Business Details
16 Years
experience
Vintage Jewelry & Antique Engagement Rings | Erstwhile Jewelry
Founded in 2010, Erstwhile Jewelry is a vintage jewelry brand rooted in a five-generation legacy of jewelry craftsmanship. Our story began with Jared Klusner, a fifth-generation jeweler, and his wife Alisa, who combined their expertise in antique diamonds and fashion design to create a curated collection of extraordinary vintage and handcrafted engagement rings, wedding bands, and cocktail jewelry. With origins tracing back to 1887 in Odessa and a New York City heritage since 1937, we specialize in rare antique diamonds from the Victorian, Edwardian, and Art Deco eras, reimagined through our signature settings. Our NYC showroom offers personalized appointments to explore one-of-a-kind pieces, while our global sourcing expertise ensures access to museum-quality treasures.Our team of accomplished jewelry specialists provides deep knowledge of vintage craftsmanship, gem certification, and bespoke design. We uphold rigorous standards for quality, authenticity, and ethical sourcing, ensuring every piece carries historical significance and enduring value. As both curators and creators, we bridge centuries-old artistry with modern romance, offering concierge services for custom engagement rings and rare antique finds. Our commitment to excellence has established Erstwhile Jewelry as a trusted destination for those seeking jewelry with legacy and character.
Services
Vintage Engagement Rings
Custom Jewelry Design
Wedding Band Collection
Gem Certification
Virtual Appointments
Antique Diamond Sourcing
Art Deco Jewelry
Concierge Services
Victorian Era Rings
Edwardian Style Bands
Details
- Year established: 2010
Highlights and features
- We offer five generations of jewelry expertise since 1887.
- Our collection features rare antique diamonds from historic eras.
- Our team includes certified vintage jewelry specialists.
- We provide personalized concierge services for custom designs.
- Our NYC showroom offers immersive, expert-led shopping experiences.
Services
Vintage Engagement Rings
Curated collection of one-of-a-kind engagement rings from Victorian, Edwardian, and Art Deco eras. Featuring rare old mine and old European cut diamonds expertly restored to preserve historical integrity while ensuring modern wearability. Each piece undergoes rigorous authentication and quality assessment.
Custom Jewelry Design
Personalized ring creation process combining antique diamonds with handcrafted settings. Clients collaborate directly with designers to develop unique pieces using CAD technology and traditional wax carving techniques while maintaining vintage aesthetics and structural integrity.
Gem Certification
Comprehensive evaluation of diamond characteristics and historical provenance by GIA-certified gemologists. Includes detailed documentation of cut, clarity, and period-specific craftsmanship features to verify authenticity and market value for antique and modern pieces.
Virtual Appointments
Interactive digital shopping experience with 360-degree viewing of inventory and real-time expert guidance. Clients receive personalized recommendations, pricing details, and secure transaction options through encrypted video conferencing platforms.
Antique Diamond Sourcing
Global acquisition of museum-quality diamonds through established networks of private collectors and estate sales. Specializes in sourcing unsigned stones with verifiable provenance while maintaining ethical standards in the secondary market.
People
Jared Klusner
Founder & Fifth-Generation Jeweler
Jared Klusner, fifth-generation jeweler with expertise in antique diamonds, sources rare pieces globally. His heritage traces back to 1887 Odessa, combining family legacy with modern craftsmanship to create Erstwhile Jewelry's curated collection.
Alisa Klusner
Co-Founder & Creative Director
Alisa Klusner, fashion-trained co-founder, shapes Erstwhile Jewelry's aesthetic vision. Her background in design from Parsons School informs the brand's modern interpretation of historical jewelry while managing client relations and creative direction.
Questions
What types of vintage jewelry do you specialize in?
We specialize in engagement rings and wedding bands from the Victorian (1837-1900), Edwardian (1901-1915), Art Deco (1920-1939), and Midcentury (1950-1970) eras featuring antique diamonds.
Can I schedule a virtual consultation?
Yes, we offer virtual appointments with 360-degree viewing of inventory through encrypted platforms. Book online or contact us directly to arrange a personalized session with our jewelry specialists.
Do you provide gemstone certification?
All significant diamonds receive certification from GIA-accredited gemologists, documenting cut, clarity, and historical characteristics. We provide detailed authentication reports for every antique piece.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, bank transfers, and financing options for purchases. Specific payment terms are discussed during the checkout process or consultation appointments.
How does the custom design process work?
Our custom process begins with selecting an antique diamond, followed by collaborative design using CAD renderings and wax models. Clients work directly with our artisans to create unique settings that honor historical craftsmanship.
Are your antique diamonds ethically sourced?
We maintain strict ethical standards by sourcing from estate sales, private collections, and trusted dealers with documented provenance. Our inventory avoids stones linked to conflict regions or questionable practices.
Reviews (7)
Katie Wadhams
Dec 22, 2021
Report
My experience with Erstwhile was a pleasure. I ordered through the website and it was certainly a little scary to not see the piece in person but upon request I was sent many more images and videos so I could feel confident about my purchase. It arrived in beautiful packaging (after their team double checked on date to ship so I would be home) and has exceeded expectations. What a special experience and wonderful opportunity to own a truly heirloom piece of jewelry. Special shoutout to Jesse who was wonderful to work with.
Agapito Sustaita
Nov 25, 2021
Report
I had some reservations about making such a large jewelry purchase without seeing the piece in person. However, when I asked for additional pictures, I received an immediate response with not just pictures, but also a short video. My order was handled quickly and prior to shipping, I was contacted because a final quality check revealed a possibly slight imperfection. After a jeweler make sure everything was perfect, my engagement ring arrived quickly thereafter. My entire experience was professional, warm, and delightful.
Kendra Lawrence
Nov 18, 2021
Report
We bought my engagement online two years ago and were so pleased with the quality, experience, and service that we came back to make additional purchases to celebrate a milestone birthday. Would recommend to anyone looking for something very special and unique - I get compliments all the time on my engagement ring.
Neil Smith
Oct 25, 2021
Report
Great place to get jewelry! They started out as a really small operation on Etsy and just continued to grow with honesty and quality jewelry. Really nice instagram account. Rings look even better in person. Highly recommend!
Greg Behrens
Oct 04, 2021
Report
I had a great experience working with the team at Erstwhile - Jessie & Finessa were easy to communicate with, extremely patient, and helped me get a truly unique and beautiful engagement ring. I will be back for wedding bands, and hopefully other unique pieces in the future!
Charlie Elias
Jun 16, 2021
Report
I worked with Erstwhile to reset my stone in their Golden Prism Shifter setting and it was a pleasure! Jesse was very friendly, answered any question I had and kept me informed every step of the way. As for my completed ring, it is absolutely stunning and even better than I imagined! I would definitely recommend Erstwhile and wouldn't hesitate to purchase from them again. Maybe one day I will again!
Dakota Fontanello
May 07, 2021
Report
Jesse and Erstwhile were really wonderful to deal with. They were transparent, easy-going and communicative. Truly felt like they were giving us white glove treatment from start to finish. Cant say enough nice things.