Business Details
43 Years
experience
Legendary Breakfast, Lunch & Brunch in Northampton, MA
Established in 1983, Sylvester's Restaurant honors the legacy of Dr. Sylvester Graham by crafting fresh, scratch-made dishes rooted in sustainable practices. Our commitment to locally sourced ingredients from trusted partners like Mapleline Farm and The Country Hen ensures exceptional flavor in every meal. With a focus on homemade breads, organic produce, and seasonal specials, we have been a Northampton staple for legendary breakfast, lunch, and brunch.Our dedication to community sustainability and waste reduction through partnerships like CISA reflects our mission to serve both people and the planet. Though our doors closed in May 2022, our legacy continues through Roberto's, where our team upholds the same values in new ventures.
Services
Breakfast
Lunch
Bakery
Gluten-Free Options
Takeout
Details
- Year established: 1983
Highlights and features
- We use homemade ingredients without preservatives or additives in every dish
- Our menu features 85-90% locally sourced ingredients from trusted Western Massachusetts farms
- Pioneering sustainability through composting and partnerships since 1983
- Certified organic cage-free eggs from The Country Hen in Hubbardston
- Beloved local landmark with decades of breakfast and brunch expertise
Services
Breakfast Service
Daily breakfast featuring organic eggs, homemade breads, and locally sourced ingredients. Signature dishes include steel-cut oatmeal and corned beef hash prepared fresh each morning. Gluten-free options available for all menu items.
Bakery Products
In-house baked goods using traditional methods and local grains. Offers sourdough, whole wheat, and specialty breads like caraway rye. Pastries, cookies, and signature Graham Cracker S'mores made daily.
Lunch Service
Seasonal lunch options with farm-to-table ingredients. Features gourmet sandwiches, salads with house-made dressings, and daily specials. Available for dine-in or takeout with organic produce from regional farms.
Gluten-Free Dining
Comprehensive gluten-free menu across all meal times. Certified gluten-free preparation area ensures safety for allergy-conscious diners. All menu items have gluten-free alternatives available upon request.
Local Sourcing
85-90% ingredient sourcing from Western Massachusetts farms. Partners include Mapleline Farm for dairy and Thomas' Farm for goat cheese. Supports sustainable agriculture through CISA membership and waste reduction programs.
People
Peter St. Martin
Co-Owner
Co-founded Sylvester's Restaurant in 1983 with Maureen McGuinness. Championed scratch cooking and local sourcing for nearly four decades. Now continuing culinary innovation at Roberto's Restaurant since May 2022 closure.
Maureen McGuinness
Co-Owner
Led Sylvester's Restaurant kitchen operations from 1983 until closure in 2022. Maintained rigorous quality standards for homemade dishes using local ingredients. Now applying culinary expertise at Roberto's Restaurant in downtown Northampton.
Questions
What made Sylvester's Restaurant Restaurant unique?
Our commitment to scratch-made cooking using 85-90% locally sourced ingredients from Western Massachusetts farms created truly unique dining experiences
Are gift cards still valid?
Existing gift cards can be redeemed at Roberto's Restaurant starting July 2022, continuing our legacy in Northampton
What were your operating hours?
Thursdays-Fridays 7:30 AM-1:30 PM and Saturdays 7:30 AM-3:00 PM before our May 2022 closure
Did you offer online ordering?
Yes, we provided online ordering for contactless pickup before our permanent closure
Where are you located?
111 Pleasant Street, Northampton, MA 01060 - directly adjacent to the Chamber of Commerce
What happened to the business?
We permanently closed in May 2022 after 39 years, with our team now operating Roberto's Restaurant at the same location
Reviews (5)
Connie Skowron
Jan 03, 2022
Report
Never going back. It's like a cafeteria. I go out to eat I want to be waited on. Very unsanitary. Utensils out in the open anyone sneezing and it goes on the utensils. Not good at all. And you have to bus your own table. So no one sanitizes the tables. Have to get up and get your own refills. Really! Never going back ALL the other restaurants WAIT on you.
Donna Wang
Dec 30, 2021
Report
Mixed bag. Nice service, but my husband had the WORST pancakes he had ever had. Even our six year old wouldn't eat them (with maple syrup). My corned beef hash though was delicious, though I won't get it on cornbread next time- it's way to sweet for me. But nice atmosphere, and nice people that work there.
Nathan Greenhall
Dec 18, 2021
Report
This is one of those gems you are beyond happy to stumble upon. Wife and I are in town for a bedding and wanted to go out for food. Incredibly delicious and fairly priced. Would recommend and definitely would return.
Cristina O'Keefe
Nov 17, 2021
Report
Food was ok and the place was popping! They have a new system where you order online and they bring the order to you which I think it's cool. What baffled me was that they ask you to bus your own table. As a business, you can't rely on the customer to clean your place! That's a public health issue in my opinion. The table by us picked their dishes and left, and the hostess sat down a family on a dirty table, sugar and crumbs still there. Bit apparently if you leave a mug on the table, the server will clean it? The sign on the table stated it's to keep their awesome staff happy in regards of wage
C. Adams
Oct 12, 2021
Report
Great food! Many choices for breakfast! Order and pay at the counter. Nice clean dining area. Friendly staff!