Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
26 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining Experience in DeBary, FL
Goodfella's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant Of Debary has been serving authentic Italian cuisine in DeBary, Florida since 2000. Our commitment to quality ingredients and traditional recipes ensures every dish reflects the rich heritage of Italian cooking. We combine handcrafted pizzas with homemade pastas and fresh seafood, all prepared using time-honored techniques passed down through generations. Our partnership with Wiseguys Lounge enhances the dining experience by offering expertly crafted cocktails and live entertainment. The family-owned establishment prioritizes community connections while maintaining high standards of hospitality and culinary excellence.

Our staff receives ongoing training to ensure exceptional service and food presentation. We source locally grown produce and premium imported Italian ingredients to maintain consistency in flavor and quality. The restaurant's warm ambiance and attentive service create an inviting environment for both casual meals and special occasions. Our menu features classic Italian dishes alongside modern interpretations that appeal to diverse palates. We maintain strict food safety protocols and regularly update our offerings based on customer feedback. The establishment supports local farmers and producers to strengthen community ties while reducing environmental impact.
Services
Italian Restaurant Pizzeria Lounge Catering Private Dining
Details
  • Year established: 2000
Highlights and features
  • We use locally sourced ingredients for authentic Italian flavors
  • Our wood-fired pizzas feature imported Italian cheeses and meats
  • We offer private dining spaces for special occasions
  • Our staff receives ongoing culinary training and certification
  • We maintain strict quality control for consistent food preparation
Services
Italian Restaurant
Goodfellas offers traditional Italian dining with homemade pastas, fresh seafood, and classic entrees. Our menu features dishes like Chicken Parmigiana, Eggplant Rollatini, and Tortellini Alfredo. The restaurant serves lunch and dinner seven days a week with a focus on authentic recipes and quality ingredients.
Pizzeria
Our pizzeria creates wood-fired pizzas using imported Italian cheeses and meats. Options include classic Cheese Pizza, Meat Lovers, Vegetarian, and specialty pies like the Goodfellas Special. Gluten-free and take-and-bake options are available for customers with dietary preferences.
Lounge
Wiseguys Lounge provides handcrafted cocktails, premium wines, and spirits in a sophisticated setting. The lounge offers live entertainment including comedy nights and trivia. Customers can bring drinks from the lounge to the restaurant for pairing with Italian dishes.
Catering
Goodfellas offers catering services for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Our menu includes family-style Italian dishes, appetizers, and specialty pizzas. We provide delivery, setup, and service staff for events at our venue or client-selected locations.
Private Dining
The restaurant features private dining spaces for special occasions. Options include banquet rooms that accommodate groups of various sizes. The spaces work for birthday celebrations, business meetings, and family gatherings with customized menu options available.
People
Amanda McDonald
Owner
Amanda McDonald co-owns Goodfella's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant Of Debary and Wiseguys Lounge. She oversees daily operations and maintains the restaurant's commitment to quality Italian cuisine. Amanda focuses on creating memorable dining experiences while supporting local community initiatives.
Eddie Steelman
Owner
Eddie Steelman co-owns Goodfella's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant Of Debary with his sister Amanda. He manages Wiseguys Lounge operations and ensures the establishment maintains its reputation for excellent service. Eddie works to preserve the family's Italian heritage in all business aspects.
Questions
Does Goodfellas offer catering services for special events?
Yes, we provide full catering services for weddings, corporate events, and private parties with customizable Italian menus.
Can I bring drinks from Wiseguys Lounge to the restaurant?
Yes, guests may bring drinks from Wiseguys Lounge to Goodfellas Pizzeria for pairing with Italian dishes.
Are there gluten-free options available on the menu?
Yes, we offer gluten-free pizza crusts and other menu modifications to accommodate dietary restrictions.
Do you have private dining spaces for large groups?
Yes, we feature private banquet rooms that accommodate various group sizes for special occasions.
What are the restaurant's operating hours?
We're open Tuesday-Thursday 11AM-8:30PM, Friday-Saturday 11AM-9:30PM, and Sunday 12PM-8:30PM.
Reviews (6)
Confiance Concierge Services
Feb 02, 2022 Report
The Meatball Sub is delicious! Their Ingredients are fresh. We like sitting in the outdoor area. Very good service.
Ed Hubbard
Jan 28, 2022 Report
Won't take reservations. Get there early to get the table for my party, won't seat until every last person is here. Avoid unless you both like waiting and being annoyed.
JoAnn Epstein
Dec 29, 2021 Report
First let me start by saying this was my favorite Italian restaurant food was the BEST!!!! However for some reason they eliminated all my favorite dishes on the menu no shrimp Sinatra no chicken franchese they claim limited menu why?BTW if you look at the menu on line it still lists a full menu I sincerely hope they get back to doing what they do best
Suzanne Diberardino
Dec 28, 2021 Report
This is our favorite restaurant. My husband and I went there December 22nd and Chance was our waiter. Outstanding service as always, we met Anthony for the first time, such a nice guy. When we asked for the bill we were told that it was taken care of. I believe it was Rachelle, I hope that I have your name correct. You were such a lovely person, saving my spot in line and caring that we had access due to my husband being handicapped. Thank you so much, you are truly a beautiful person! I only hope that we see again, I want to thank you in person. Wishing you a Merry Christmas!
Jeanmarie Scafiddi
Dec 26, 2021 Report
The food the service the staff was absolutely amazing! The Bianca pizza was absolutely delicious! Gigi was an amazing host as always!! The calamari was delicious and i love the lemon sleeve. Thats a wonderful idea. Highly recommend!!
Michael Allen
Nov 11, 2021 Report
They have an internet presence and Facebook page but dont tell you until you are being checked in to be seated that due to Covid or employee shortage or ?? that they are only doing pizzas and their easiest to prepare meals. We made a decision to eat there because of the dishes they traditionally serve and location. They have chosen not to publicly post this online. I had to pick something to eat because my family wanted to eat there, but honestly, I will never go back. Limit seating and make guests wait to get the full menu, or post the pizza and spaghetti menu online. I was terribly disappointed