Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Wisconsin Insurance Partner Since 1975
Since 1975, Colonial Insurance has been a trusted provider of comprehensive insurance solutions in Wisconsin. As a proud member of the Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin, we leverage over four decades of experience and partnerships with leading carriers to deliver personalized coverage. Our team of seasoned professionals, including advisors with 45+ years of combined industry experience, specializes in tailoring insurance products to meet individual and business needs.We maintain a 97% client retention rate through our commitment to exceptional service, transparent communication, and competitive pricing. Our locally owned agency serves clients with a deep understanding of regional risk exposures while maintaining national industry standards.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Renters Insurance
Condo Insurance
Commercial Property Insurance
Liability Insurance
Workers Compensation Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1975
Highlights and features
- We offer personalized insurance solutions tailored to your specific needs
- Our team has over 45 years of combined experience in the insurance industry
- We partner with multiple insurance carriers to ensure competitive pricing
- Available 24/7 for emergency claims assistance
- Locally owned and operated in Menomonee Falls since 1975
What people say
Exceptional service
Knowledgeable agents
Prompt assistance
Competitive rates
Excellent communication
Services
Home Insurance
Homeowners insurance protects against property damage, theft, and liability claims while providing financial security for one of life's greatest investments. We offer customized policies covering fire, weather damage, and personal belongings with flexible options for homeowners, renters, and condo owners. Our advisors help clients understand coverage limitations and ensure adequate protection for their specific living situation.
Business Insurance
Business insurance protects commercial operations from property damage, liability claims, and employee-related risks while ensuring business continuity in crisis situations. We provide comprehensive coverage including property, liability, workers compensation, and umbrella policies tailored to specific industries. Our advisors help businesses mitigate risks through customized insurance packages that adapt to evolving operational needs.
Life Insurance
Life insurance provides financial security for beneficiaries through death benefits that support dependents and cover final expenses while offering cash value accumulation in permanent policies. We offer term, whole, and universal life insurance options with flexible premium structures to accommodate different life stages and financial goals. Our advisors help clients choose between temporary and permanent coverage based on their long-term financial planning needs.
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance provides financial protection against vehicle damage, liability claims, and medical expenses while offering specialized coverage for various vehicle types. We offer comprehensive policies covering cars, trucks, motorcycles, ATVs, and RVs with options for liability, collision, and uninsured motorist protection. Our advisors help clients balance coverage needs with budgetary considerations while explaining state-specific requirements.
Umbrella Insurance
Umbrella insurance provides additional liability protection beyond standard policy limits while covering unexpected legal expenses and personal injury claims. We offer policies starting at $125 annually with coverage amounts up to $2 million that supplement homeowners, auto, and commercial policies. Our advisors help clients assess their risk exposure and determine appropriate coverage levels for asset protection.
People
Dan MacLeod
Principal Insurance Advisor
Dan MacLeod has been serving clients since 2012 after graduating from Edgewood College with a Business degree. Raised in Menomonee Falls, he brings generational insurance expertise and maintains a 97% client retention rate.
Jack Larsen
Personal and Commercial Insurance Advisor
Jack Larsen combines nine years of Fortune 50 leadership experience with local market knowledge. A UW-Whitewater graduate, he specializes in risk mitigation strategies for both personal and commercial insurance clients.
Don MacLeod
Personal and Commercial Insurance Advisor
Don MacLeod brings over 45 years of industry experience to client consultations. Recognized for cost-saving solutions and exceptional claims resolution, he remains actively involved in community charitable organizations.
Chris Heller
Personal Insurance Advisor
Chris Heller transitions from 36 years as an Appleton area math educator to insurance advising. He specializes in making complex policy details accessible and understandable to clients.
Julie Moll
Office Manager
Julie Moll has served as a licensed agent and office manager for over two decades. She handles policy updates, claims processing, and provides expert guidance to agency clients.
Questions
How do I get a personalized insurance quote?
Visit our office, call us, or start online for a customized quote within 24 hours.
What insurance types do you offer?
We provide home, auto, life, business, umbrella, renters, condo, and commercial insurance.
Why should I choose Colonial Insurance?
We combine 45+ years of local experience with multiple carrier options and 97% retention rates.
Can you help with insurance claims?
Yes, we provide 24/7 emergency support and guide clients through the claims process.
Do you serve businesses of all sizes?
We offer tailored commercial insurance for startups, established businesses, and fleet operations.
Reviews (4)
Mike Parish
Oct 17, 2021
Report
I am fairly ignorant when it comes to insurance matters. Its one of those things that as long as I have it, Im fine. When I was getting a new car, I was concerned about my coverage and making sure my vehicle was well protected. Dan McLeod helped me throughout the entire process. He found a policy that fit my needs and budget and made sure I understood what I was paying for. He also helped me cancel my previous vehicle and set up my new one. Im very thankful I had this experience and would tell anyone to work with Colonial.
Chad Donohoue
Feb 14, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
I can't say enough about this agency! They are extremely knowledgeable and most important, they are very trustworthy. They don't take advantage of you by making sure you are covered for what you need to be but they don't sell you what you don't need. Highly recommend!
I can't say enough about this agency! They are extremely knowledgeable and most important, they are very trustworthy. They don't take advantage of you by making sure you are covered for what you need to be but they don't sell you what you don't need. Highly recommend!
Cayla Donohoue
Oct 20, 2020
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
We were exceptionally happy with the service we received after talking with Dan. Not only do we feel we got the best rates, he was friendly professional and made us feel well taken care of. Thanks Dan!
We were exceptionally happy with the service we received after talking with Dan. Not only do we feel we got the best rates, he was friendly professional and made us feel well taken care of. Thanks Dan!
Ann
Jan 07, 2017
Report
We have been with Don and Colonial Insurance for over 25 years. He helped us out when our driving records were not so great and found us the best rates available. He has always gotten us the best rates and made recommendations on how to get even better rates. Will never leave them!
