Business Details
49 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Trusted Insurance Services in Brookfield, WI
Established in 1977, Capital Insurance Agency of Wisconsin has built a legacy of trust and personalized service. Founded by Josef Schmidt as an independent agency operating from his home, we prioritized treating clients as family from day one. In 1988, Jeff Sladky joined the team, and by 1994 became principal owner, expanding operations to a dedicated office in Brookfield, WI, while preserving our core family-centric values. Our independence allows us to represent top-tier Midwest insurers, offering tailored solutions for personal and commercial needs.With over four decades of combined team experience, we deliver reliable coverage, competitive pricing, and unwavering support through claims resolution. Our reputation reflects our commitment to integrity, expertise, and community-focused service, ensuring every client receives the attention they deserve.
Services
Personal Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life & Health Insurance
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Renters Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Boat Insurance
Commercial Umbrella
Professional Liability
Details
- Year established: 1977
Highlights and features
- We offer over four decades of experience serving the Midwest insurance market
- Our independent agency model provides access to multiple top-tier insurers
- Family-oriented service with personalized policy recommendations
- Experienced agents maintain active industry licenses and ongoing education
- Comprehensive commercial coverage for niche industries like contractors and restaurants
What people say
Wonderful to work with
More coverage for less cost
Excited to continue business
Actual customer care
30 years of service
Services
Personal Insurance
Protect your family and possessions with customized insurance solutions. Our licensed agents assess individual needs to create comprehensive policies covering vehicles, homes, and valuable assets. We offer specialized coverage options including flood insurance, farm insurance, and collectibles protection while maintaining competitive pricing through multiple provider partnerships.
Commercial Insurance
Secure tailored insurance for contractors, retailers, restaurants, and specialty industries. We provide essential coverage including general liability, workers' compensation, commercial umbrella policies, and professional liability. Our expertise ensures comprehensive protection for property, operations, and employees while helping businesses navigate risk management requirements.
Life & Health Insurance
Plan for your future with customized life and health insurance solutions. Our agents help clients evaluate changing needs over time, offering individual and group policies, Medicare supplements, long-term care coverage, and disability insurance. We ensure adequate protection through both short-term and permanent coverage options for personal and family financial security.
Auto Insurance
Guarantee financial protection for personal and commercial vehicles. We provide comprehensive auto insurance policies covering collision, liability, and uninsured motorists while offering specialized coverage for motorcycles, boats, snowmobiles, and antique vehicles. Our independent agency status enables competitive rate comparisons across multiple insurers.
Homeowners Insurance
Safeguard residential properties with customized homeowners insurance. We offer traditional home coverage, condominium insurance, mobile home policies, and second-home protection. Our agents ensure comprehensive coverage for structural damage, personal property loss, and liability risks while providing flood insurance and other specialized endorsements.
People
Jeff Sladky
Owner/President
With 36 years of industry experience since joining in 1988, Jeff leads Capital Insurance Agency as President and sole owner. A Marquette University graduate, he previously worked at Equitable Life Insurance Company before developing the agency's family-oriented approach. Jeff maintains deep community ties through local sports and family activities.
Joe Sladky
Vice President
Joining in 2015, Joe brings expertise in personal and commercial insurance with prior experience at Badger Mutual Insurance. A UW-Eau Claire graduate, he coaches Marquette High Varsity Tennis and serves as a UW-Milwaukee MBA candidate. His family focus aligns with the agency's personal service philosophy.
Lisa Randazzo Clark
Commercial Lines CSR/Health Insurance CSR
Licensed in 2020, Lisa combines insurance expertise with prior small business ownership experience running a bridal shop. Her background in customer service and renovation projects enhances her ability to understand commercial clients' unique insurance needs while maintaining family priorities.
Rehan Dhala
Personal Lines Agent/CSR
Joining in 2025, Rehan holds a business management degree from Indiana University and pursues an MBA at UW-Milwaukee. His dual role as bartender and insurance agent provides diverse client interaction experience while maintaining active involvement in sports and community activities.
Mary Byington
Operations Manager/Personal Lines Agent
With 29 years of tenure since 1995, Mary combines customer service expertise developed over four decades. Her personalized approach to policyholder relationships extends to travel experiences and home renovation projects, reflecting the agency's commitment to understanding clients' personal circumstances.
Questions
What insurance products do you offer?
We provide personal insurance (auto, home, life), commercial coverage for businesses, and health insurance options. Specialized policies include boat, motorcycle, farm, and collectibles insurance.
How do you find competitive insurance rates?
As an independent agency, we compare policies from multiple top insurers to find the best combination of coverage and price tailored to your specific needs.
Can you help with business insurance needs?
Yes, we specialize in commercial insurance for contractors, restaurants, retail stores, and professional services, offering liability, property, and workers' compensation coverage.
What if I need emergency assistance?
For urgent insurance emergencies, please call us directly at (262) 781-8080 during regular business hours or use our after-hours appointment system.
Do you offer policy reviews?
We recommend annual policy reviews, especially after major life changes, to ensure your coverage continues meeting your evolving protection requirements.
