Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
30 Years
experience
Welcome to Mama Mia's Pizzeria - Orlando's Best Pizza & Wings Since 1996
Since 1996, Mama Mia's Pizzeria has been hand-crafting Orlando's favorite pizza, calzones, Stromboli, and wings using individually selected ingredients to ensure the best and most authentic tasting New York style pizza south of Manhattan. Our family-owned and operated pizzeria takes pride in preparing all dough, sauces, and dinners by hand in small batches on location, with homemade Pizza and Marinara sauces containing no sugar, salt, additives, preservatives, or artificial colors. With over 25 years of experience serving the Orlando community, we maintain a deep commitment to quality by only serving food we would feed our own family.

Our dedication to breaking free from chain restaurant standards has earned us consistent recognition as Orlando's best pizza year after year through our combination of traditional recipes and modern culinary techniques. We operate from our 706 East Wallace Street location with a team of skilled artisans who share our passion for authentic Italian cuisine.
Services
Pizza Wings Calzones Stromboli Subs Salads Garlic Bread Beverages Desserts
Details
  • Year established: 1996
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1996 with authentic New York style recipes
  • Homemade sauces with no artificial additives or preservatives
  • Fresh ingredients prepared daily in small batches
  • Consistently voted Orlando's best pizza by local customers
  • Skilled artisans using traditional Italian culinary techniques
Services
Pizza
Hand-crafted New York style pizzas with 16" and 18" options. Choose from cheese, deluxe, all meat, veggie, or bianco white pizza varieties. Toppings include pepperoni, sausage, fresh vegetables, and premium meats. Each pizza uses homemade sauce with no artificial additives.
Wings
10-piece chicken wings available in hot, medium, mild, BBQ, and teriyaki sauces. Served with blue cheese or ranch dressing. Made fresh to order with quality ingredients. Current pricing available by phone.
Calzones
Handmade calzones filled with mozzarella and ricotta cheese. Available in 8", 16", and 18" sizes. Served with marinara sauce on the side. Fresh ingredients prepared daily in small batches.
Stromboli
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, onion, mushroom, green pepper, and black olives stuffed in dough. Available in 8" and 16" sizes. Baked to golden perfection with quality ingredients and traditional methods.
Subs
8" Italian subs with meatball parmesan, ham & cheese, or classic Italian ingredients. Made with fresh-baked bread and premium meats. Affordable lunch options with generous portions.
Questions
What pizza sizes do you offer?
We offer 16" large and 18" extra-large pizza sizes with various topping options.
Do you have gluten-free options?
Currently we don't offer gluten-free crust options but can accommodate other dietary needs with advance notice.
What are your delivery hours?
Delivery hours match our regular operating hours: Sunday 12PM-11PM and Monday-Saturday 10:30AM-11:59PM.
Do you cater events?
Yes, we offer catering services for parties and events with advance ordering.
Are you open on holidays?
We remain open year-round except for major holidays like Thanksgiving and Christmas.
What makes your pizza special?
Our homemade sauces with no artificial additives, fresh ingredients, and traditional New York style techniques create our signature taste.
Reviews (4)
Anthony Robinson
Jan 29, 2022 Report
This is the best pizza In Florida hands down. Heck, I used to live in Massachusetts and this beats any pizza Ive ever had up there too. I will only be ordering from here From now on.
Carlos Ortiz
Jan 25, 2022 Report
This is not your ordinary basic pizza from Pizza Hut. If you looking for quality pizza this is one of pizzeria you should try. Your pie will be greasy and thin. When you order a large youre getting a large pie. Only complaint i have is the slices had some flop. I kinda like my pizza well done and crispy. Yes I would order from this restaurant again.
Sarah Cardona
Jan 25, 2022 Report
Wow where do I start with this review... with much excitement to write this review I cannot express how amazing the service and food was! I went in with my husband and we ordered the two slice and drink special which I cannot tell you enough how amazingly priced this deal is ! The pizza was amazing!! And the service I would have to say was one of the best service I have ever had ! Kevin was truly a pleasure and inspiration to talk to! All smiles and laughter me and my husband could sit there and talk all night with him if we could! Not only did we enjoy the food but Kevin told us a little about
Michael Jimenez
Dec 25, 2021 Report
I've eaten a lot of pizza from many different pizza places. All over Florida and even a few spots in NYC. This place is on point with their pizza. Nice thing crust cooked perfect. Just enough sauce but sweet and savory. The cheese is nice and gooey. With just the right amount of toppings on top! So satisfying and delicious! Next time I'm around I'm will make sure to stop here again.