Business Details
33 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Winter Garden, FL
Founded in 1993, Abney Insurance has proudly served Florida residents for over three decades. As a family-owned and operated agency, we prioritize personalized service and customer satisfaction, offering a comprehensive range of insurance products including auto, home, motorcycle, recreational vehicle, boat, golf cart, business, umbrella, and life insurance. Our team of licensed professionals is dedicated to helping clients find the right coverage at competitive rates by partnering with multiple top-rated carriers. Unlike impersonal online platforms, we provide tailored solutions through direct consultation, ensuring each client's unique needs are met. Our commitment to excellence is reflected in our long-standing relationships with both clients and industry partners.We pride ourselves on maintaining a responsive, trustworthy approach that fosters lasting trust within our community. With offices in Winter Garden, FL, we serve clients across the Sunshine State, combining local expertise with nationwide carrier partnerships. Our staff's extensive qualifications, including designations like ChFC, CLU, and ARM, demonstrate our dedication to professional excellence. By focusing on education and transparency, we empower clients to make informed decisions about their financial protection. Our mission remains unchanged since our founding: to provide Floridians with comprehensive insurance solutions backed by personalized service and industry-leading expertise.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Flood Insurance
RV Insurance
Boat Insurance
Classic Car Insurance
Renters Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1993
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1993 with 31+ years of local insurance expertise
- Represents multiple A-rated insurance carriers for optimal coverage options
- Personalized service through licensed professionals with industry designations
- Specializes in Florida-specific insurance needs including flood protection
- Offers comprehensive coverage for specialty vehicles and properties
Associations and certifications
- A.M. Best
- Demotech
Services
Auto Insurance
Protect your vehicle and financial future with customizable auto insurance policies. We offer liability, collision, comprehensive, and specialty coverage options for standard vehicles and classic cars. Our experienced agents help Florida drivers find competitive rates while ensuring adequate protection for their specific needs and driving history.
Home Insurance
Safeguard your most valuable asset with tailored home insurance solutions. We provide coverage for structural damage, personal belongings, and liability protection. Our policies can be customized with additional riders for unique needs, including flood insurance and coverage for specialty homes like condominiums and rental properties.
Life Insurance
Secure your family's future with term and permanent life insurance options. Our policies provide financial protection for dependents, covering final expenses, income replacement, and legacy planning. We offer competitive rates through multiple carriers to match different budgetary and long-term financial goals.
Motorcycle Insurance
Specialized protection for motorcycle enthusiasts that covers collision damage, theft, and liability. Our policies accommodate various bike types and riding styles while meeting Florida's legal requirements. We offer customizable options for custom builds, frequent riders, and seasonal motorcycle owners.
Umbrella Insurance
Enhance your existing liability coverage with umbrella insurance policies. These plans provide additional financial protection against major claims that exceed standard policy limits. Ideal for homeowners, drivers, and business owners seeking comprehensive risk management solutions for unexpected catastrophic events.
People
Paula Abney
Owner
With over 30 years in the insurance industry, Paula Abney leads our family-owned agency as a Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) and holds Chartered Financial Consultant (ChFC) and Chartered Life Underwriter (CLU) designations.
Tyler Abney
Personal Lines Agent
Specializing in personal insurance solutions, Tyler Abney brings extensive product knowledge to help clients protect their homes, vehicles, and families with customized coverage options tailored to individual risk profiles.
Aaron Abney
Licensed Agent
Licensed in both personal and commercial lines, Aaron Abney assists clients with comprehensive insurance planning, focusing on life insurance products and business risk management solutions for Florida entrepreneurs.
Brandon Abney
Commercial Lines Specialist
Handling business insurance needs across industries, Brandon Abney provides specialized coverage solutions for commercial properties, liability protection, and risk management strategies for Florida businesses.
Monica Thilmony
Customer Service Representative
Supporting our client-focused approach, Monica Thilmony ensures smooth policy administration and claims assistance, maintaining our commitment to responsive service throughout the insurance lifecycle.
Questions
What types of insurance does Abney Insurance offer?
We provide auto, home, life, motorcycle, RV, boat, flood, umbrella, condo, renters, classic car, and commercial insurance policies tailored to Florida residents' needs.
How can I get a personalized insurance quote?
Contact our Winter Garden office directly at 407-877-6110 or use our online comparative quoting form to receive customized coverage options from multiple top-rated carriers.
Do you offer insurance for specialty vehicles?
Yes, we specialize in coverage for classic cars, motorcycles, boats, golf carts, and recreational vehicles with tailored protection plans through specialty insurance carriers.
Are your insurance agents licensed and qualified?
Our team includes licensed professionals with industry designations like ChFC, CLU, and ARM, ensuring expert guidance for all personal and commercial insurance needs.
How does Abney Insurance handle claims assistance?
We partner with top-rated carriers that provide direct claims filing through their websites or dedicated customer service lines while offering ongoing support throughout the process.
Can renters obtain insurance coverage through your agency?
Yes, we offer renters insurance policies that protect personal belongings and provide liability coverage for apartment and condominium tenants across Florida.
Reviews (4)
Mike Morgan
May 24, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
All I can say is WOW! Their new office is fantastic. Monica Thilmony has helped me find the right insurance plan I needed.
All I can say is WOW! Their new office is fantastic. Monica Thilmony has helped me find the right insurance plan I needed.
Dj G.
Mar 31, 2021
Report
One of the best insurance brokers around. I've do e business with them for over 20 years. The Abney's are fantastic.
Colton Allen
Nov 27, 2020
Report
I moved down to FL about 2 years ago and was connected with Monica at Abner for my car insurance switch. She has been an extremely reliable agent and has gone above and beyond helping me in the past from when someone ran into my car and knocked off my bumper to just a year later when I needed to switch vehicles on my policy. I would recommend Monica, and Abner, to any of my friends because of my experience.
Linda Fry
Aug 11, 2019
Report
Friendly, professional service, and always willing to answer questions and be sure you understand your policy.
