Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Cambridge, OH
Shafer Insurance Agency has been a cornerstone of community service since its founding in 1900. Our legacy of trust and personalized service spans four generations, rooted in the values established by John B. Shafer and continued under the leadership of current owner Mindy Eltringham, who brings 29 years of dedicated experience. As an independent agency, we prioritize client needs by offering tailored insurance solutions for personal and commercial clients across Ohio.Our team of licensed professionals combines deep local knowledge with expertise in property/casualty, life/health insurance, and commercial risk management to deliver comprehensive coverage. With a commitment to maintaining the Shafer name's integrity, we blend traditional service values with modern insurance practices to ensure clients receive both competitive pricing and unwavering support through every policy lifecycle stage.
Services
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Farm Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1900
Highlights and features
- We offer 125 years of insurance expertise serving Ohio families and businesses
- Our independent agency status provides access to multiple carrier options
- Fourth-generation family ownership ensures consistent service values
- Team includes licensed agents with decades of combined industry experience
- Personalized approach combines traditional service with modern solutions
Services
Auto Insurance
We create customized auto insurance plans to protect your vehicle and driving needs. Coverage options include collision/comprehensive protection, liability coverage, road service, and lease/loan gap insurance. Our agents help drivers in Ohio find affordable policies that meet state requirements while providing comprehensive protection for personal and commercial vehicles.
Business Insurance
Our commercial insurance solutions protect businesses of all sizes across Ohio. We offer property insurance, general liability coverage, and commercial auto policies tailored to specific industry needs. From restaurants to car dealerships, our experienced team creates customized risk management packages that safeguard business assets and operations while ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements.
Farm Insurance
We provide specialized insurance for Ohio's agricultural community, covering hobby farms to commercial operations. Our policies protect against risks associated with farming equipment, livestock, and crop production. By partnering with top-rated agribusiness carriers, we deliver cost-effective solutions that protect farm assets while understanding the unique challenges faced by modern farmers in our region.
Home Insurance
Our homeowners insurance policies protect your largest investment with comprehensive coverage for dwellings, personal property, and liability protection. We also offer condo and renters insurance options across Ohio. Our agents work with clients to create customized policies that cover structural damage, personal belongings, and additional living expenses during covered losses while maintaining competitive pricing.
Life Insurance
We help Ohio residents secure their family's financial future through various life insurance products. Our solutions address common concerns about affordability and coverage needs while providing death benefit protection for dependents. Whether you're a young family, empty nester, or business owner, we offer policies that ensure financial security and help with estate planning, final expense coverage, and business succession planning.
People
Mindy Eltringham
Owner
With 29 years of experience, Mindy has led Shafer Insurance since 2020. She worked alongside John R. Shafer for 22 years, mastering all aspects of insurance services. Mindy maintains the agency's founding values while implementing modern insurance solutions for Ohio policyholders.
Jacilyn Cox
Licensed Agent
Jacilyn has served Ohio clients for 13 years with expertise in property/casualty and life/health insurance. As a notary, she provides additional document services while maintaining her insurance licensing credentials to better serve personal and commercial clients.
Shannon Shiflett
Licensed Agent
Shannon brings seven years of insurance experience to our team, specializing in personal lines coverage. Her knowledge of Ohio insurance regulations helps clients navigate policy options while maintaining the high service standards established by the Shafer family legacy.
Laura Walker
Licensed Agent
As our newest team member, Laura applies her insurance expertise to help clients find appropriate coverage solutions. With current licensing in all required categories, she represents the next generation of professionals continuing Shafer Insurance's tradition of personalized service.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Ohio residents from our Cambridge office, providing insurance solutions across the state for personal and commercial clients.
What insurance types do you offer?
We provide auto, home, farm, life, business insurance, and commercial bonds. Our independent agency offers coverage for personal valuables, recreational vehicles, and specialty commercial needs.
Are you available outside regular hours?
Our office is open Monday-Friday 8am-5pm. We offer evening and Saturday appointments for client convenience when scheduled in advance.
How long have you been in business?
Since 1900, we've provided continuous insurance services to Ohio communities, making us one of the state's longest-operating independent insurance agencies.
Can you help with policy reviews?
Yes, we welcome clients to visit our office for in-person policy reviews and premium payments to ensure your coverage meets current needs.
Reviews (2)
Dustin Mahrt
Dec 31, 2020
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
You know they are doing something right if they've been around for 120 years! Established in 1900. You get a certain level of integrity when you deal with an agency of this caliber. 10 out of 10, would recommend!
You know they are doing something right if they've been around for 120 years! Established in 1900. You get a certain level of integrity when you deal with an agency of this caliber. 10 out of 10, would recommend!
John Lewis
May 21, 2019
Report
Not enough praise for this insurance agency! Did a fantastic job. Very helpful and willing to work with me even though I wasnt able to come to the office. Thanks again!
