Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Authentic Key West Dining at Fisherman's Cafe Key West Key West
Fisherman's Cafe Key West Key West has been a cornerstone of the community since the early 1970s, when it first opened as a gathering place for local fishermen and residents. Originally located at the Henry Flagler railroad station on Caroline Street, the cafe was known for its warm, inclusive atmosphere where visitors and locals alike felt at home. The Vega family, who owned the establishment, built personal connections with patrons, often anticipating their orders before they sat down. Today, the cafe continues this legacy at Key West's Historic Seaport, offering fresh, just-caught seafood and made-to-order specialties that reflect the authentic flavors of old Key West.

Our commitment to quality ingredients, personalized service, and historic ambiance remains unwavering. We pride ourselves on maintaining the same welcoming vibe that made the original location a beloved institution. With decades of experience in the hospitality industry, our team ensures every guest experiences the unique charm and culinary traditions that define Fisherman's Cafe Key West Key West. Our expertise in seafood preparation and dedication to preserving Key West's cultural heritage set us apart as a trusted dining destination. We adhere to the highest standards of food safety and customer satisfaction, ensuring a memorable experience for every visitor.
Services
Breakfast Lunch Dinner Seafood Sandwiches Wraps Salads Beverages Kids Menu Catering
Details
  • Year established: 1970
Highlights and features
  • We serve fresh, just-caught seafood daily.
  • Our made-to-order specialties capture authentic Key West flavors.
  • Experience the historic ambiance of our original 1970s location.
  • Family-owned legacy with deep community roots.
  • Warm, welcoming vibe that feels like home.
Services
Breakfast
Enjoy all-day breakfast featuring eggs, pancakes, bacon, sausage, and toast. Our made-to-order specialties include egg sandwiches, breakfast burritos, and traditional Southern biscuits with gravy. Freshly brewed coffee and Cuban-style beverages complement your meal.
Seafood
Savor locally sourced seafood dishes including shrimp po' boys, grilled mahi sandwiches, and fish & chip baskets. Our menu highlights the freshest daily catches prepared with Key West-inspired seasonings and sauces.
Sandwiches
Choose from classic deli sandwiches like Italian combo, Cuban mix, and traditional reuben. Our grilled options include Angus hamburgers, chicken breast, and hot dogs served with house-made sides.
Salads
Opt for lighter fare with our signature Chinese chicken salad, Caesar salad, or chef salad featuring premium ingredients like charbroiled chicken, hearts of palm, and key lime dressing.
Kids Menu
Delight young diners with kid-friendly options including cheese quesadillas, shrimp baskets, and grilled cheese. All meals come with french fries and are prepared to order for quality and freshness.
Questions
What is Fisherman's Cafe Key West Key West Key West known for?
We're renowned for serving fresh, locally caught seafood and made-to-order specialties since the 1970s in a historic, welcoming atmosphere that captures Key West's unique charm.
What are your operating hours?
We're open daily from 7:00 AM to 5:00 PM, seven days a week, offering breakfast, lunch, and dinner options.
Where are you located?
Our current location is at Key West's Historic Seaport, 205 Elizabeth Street, Unit D, continuing our tradition at this iconic destination.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide catering for local events featuring our signature seafood dishes and classic cafe specialties. Please contact us for details and availability.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, debit cards, and mobile payment options. Cash payments are also welcome for in-person transactions.
Videos
Reviews (7)
Lana
Jan 05, 2022 Report
What can I saythis is a must when visiting Key West. We love tacos and tried many different establishments while we were there, and I can honestly say Fishermans Cafe is the best! Too bad they didnt have any lobster that day, but the pulled pork and fish tacos were unbelievable. Pulled pork was seasoned well and not salty (which I find too often) and if getting the fish, get it blackened. The food took a bit of time, but its expected since it was made fresh. Plantains were made just how I like em - soft and sweet. Portions are sizeable so you definitely get your moneys worth.
Alexandra Cowans
Dec 16, 2021 Report
This is a must have if youre visiting Key West. We accidentally stumbled upon this place a few years ago and cannot leave the island without having their best fish sandwich! Everything is fresh, seasoned amazingly!!
James Balaguer
Mar 29, 2021 Report
Was torn between the shrimp wrap and the lobster tacos. Went lobster tacos with fried plantains. Very, very good. I like that the lobster taco wasn't creamy but had a nice vinegrette on slaw and was savory. Very different from a lobster roll & really good. Will go back before my trip is over.
Nick Filardo
Feb 26, 2021 Report
The coconut lobster tacos were the bomb!! After a few days in Key West, this was one of the best things we ate. And we ate lots of great food in Key West. Extremely flavorful!!
Eesa Ali
Jan 19, 2021 Report
We had lobster tacos, catch of the day tacos (yellow tail snapper), and an island bowl. They were all very good. The breakfast looks good too. Id like to try the guava sesame toast and coffee next time. **Edit** I came back for breakfast and had the sesame guava toast and a cafe con leche. So good
Carla Nicole
Dec 24, 2020 Report
This was such a great choice!! I had the shrimp tacos and my family tried the fish tacos, turkey sandwhich and shrimp wrap. They were all so so good! The value for the pricing is great and everything was truly delicious. The staff was also super nice
Note: limited seating avilable and is outside seating bit has fans.
Charlotte Ellis
Dec 25, 2019 Report
One of the best hidden gems on the island. Black bean burger is phenomenal, and their yuca fries are some of the crunchiest, most delicious things I have ever tasted. The woman in front (so sorry I don't know her name!) is always so pleasant and friendly. Don't fret at prices at first glance - the portions are HUGE. I have yet to finish something I've ordered, despite a large appetite. Lemonade is fresh and has no added sugar - I love it that way. Have yet to try the coffee but have heard very good things. Excited to come back next year.