Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Go-To Italian Restaurant for Fresh NY-Style Pizza in Edgewater, FL
Established in 1959, Alberto's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant is a family-owned Italian restaurant rooted in tradition, quality, and exceptional service. We specialize in hand-tossed New York-style pizza made daily with fresh dough, thin crusts, and premium ingredients, preserving a recipe perfected over generations. Our menu features authentic Italian dishes including pasta, hoagies, stromboli, calzones, and salads, alongside American favorites. Committed to a dining experience that blends tradition with a casual, welcoming atmosphere, we serve guests in Edgewater, Florida, and cater events with customized menus.

Our signature Pizza Challenge, a two-person 28-minute 28-inch cheese pizza contest, offers winners a free meal and $100 cash. Recognized as the Best Italian Restaurant for 15 consecutive years by The News-Journal Southeast Volusia, we prioritize guest satisfaction through quality ingredients and a dedication to hospitality that honors our founder Alberto Salvo's original vision.
Services
NY-style pizza Italian dishes Catering Pizza Challenge Dine-in Takeout Delivery Lunch specials Hoagies Salads
Details
  • Year established: 1959
Highlights and features
  • We serve fresh New York-style pizza made daily with hand-tossed thin crusts.
  • Our family tradition since 1959 ensures authentic Italian recipes perfected over generations.
  • Catering services provide customized menus for events of all sizes.
  • The Pizza Challenge offers a unique dining experience with prizes for winners.
  • Recognized as Edgewater's best Italian restaurant for 15 consecutive years.
What people say
Best Italian Restaurant Authentic NY-style pizza Great service Family-friendly atmosphere Excellent pasta
Services
NY-style pizza
Our hand-tossed New York-style pizza features fresh, daily-made dough and thin crusts, topped with premium ingredients. This iconic dish, rooted in a 1959 tradition, delivers the authentic taste of NYC with every slice. Ideal for casual dining or takeout, it combines quality and heritage.
Italian dishes
Authentic Italian meals include housemade pasta, hoagies, stromboli, calzones, and salads. Each dish uses time-honored recipes and quality ingredients to reflect Italy's culinary heritage. Perfect for families or individuals seeking traditional flavors in a relaxed setting.
Catering
Customized catering services for events of all sizes, offering menus tailored to client needs. From casual gatherings to formal affairs, our Italian specialties provide a memorable dining experience. Contact us for pricing and menu options.
Pizza Challenge
Test your appetite with the legendary Pizza Challenge: two people eat a 28-inch cheese pizza in 28 minutes. Winners receive the pizza free plus $100. Call ahead to scheduleideal for adventurous diners and special occasions.
Delivery
Enjoy our Italian favorites delivered through DoorDash and Uber Eats. The menu includes signature pizzas and dishes, with delivery options for lunch, dinner, or late-night cravings. Accessible via apps for convenience.
Questions
What makes Alberto's pizza unique?
Our pizza uses fresh dough made daily and a thin crust hand-tossed to New York-style perfection, rooted in a 1959 family recipe.
Does Alberto's offer catering services?
Yes, we provide customized catering for events with Italian specialties. Contact us directly for menus and pricing.
What is the Pizza Challenge?
The Pizza Challenge requires two people to eat a 28-inch cheese pizza in 28 minutes. Winners earn it free plus $100.
What are Alberto's operating hours?
We are open Tuesday-Thursday 11 AM-9 PM, Friday-Saturday 11 AM-10 PM, and Sunday 11 AM-9 PM. Closed Mondays.
How can I order delivery from Alberto's?
Use DoorDash or Uber Eats apps to order delivery. Our menu is available online for lunch, dinner, or late-night cravings.
Is Alberto's suitable for families?
Yes, our casual atmosphere and diverse menu cater to all ages, making it ideal for family gatherings and meals.
Reviews (4)
Michelle Goodrich
Dec 13, 2021 Report
We had a large party for dinner after our Daughter's wedding. Everything was wonderful. The food was perfect, pizza and pasta. The service was fast, friendly and accurate. We will definitely be back on our next visit to New Smyrna Beach. 6 out of 5 Stars!
Tabie Kelley
Dec 10, 2021 Report
Inside dining or pickup either way never a bad experience there. Food is always delicious and hot off the press!! The Garlic knots are 1000% delicious!! Pizza is always good! Greek Salads are legit!
Laci Phipps
Nov 14, 2021 Report
Service was great!!! Everything we ordered was amazing!!!! Definitely a place I would go back too when I come back down for vacation again
Summer Layshock
Nov 13, 2021 Report
Literally the best garlic knots I have ever tasted. And the Greek salads omg can’t even explain, god sent