Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining & BBQ Pizza in Memphis Since 1923
Founded in 1923 by Emil Coletta as the Suburban Ice Cream Company, our establishment transitioned to Italian cuisine after recognizing growing demand. We pioneered Memphis' first BBQ pizza in the 1950s when Emil's son Horest trained in Chicago, creating a signature dish that became a local icon and even a favorite of Elvis Presley. Now in our third generation of family ownership, we maintain two locations while preserving traditional recipes and techniques passed down through decades. Our catering division leverages over 75 years of experience to serve events ranging from intimate gatherings to large corporate functions.The private dining facility at our Appling location accommodates up to 100 guests with customizable menus and decor options. We maintain strict quality control through family oversight of daily operations at both locations. Our bulk takeout program offers restaurant-quality meals for immediate pickup, while our nationwide shipping partnership with Goldbelly extends our Memphis heritage to customers across America. The restaurant's longevity reflects our commitment to authentic Italian flavors combined with Southern hospitality.
Services
Italian Cuisine
BBQ Pizza
Catering Services
Private Dining
Bulk Take-Out
Nationwide Shipping
Event Catering
Banquet Facilities
Custom Menus
Wedding Catering
Details
- Year established: 1923
Highlights and features
- We offer 100 years of family-owned Italian culinary expertise
- Our catering team serves events with minimum 20-60 entrees
- Private dining rooms accommodate up to 100 guests with formal packages
- Signature BBQ pizza recipe perfected since 1952
- Nationwide shipping available through Goldbelly partnership
What people say
Amazing pizza
Best BBQ pizza
Awesome food and service
Incredible staff
Worth the drive
Services
Italian Cuisine
Our traditional Italian menu features house-made pasta, fresh seafood, and classic meat dishes prepared using recipes perfected over three generations. Each location maintains a warm, inviting atmosphere with attentive service. Diners enjoy signature items like shrimp Diane and eggplant parmesan alongside regional specialties.
BBQ Pizza
Invented in 1952, our BBQ pizza combines Chicago-style pizza techniques with Memphis barbecue traditions. The unique recipe features smoked meats and tangy sauce atop hand-tossed dough. This local favorite remains unchanged since its creation and ships nationwide through our Goldbelly partnership.
Catering Services
We provide full-service catering for events from 20 to 100 guests with customizable menus and formal presentation. Our 75+ years of experience includes weddings, corporate events, and family reunions. Services include setup, serving staff, and premium tableware options for an additional fee.
Private Dining
The Appling location offers two private rooms accommodating 50-100 guests with flexible seating arrangements. Both spaces feature formal dining packages including linen tableware, centerpieces, and custom menus. Minimum spending requirements apply for room reservations and event catering.
Bulk Take-Out
Pre-packaged meal options serve 5-24 people with classic dishes like lasagna, chicken alfredo, and shrimp diane. Orders require minimum quantities and must be placed in advance. Hot entrees and prepared sides maintain restaurant quality for immediate serving or reheating.
People
Jerry Coletta
Owner/Operator
Third-generation restaurant leader maintaining family traditions at the South Parkway location since 1994. Oversees daily operations and menu consistency across both locations while preserving original recipes.
Diane Coletta
Co-Owner
Active partner in daily management at South Parkway location. Coordinates staff training and maintains quality control standards established by the founding generation. Ensures consistent customer service across both Memphis locations.
Lisa Coletta
Location Manager
Second-generation manager at Appling Road location with 25+ years of operational experience. Oversees catering services and private event coordination while maintaining family culinary traditions in menu preparation.
Stephen Coletta
Operations Director
Responsible for logistics and supply chain management across both locations. Implements modern efficiency improvements while maintaining original preparation methods for signature dishes like BBQ pizza.
Kristina Coletta
Event Coordinator
Manages private dining bookings and large catering events. Coordinates formal event packages including room setup, menu customization, and premium service options for corporate and social functions.
Questions
What makes your BBQ pizza unique?
Our signature BBQ pizza combines Chicago-style pizza techniques with Memphis barbecue traditions, featuring smoked meats and tangy sauce on hand-tossed dough since 1952.
Do you cater events outside Memphis?
We cater local Memphis events directly and offer nationwide shipping through Goldbelly for individual meals, but currently don't provide catering services outside the Memphis area.
What private dining options are available?
Our Appling location offers two private rooms accommodating 50-100 guests with customizable menus, formal table settings, and event coordination services for social and corporate functions.
Can I order takeout for immediate pickup?
Yes, we offer bulk takeout options available for same-day pickup at Appling location, with minimum order quantities required for pre-prepared meals serving 5-24 people.
How do I book a private event?
Contact our Appling location directly at 901-383-1122 to discuss private dining options, including room availability, menu customization, and event requirements for groups of 20+ guests.
Are gift cards available?
Physical gift cards in any denomination are available for purchase at both S. Parkway and Appling locations, with no digital gift card option currently offered.
Reviews (4)
Bill Miller
Jan 30, 2022
Report
The food was great as always and the price was awesome for everything we had to eat and drink. Customer service is outstanding with a beautiful clean place to eat. Thanks for the great manicotti..
Sean Lovejoy
Jan 09, 2022
Report
Good food, great atmosphere. Take out was a little slow due to a busy night and the pizza wasnt quite hot when it finally made it to the to go counter, but still delicious.
Sharla Carsley
Dec 26, 2021
Report
Horest Coletta would be absolutely ashamed at how awful his food has gotten. First time diner with my work crew and let me tell you… I’m 100% positive that McDonalds could do a better job at Italian food. I mean we had about 50 people in a party room. I had to ask for a high chair. To go cups for kids but the kids didn’t fit. I ordered BBQ pizza which was absolutely awful. Meat was dried out and tasteless. No cheese at all. Barely any ice in our drinks. My husband ordered a meat pizza and he, who eats practically everything, even said it was bland and chewy. How in gods green
Danita Zelinski
Dec 12, 2021
Report
Their thousand island dressing is one of my FAVORITE dressings ever! I can eat a couple of pieces of their pizza and I am full!! Spaghetti sauce reminds me of my mom’s. Love their meatballs. We had waiter, Edward, great!