Business Details
Experience Fresh Seafood & Steaks in Edgartown
Atlantic Fish & Chop House, located in Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, is a premier dining destination renowned for its elegant yet approachable cuisine. Our Executive Chef curates a menu featuring the freshest wild-caught seafood, including island oysters, whole grilled Branzino, and USDA prime Certified Angus Beef, complemented by an extensive wine list and crafted cocktails. The 200-seat, multi-level venue offers versatile indoor and outdoor dining spaces, creating a vibrant atmosphere for casual meals, private events, and late-night gatherings. We prioritize sourcing high-quality ingredients to deliver dishes that highlight seasonal flavors while maintaining a commitment to exceptional service through our professional and friendly staff.Open seasonally with varied hours, we cater to both spontaneous visits and curated private events, ensuring every guest experiences the unique charm of Martha's Vineyard through our culinary offerings. Our dedication to hospitality extends to hosting weddings, corporate functions, and special celebrations, with testimonials praising our attention to detail and ability to create memorable occasions. As a locally rooted establishment, we blend coastal New England charm with modern sophistication, inviting guests to savor fresh, thoughtfully prepared meals against a backdrop of stunning waterfront views.
Services
Seafood Dishes
Prime Steaks
Private Events
Cocktail Bar
Wine Selection
Highlights and features
- We offer the freshest wild-caught seafood and premium steaks sourced for quality.
- Our multi-level venue provides versatile dining spaces with scenic waterfront views.
- Professional staff ensures exceptional service for casual meals and private events.
- Seasonal menus highlight local ingredients and coastal culinary traditions.
- We host weddings, corporate events, and celebrations with tailored hospitality.
What people say
Fresh seafood
Scenic waterfront views
Attentive staff
Flawless events
Vibrant nightlife
Services
Seafood Dishes
Our seafood menu features wild-caught salmon, Mediterranean-style Branzino, and Dorado, prepared with seasonal ingredients to highlight natural flavors. Each dish emphasizes sustainability and quality, sourced daily to ensure peak freshness. Ideal for diners seeking coastal cuisine in an elegant yet relaxed setting.
Prime Steaks
We serve USDA prime Certified Angus Beef and Japanese A5 Kobe Steaks, grilled to perfection and paired with house-made sides. Our steaks cater to meat enthusiasts looking for premium cuts in a sophisticated dining environment. Complemented by a curated wine list, these dishes deliver a classic yet modern steakhouse experience.
Private Events
The venue accommodates private functions, including weddings, corporate retreats, and luncheons, with customizable menus and dedicated coordination. Testimonials praise our team's ability to execute seamless events with exceptional food and service. With indoor and outdoor spaces, we create memorable settings for celebrations of up to 200 guests.
Cocktail Bar
After 10 PM, our bar transforms into a lively venue with DJs, craft cocktails, and an extensive wine selection. The ambiance shifts to a festive, social atmosphere while maintaining the restaurant's upscale appeal. This offering caters to guests seeking evening entertainment alongside premium libations.
Wine Selection
An expansive wine list features varietals from renowned regions, carefully selected to pair with seafood and steak dishes. The collection includes both familiar favorites and unique finds, enhancing the dining experience through curated flavor profiles. Knowledgeable staff guide guests in choosing wines that complement their meals.
Questions
Does Atlantic Fish & Chop House accept dinner reservations?
We do not accept dinner reservations for regular dining but welcome walk-ins. Private events with 20+ guests can be reserved by contacting our event coordinator.
What are the restaurant's seasonal hours?
April: Open Wed-Sun, 12 PM-9 PM. May-September: Open Wed-Mon, 12 PM-9 PM. October: Open Wed-Sun, 12 PM-9 PM. Closed Tuesdays year-round.
What type of cuisine does the restaurant specialize in?
We specialize in fresh seafood and prime steaks, including wild-caught salmon, Branzino, USDA Certified Angus Beef, and Japanese A5 Kobe Steaks, with seasonal menus.
Can I host a private event at the venue?
Yes, we host weddings, corporate events, and private parties for 20+ guests, offering customizable menus, dedicated coordination, and multi-level event spaces with waterfront views.
Is there a dress code for dining or nightlife?
Smart casual attire is recommended for dining. Nightlife events after 10 PM maintain a sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere with no strict dress code.
Videos
Reviews (7)
Nickki D.
Oct 25, 2021
Report
October birthdays' family celebration! Friendly atmosphere and excellent food and service! Crackling pork shank was flavorful and moist and the slice of chocolate mousse cake fed 6 people! Couldn't ask for more!
Victoria Dubose-Briski
Oct 23, 2021
Report
Horrible service. My husband and I wanted to stop by for wine and appetizers around 5:30PM, as we had just finished shopping. The male host was very rude. It was a Wednesday evening and there were many tables open outside and at the bar. We asked for one outside and he stated we could only sit in the back of the restaurant on a couch. He was condescending and his tone was extremely abrasive. We immediately left. We do not recommend this restaurant due to the unpleasant service.
John M.
Sep 13, 2021
Report
We've been going to The Atlantic Restaurant ever since it opened and are growing increasingly disappointed. The last couple of times, menu items we selected were over-seasoned, especially with salt. But last evening was the worse. They have what was a wonderful bar, where people could enjoy each others' company. But now they limit the bar to meal only. It was deserted when we arrived (and left) but they insisted we had to go sit in a couch outside, all by ourselves. We ordered martinis, mine on the rocks. It obviously had been shaken with ice, instead of simply being poured over ice because it
Ana Roman-Gonzalez
Aug 21, 2021
Report
I was refused seating even though there were plenty of chairs available. I made it clear to the older gentleman serving as hostess that my husband and I would be consuming drinks and appetizers. He refused to let us sit at the bar.
Bill Yelenak
Jun 25, 2021
Report
This may be our favorite restaurant on the island, especially when you can get a seat outside overlooking Edgartown Harbor. Food is always excellent and prepared well. Had the Sirloin, gratin potatoes and lobster salad on a recent visit, and everything was delicious. One downside: Because it's good, it is often super busy and they don't take reservations, so we always try to be on the early side when dining here -- or be prepared for a lengthy wait!
Antonio Caban
Apr 15, 2021
Report
Food and scenery is picture perfect! We sat outside, right near the docks, which made for a great backdrop as the sun began to set. If you're looking for COVID safe dining, this is the right place as there are a number of seating options both indoor and out. Food and cocktails menu is varied - there's something for everyone - and the staff is friendly and accommodating.
P. S.
Oct 15, 2019
Report
Fresh and excellent foods and drink. The server was really nice. I dont know what ppl talked about in these reviews, but sometimes you could miss great foods on reading too many ppls opinions. I and my husband didnt see any rude servers at all. All customers were happy.