Business Details
11 Years
experience
Custom Engagement Rings & Fine Jewelry in Denver & Austin
The Diamond Reserve is a luxury private jeweler specializing in custom engagement rings, bridal jewelry, and fine diamond collections. Founded in 2015, we operate in Denver and Austin, offering personalized, appointment-only services that prioritize education, transparency, and craftsmanship. Our team of diamond experts provides one-on-one consultations to guide clients through selecting and designing timeless pieces that reflect their unique stories and values. With a commitment to local communities and ethical sourcing, we ensure every client receives a seamless, stress-free experience backed by decades of combined industry expertise.
Services
Custom Engagement Rings
Bridal Jewelry
Diamond Education
Heirloom Redesign
Fine Jewelry Repair
Details
- Year established: 2015
Highlights and features
- We offer personalized, appointment-only consultations with diamond experts.
- Our team specializes in certified natural and lab-grown diamonds.
- Handcrafted locally in Colorado and Texas with ethical sourcing.
- We provide transparent education on diamond selection and pricing.
- Proven track record with 3,000+ satisfied clients since 2015.
What people say
Amazing experience
Seamless process
Stunning designs
Expert guidance
10/10 recommend
Services
Custom Engagement Rings
Create one-of-a-kind engagement rings tailored to your preferences. Our experts guide you through selecting certified diamonds and designing unique settings. Perfect for those seeking personalized, ethically sourced jewelry that reflects their love story.
Bridal Jewelry
Elegant bridal collections including wedding bands and ceremony-ready pieces. We craft matching sets that complement engagement rings. Ideal for couples wanting cohesive, handcrafted designs with expert styling advice.
Diamond Education
Comprehensive guidance on diamond selection, including the 4 Cs and ethical sourcing. Our team demystifies pricing and quality factors. Ensures informed decisions for confident, value-driven purchases.
Heirloom Redesign
Transform family heirlooms into modern, wearable art. We preserve sentimental value while updating designs. Perfect for revitalizing outdated pieces into timeless, personalized jewelry.
Fine Jewelry Repair
Professional repair and restoration services for all fine jewelry. Our artisans handle resizing, cleaning, and damage restoration. Maintains the beauty and longevity of cherished pieces.
People
Kaeleigh Testwuide
Founder & Diamond Expert
Kaeleigh founded The Diamond Reserve in 2015 after a decade in diamond brokerage. She rebranded the company into a female-led jeweler, prioritizing integrity and personalized service. With 3,000+ clients, she ensures every piece reflects love stories and local craftsmanship.
Erin Kurtz
Director of Operations
Erin joined in 2016, implementing customer service standards and business strategies. She shifted perspectives on diamonds being elitist, focusing on storytelling through custom designs. Leads the Austin team with a warm, intentional approach.
Sabrina Jandro
Sales Manager
Sabrina brings 3+ years of diamond industry experience, specializing in trend-savvy engagement rings. A Colorado native, she combines local knowledge with modern design expertise. Known for her loyalty, client-focused guidance, and community engagement.
Kaitlin Rathkamp
Diamond & Jewelry Design Expert
Kaitlin blends mindfulness and creativity from her yoga background into jewelry design. She helps couples find stones that capture their love stories. Her artistic vision and travel-inspired aesthetics enrich The Diamond Reserve's offerings.
Lauren Schellenberg
Diamond & Jewelry Design Expert
Lauren leverages her small-town roots and family business experience to connect with clients. She specializes in storytelling through jewelry and outdoor-inspired designs. Her warmth and attention to detail create memorable client experiences.
Questions
What services does The The Diamond Reserve offer?
We specialize in custom engagement rings, bridal jewelry, diamond education, heirloom redesign, and fine jewelry repair. All services include personalized consultations with diamond experts.
Are your diamonds certified?
Yes, we offer both GIA-certified natural diamonds and lab-grown options. Our team educates clients on the 4 Cs and ethical sourcing practices.
Do you have retail locations?
We operate by appointment only in Denver (Cherry Creek North, 16th Street) and Austin. This ensures privacy and personalized attention for every client.
How long does the custom jewelry process take?
Most custom pieces take 4-6 weeks. The process includes education, diamond selection, design collaboration, and handcrafting by local artisans.
Can I redesign existing jewelry?
Yes, our heirloom redesign service transforms family pieces into modern designs. We preserve sentimental value while updating aesthetics to create wearable art.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, bank transfers, and offer financing options. Specific details are discussed during your personalized consultation.
Reviews (7)
Rebecca Kling
Dec 24, 2021
Report
My Fianc and I worked with The Diamond Reserve for both my engagement ring and our wedding bands. They are so knowledgeable, kind, and very patient. Erin made the wedding band buying process so easy and was willing to meet with me multiple times while I was making my decision. We will definitely be working with them again in the future!
Marc Blumenthal
Dec 14, 2021
Report
One of the most significant purchases of our life. The journey to design the symbol of our union brought us to Kaeleigh and Erin at The Diamond Reserve. We are so grateful for the knowledge, expertise, and care delivered by this company. Everything from quality, communication, and pricing was above and beyond any other company we interacted with while engagement ring shopping. We will be using The Diamond Reserve again and have been spreading the word to our family and friends. What an exemplary business here in Denver Colorado.
Jane McDonald
Dec 14, 2021
Report
Kaleigh & Erin brought my ring dreams to life! Beautiful office with knowledgeable & friendly staff. I highly recommend for any custom jewelry needs.
Abbey Drevline
Dec 03, 2021
Report
Timeless, elegant, and personable. The Diamond Reserve took my lifetime vision of my engagement ring and turned my dream into a reality. Not a day goes by that I dont look at my ring and admire every detail that was put into it. I also had such a great experience with Erin and picking out our wedding bands!! The whole team is amazing and I highly recommended!
Sarah Maslo
Nov 26, 2021
Report
Working with the Diamond Reserve for both my engagement ring and wedding band was a fantastic decision. I wanted a small, simple, lab-grown gemstone ring and they were so respectful of that wish. They designed a set that really matches my personality; I love both my engagement ring and wedding band. Their work is beautiful, and I'd absolutely recommend them to anyone searching for an engagement ring.
Alexandra Hoffman
Nov 03, 2021
Report
We loved working with Erin on designing my engagement ring, so we came back to design our wedding bands with her too! Erin was always so responsive and was able to meet with us during the weekday evenings which was so convenient. Their turnaround times are quick, and the prices for custom rings were lower than what we saw at other jewelry stores for stock settings and wedding bands. Highly, highly recommend!!
Matthew Katzman
Oct 06, 2021
Report
We worked with Erin at the Diamond Reserve for both the engagement ring and wedding bands. What a spectacular experience. If you need a custom ring in Denver and high quality diamonds, look no further than the Diamond Reserve. Erin showed great attention to detail when helping customize our rings and was super transparent and respectful of our budget. When we approached with a unique and customized request for a wedding band, the team at the Diamond Reserve was eager to make it happen! Erin was responsive, kind and helped us enjoy this unique experience. We loved working with them and would be