Business Details
Wisconsin Cheese Curds & Artisan Cheeses in Cashton, WI
Established in the heart of the Amish community in Southwestern Wisconsin, Old Country Cheese has built a reputation for crafting premium dairy products using traditional methods. Our facility processes 120,000 pounds of fresh milk daily from over 230 local Amish producers across Cashton, Hillsboro, Tomah, and surrounding regions. We specialize in a wide array of cheeses including world-famous Muenster cheese curds, aged cheddars, and specialty varieties like juusto baked cheese. Our commitment to quality extends beyond dairy, offering Amish-made crafts, candies, and maple syrups that reflect the heritage of our community. With decades of experience in artisan cheese production, we combine time-honored techniques with modern food safety standards to deliver exceptional products.Our physical store in Cashton provides year-round in-person shopping, while our online platform offers convenient access to our full product catalog. We maintain strict quality control throughout our production process, ensuring every item meets our high standards for flavor and freshness. Our team takes pride in preserving Amish traditions while adapting to contemporary consumer needs through product innovation and customer service excellence. This dedication to authenticity and quality has made us a trusted name in Wisconsin cheese production and distribution.
Services
Muenster Cheese
Cheddar Cheese
Cheese Curds
Gift Baskets
Amish Crafts
Maple Syrup
Beef Jerky
Cheese Spreads
Highlights and features
- We source fresh milk from 230 trusted Amish producers in Southwestern Wisconsin
- Our facility processes 120,000 pounds of milk daily for consistent product availability
- We offer over 20 cheese varieties including award-winning Muenster cheese curds
- Our physical store provides year-round in-person shopping options
- We maintain strict quality control standards for all dairy products
Services
Muenster Cheese
Our signature Muenster cheese curds are made daily using traditional methods and fresh Amish milk. These squeaky cheese curds feature a creamy texture and mild flavor that appeals to all ages. Available in plain, garlic, and dill varieties, they're perfect for snacking or adding to meals.
Aged Cheddar
We produce cheddar cheese in various aging levels from medium to 10-year-old varieties. Our cheddar collection includes specialty options like cheddar with chives, pepper, onion, garlic, and vegetable blends. Each batch is carefully aged to develop complex flavors and textures.
Gift Baskets
Curated gift baskets featuring our premium cheeses, Amish-made candies, and maple syrup products make perfect gifts for any occasion. Available in multiple sizes and configurations, these gift sets showcase Wisconsin's best artisan food products.
Amish Crafts
Our store offers a selection of authentic Amish-made crafts and food products alongside our cheese offerings. These handmade items include wooden goods, jams, and traditional Amish specialties that complement our dairy products.
Cheese Spreads
We create a variety of cheese spreads using our premium cheese base. These spreads combine different cheese varieties with flavorings like pepper, herbs, and vegetables to create unique taste experiences perfect for entertaining or everyday enjoyment.
Questions
Do you offer cheese curds year-round?
Yes, our famous Muenster cheese curds are available year-round through our physical store in Cashton, WI.
Why can't I order online during summer months?
We temporarily suspend online shipping from April 1st through September 30th due to shipping reliability concerns during warmer months.
What cheese varieties do you produce?
We make over 20 cheese varieties including Muenster, cheddar (aged 2-10 years), juusto, Colby, Monterey Jack, and specialty flavored cheeses.
Where does your milk come from?
We source fresh milk daily from 230 Amish producers in Southwestern Wisconsin communities around Cashton, Hillsboro, and Tomah.
What are your store hours?
Our physical store operates Monday-Saturday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM and is closed on Sundays.
Do you accept credit cards?
Yes, we accept Visa, Mastercard, Discover, and American Express for both in-store and online purchases.
Reviews (4)
Roxanne Scott
Jul 03, 2021
Report
We like this place. Always has fresh cheese curds and Cedar Crest ice cream. Lots of Amish crafted gifts, jams, salsas, etc. The owner is very friendly and personable.
Elizabeth Bahr
Jun 17, 2021
Report
If you want a drive in the country, this is a good place to go. They're even open 11-2 on Sunday. They have bulk cheese, jams and salsas, and wooden cutting boards.
Gina Nevin
May 30, 2021
Report
Visit here every time I'm in the area. They have the best cheese curds in the world! Really friendly service. Good, down home folks. On this particular visit, I had a great chat with an Amish gentleman who gave me several tips for making my cashew crunch even better... Yum!
Marie Puttkamer
May 04, 2021
Report
Was a nice store but far from true amish. The first clue is open on Sundays. Everything is nice but priced high. The seasoned cheese curds have a lot to be desired. Carr Valley Cheese is much better. They also tried to sell us a so called amish greenhouse map for$2.00
