Business Details
16 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Lakewood, CO
Schey Insurance Agency has served the Lakewood, Colorado community for over a decade, building on decades of combined industry experience from our leadership team. As an independently owned and locally operated agency, we prioritize personalized service, helping individuals and businesses navigate insurance complexities with expert guidance. Our team of dedicated professionals works directly with clients to assess unique needs, compare policies from over 35 carriers, and deliver tailored coverage solutions. We maintain a client-first approach, emphasizing transparency, integrity, and long-term relationships.With deep roots in the local business community and active involvement in organizations like the West Metro Chamber and Westside Business Builders, we combine local market knowledge with national carrier resources. Our commitment extends beyond transactionswe aim to be trusted advisors, available 24/7 to assist with claims, policy adjustments, and risk management strategies. This philosophy has earned us recognition for outstanding service, including testimonials highlighting our responsiveness, cost-saving expertise, and compassionate support during critical moments.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Vehicle Policies
Property Policies
Business Policies
Details
- Year established: 2010
Highlights and features
- We offer over 40 years of combined insurance expertise from our leadership team.
- Our locally owned agency provides personalized service tailored to Colorado residents.
- We compare policies from 35+ carriers to find your optimal coverage-price balance.
- Our team maintains 24/7 availability for claims assistance and urgent needs.
- We prioritize long-term client relationships over transactional interactions.
What people say
Outstanding service
Saved me a HUGE amount
Highly responsive
Top-notch customer service
Perfect insurance offering
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions tailored to individual driving needs. Our services include policy comparison across 35+ carriers, coverage optimization for personal and commercial vehicles, and specialized policies for classic cars, motorcycles, and ride-sharing services. Our team ensures clients receive competitive rates while maintaining adequate protection against accidents, theft, and liability claims.
Home Insurance
Our home insurance services cover single-family homes, condos, and rental properties against common risks like fire, hail, and theft. We offer policy customization for new construction, vacation homes, and high-value item coverage. Our team specializes in helping clients understand policy details, secure appropriate rebuilding coverage, and navigate claims processes with personalized support.
Commercial Insurance
We provide tailored commercial insurance packages for businesses of all sizes. Our services include general liability, property coverage, workers' compensation, and specialized policies for directors/officers and non-profits. We help businesses assess risk exposure, compare carrier options, and maintain continuous operations through crisis situations with comprehensive protection strategies.
Vehicle Policies
Our vehicle insurance services cover diverse transportation needs beyond standard auto policies. This includes motorhomes, ATVs, snowmobiles, and classic car coverage. We specialize in finding niche market solutions while ensuring proper valuation and protection for unique vehicles, with expert guidance on policy terms and claim procedures.
Property Policies
We offer specialized property insurance for residential and commercial real estate investments. Services include coverage for long-term rentals, short-term vacation properties, and new construction projects. Our team helps property owners understand policy limitations, secure adequate rebuilding coverage, and manage risks associated with tenant occupancy and property management.
People
Taylor Davis
Owner
Taylor Davis leads the agency with entrepreneurial experience from family businesses in contracting and property management. Passionate about community development, Taylor serves on local business boards and focuses on creating impactful client relationships. Outside work, Taylor enjoys outdoor activities and plans to establish nonprofits for mustang rescue and small business support.
Sally Schey
Agent
With over 40 years in insurance, Sally founded the agency in 2010 after a 30-year career at a major carrier. A West Metro Chamber ambassador, she specializes in personalized coverage solutions. Sally prioritizes client education and maintains deep community ties through local business organizations, combining extensive experience with hands-on service approach.
Kelly Dent
Agent
Kelly provides personalized auto and home insurance solutions, emphasizing client education and advocacy. With a career built on trust and transparency, Kelly takes a customized approach to coverage while maintaining strong client relationships. Outside work, Kelly enjoys family time, travel, and outdoor activities that reinforce the importance of protecting valued assets.
Nancy
Agent
Nancy brings decades of insurance experience, having worked as both claims adjuster and agent. A Denver native with extensive industry knowledge, she maintains long-term client relationships through personalized service. Nancy enjoys gardening and reading, balancing professional expertise with community-focused insurance solutions for local residents.
Luna
Chief Canine Officer
Luna serves as office morale officer, providing emotional support through companionship and playful interactions. This energetic canine helps reduce workplace stress while welcoming visitors with friendly greetings. Luna's presence reflects the agency's commitment to work-life balance and creating a welcoming environment for both clients and staff.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, and commercial insurance policies, including specialized coverage for vehicles like motorcycles, classic cars, and business fleets.
How do you help clients find the best rates?
We compare policies across 35+ insurance carriers to find optimal coverage-price combinations tailored to each client's specific needs and risk profile.
Can you help with existing insurance policies?
Yes, we review current policies to identify coverage gaps or cost-saving opportunities, providing recommendations while respecting your existing carrier relationships.
What if I need assistance during a claim?
We provide 24/7 support for claim guidance, helping clients navigate the process with clear advice and advocacy to ensure fair and timely resolutions.
Do you serve businesses as well as individuals?
Yes, we offer commercial insurance packages including liability coverage, property protection, and specialized policies for business operations of all sizes.
How do you handle unique insurance needs?
We specialize in customized solutions for complex situations, including high-value home insurance, rental property coverage, and niche vehicle policies.
Reviews (4)
Stefan Magyar
Dec 07, 2020
Report
Whether you need personal or commercial insurance, there's nobody better to help you with your needs than Sally Schey at Schey Insurance. Since she's an independent agent, Sally can get you the best possible deal with the proper coverage. She set my daughter up with a renter's insurance policy; the process was easy and straightforward. The customer service at Schey Insurance is top notch and Sally truly cares about her customers. Give her a call when you have any insurance needs or questions!
Wendy Hanophy
Nov 26, 2020
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Responsiveness,Value
Sally has literally saved me thousands of dollars on my insurance! Currently we insure our home, autos, and business with Sally. Whenever we have a need, she is available to answer our questions and solve problems. I'm so thankful to have a great agent to rely on!
Sally has literally saved me thousands of dollars on my insurance! Currently we insure our home, autos, and business with Sally. Whenever we have a need, she is available to answer our questions and solve problems. I'm so thankful to have a great agent to rely on!
Wendy Lee Armstrong
Nov 05, 2020
Report
Sally has helped me combine my Automobile Insurance with my Home (Mortgage) Insurance to save me money. The master bedroom bathroom link water behind the vanity sink. The estimator that came over for the insurance company; He said, he didn't think my insurance would over the cost. Sally saw the pictures and made sure it gotten taken care off. Also, I've taken pictures of my cracked windshield on my car. The next day the windshield repair man was out to fix it. Go Sally . . Your the best!!!
Bobbi Reynolds
Sep 25, 2020
Report
We started using Schey Insurance based on the advice of other business owners who had worked with this agency for years. We ended up getting customized, better quality insurance for less money, and immediately decided to have Sally recommend the best coverage for our personal auto and home insurance. We are too busy to spend house researching and then wondering if we're going to get what we pay for. Sally is ON IT, and we highly recommend that you contact her to see if she can do the same for you and/or your business!