-of-a-kind inventory pieces and bespoke creations.

Clients benefit from our local manufacturing capabilities, transparent pricing, and extensive knowledge of both modern and antique jewelry techniques. Having served Chicagoland since 1997, our reputation for excellence is reflected in numerous client testimonials praising our patient guidance and beautiful results. We specialize in reimagining outdated jewelry into contemporary masterpieces while maintaining the sentimental value of original materials. Our multidisciplinary approach combines technical expertise with artistic vision to create wearable art that meets individual style and budget requirements.
Services
Custom designs Jewelry restyling Diamond selection Gemstone appraisal Precision repairs Hand engraving
Details
  • Year established: 1997
Highlights and features
  • 25+ years of custom jewelry design experience in Chicago
  • GIA-certified gemologists provide expert material selection
  • Complete in-house design and manufacturing process
  • Specialists in transforming heirloom jewelry into modern designs
  • Proven track record of complex custom projects completed ahead of schedule
Associations and certifications
  • GIA
  • JBAR
What people say
Beyond her expectations Breathtaking diamond collection Smooth and fun process Expertise and artistry Perfect engagement ring
Services
Custom designs
Transform your vision into wearable art through our comprehensive custom design process. Clients collaborate directly with GIA-certified designers to create one-of-a-kind engagement rings, wedding bands, and statement pieces. Our Chicago-based artisans use computer-aided design and traditional techniques to ensure perfect execution of every detail from material selection to intricate settings.
Jewelry restyling
Reimagine outdated or unused jewelry into contemporary masterpieces while preserving sentimental value. Our experts repurpose metals and stones from existing pieces into modern designs that reflect current style preferences. This service includes careful assessment of materials and creative options for transforming family heirlooms into wearable treasures.
Diamond selection
Access our extensive inventory of ethically sourced diamonds and colored gemstones through guided selection sessions. Clients receive expert advice on cut, clarity, and setting options tailored to their design needs and budget. Our GIA-qualified staff ensures optimal value and quality in every stone selection for custom or inventory pieces.
Gemstone appraisal
Obtain accurate jewelry valuations for insurance, estate planning, or fair market purposes from our JBAR-certified graduate gemologist. The appraisal process includes detailed analysis of materials, craftsmanship, and current market values. We provide comprehensive documentation meeting insurance industry standards for all types of fine jewelry.
Precision repairs
Restore damaged or worn jewelry to like-new condition through expert repair services. Our Chicago workshop handles everything from ring sizing and prong retipping to complex antique restoration. Using both modern technology and traditional techniques, we ensure structural integrity while maintaining original design aesthetics for both modern and vintage pieces.
People
Andrea Mattei
Lead Designer & GIA Graduate Gemologist
Andrea has specialized in custom jewelry design since 1997, combining her GIA Graduate Gemology credentials with a graphic design master's degree. She serves as creative director for custom projects and provides expert appraisal services while maintaining hands-on involvement in client consultations.
Judith Arnell
Founder & Master Craftsman
Judith established the business in 1972 and continues to guide its heritage of excellence. As a founder of the Women's Jewelry Association Midwest Chapter, she brings decades of manufacturing expertise and industry leadership to the company's commitment to quality craftsmanship.
Questions
Can you create a custom ring from my own design sketches?
Yes, we welcome client design input and use advanced software to transform sketches into detailed 3D models. Our designers will work with your concepts to create precise renderings before production begins.
Do you work with lab-grown diamonds and alternative materials?
We offer both lab-grown and natural diamonds, as well as various metal options including recycled gold and platinum. Our designers help clients select materials that balance quality, sustainability, and budget requirements.
How long does custom jewelry creation typically take?
Most custom projects take 4-8 weeks depending on complexity. We provide detailed timelines during design consultation and offer expedited options when possible, with some projects completed ahead of schedule.
Can you modify existing jewelry while preserving its sentimental value?
Our restyling service specializes in reimagining heirloom pieces while maintaining their emotional significance. We create modern designs that incorporate original materials and maintain the stories behind them.
Do you provide jewelry maintenance and repair services?
Yes, our Chicago workshop offers comprehensive repair services including sizing, stone replacement, and antique restoration using both traditional techniques and modern technology for various jewelry types.
Are your appraisals accepted by insurance companies?
Our appraisals performed by JBAR-certified gemologists meet insurance industry standards. We provide detailed documentation including digital images and specifications to ensure proper coverage for your fine jewelry.
Reviews (6)
William Black
Oct 02, 2020 Report
Andrea is Absolutely Amazing! After Shopping numerous jewelers and doing countless hours of research I still felt like I hadn't found someone who could really bring my ideas to life. I didn't just want a ring from "Jarred", I wanted something unique and Special. Thankfully I was Referred to Andrea by my Fiances cousin. What a breath of fresh Air! Andrea was a joy to work with from start to finish.

She really takes the time to listen and understand what your hoping to achieve in your rings design. You can tell from the moment you meet her she is very passionate about her work and loves to create
Samantha Harris
Jan 07, 2020 Report
My engagement ring is from Judith Ansteth jewelers and it is amazing! I get compliments on it all the time and how great the quality is! We just got our wedding bands and we love them!! Mine is amazing! Its exactly what I wanted and turned out just like I hoped!! I would never go anywhere else for my jewelry! Thank you so much!!
Page Wagley
Dec 31, 2019 Report
Wonderful experience working with Andrea. My family has known her for years. I knew when I got engaged that Id ask Andrea to build it. She worked with me to understand my vision and budget. She knows her business, and is able to source stones and build something unique. Im very pleased with my ring and appreciate the care Andrea put into it. Would highly recommend.
Meghan Haggerty
Oct 18, 2019 Report
Andrea was phenomenal to work with. I brought in a picture of my dream ring and she showed us multiple options based on our budget and my dream design. Her diamond collection is breathtaking. You can not go wrong with what Judith Ansteth Jewlers has to offer. Thank you again Andrea for making my engagement ring so special. Anyone who is looking for a unique/custom ring, I can confidently say you can trust Andrea 100% with designing and crafting your ring. She killed it! :)
Scott S.
Jan 01, 2019 Report
I was referred to Judith Ansteth Jewelers by a friend as I was ready to propose to my girlfriend, and what a fantastic referral it was. From the moment I called, it was easy to tell that Andrea really cared that I ended up with the perfect ring for my now-fiance! She really wanted to know my preferences while also offering guidance and having me look at different cuts of diamonds when I visited. We narrowed down the choices, of which there were several good ones, and the end result was absolutely spectacular. My fiance LOVES it and she's received numerous compliments including several from complete
David S.
Oct 03, 2018 Report
I visited about 10 jewelers before finding not only the perfect ring but also the best experience.
Honest, thoughtful, thorough, helpful and professional are the main things that set them apart by miles. I felt that my needs were the most important part of the experience and felt WELL taken care of which is what you want such an important time, buying an engagement ring.
Im going back for many more items for sure!