Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
45 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Pizza & Dining in Niagara Falls, NY
Since 1981, Joey's Pizzeria has been Niagara Falls, NY's premier destination for authentic Italian cuisine. Our family-owned business combines generations of culinary expertise with fresh, high-quality ingredients to create memorable dining experiences. We specialize in handcrafted pizzas, char-broiled wings, and traditional Italian dishes that reflect our deep commitment to flavor and hospitality. Our team maintains rigorous standards in food preparation and customer service, ensuring every meal meets our exacting quality benchmarks. With late-night availability seven days a week and citywide delivery options, we've built our reputation on accessibility without compromising authenticity.

Our establishment holds proper licensing for beer and wine service, complementing our diverse menu offerings. Through decades of community engagement, we've cultivated a welcoming atmosphere where patrons enjoy both exceptional food and genuine service. Our operational history demonstrates consistent growth while maintaining core values of quality and customer satisfaction. This enduring commitment positions us as a trusted leader in Western New York's restaurant industry.
Services
Oven Fresh Pizza Jumbo Wings Chicken Fingers Submarines Seafood Dinners Live Music Events Food Delivery Takeout Service Friday Fish Fry
Details
  • Year established: 1981
Highlights and features
  • We've served authentic Italian cuisine since 1981 with family recipes
  • Our menu features fresh ingredients in every handcrafted dish
  • We offer late-night dining seven days a week
  • Our daily specials provide exceptional value without compromising quality
  • We deliver citywide to Niagara Falls and Wheatfield areas
Services
Oven Fresh Pizza
Our signature pizzas feature hand-tossed dough topped with premium ingredients. Available in white, double dough, or old-fashioned styles with customizable toppings. Each pizza combines traditional Italian techniques with modern flavor profiles for a distinctive dining experience.
Jumbo Wings
Char-broiled jumbo wings served in your choice of hot, medium, mild, or BBQ sauce. Available in portions from 10 to 50 pieces with consistent quality and flavor. Perfectly paired with our house-made blue cheese or ranch dressing.
Submarines
Freshly made submarine sandwiches with premium meats and quality ingredients. Choose from classic options like ham, salami, or turkey, with all subs including lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onion. Available in small and large sizes.
Seafood Dinners
Daily seafood specials featuring fresh, high-quality preparations. Our Friday fish fry has become a local tradition with consistent quality and authentic flavors. Each dinner includes traditional side dishes and proper seasoning.
Food Delivery
Citywide delivery service maintaining food quality during transport. Available for all menu items including specialty pizzas and daily specials. Our delivery area covers Niagara Falls and Wheatfield with timely service and proper temperature control.
Questions
What are your operating hours?
We're open Monday-Thursday 11 AM-11 PM, Friday 11 AM-11:30 PM, Saturday 11:30 AM-11:30 PM, and Sunday 11:30 AM-11 PM.
Do you offer delivery services?
Yes, we deliver citywide in Niagara Falls and to Wheatfield areas with proper food temperature maintenance during transport.
What pizza options do you have?
We offer white, double dough, and old-fashioned pizzas with various toppings including pepperoni, mushrooms, and sausage.
Are there special menu options?
Our everyday specials include combinations like pizza and wings packages ranging from $27.50 to $81.00 with tax.
Do you serve alcohol?
Yes, we're licensed to serve beer and wine to complement your meal.
What live events do you host?
We feature live music performances and quick draw events in our restaurant space with scheduled artists announced regularly.
Reviews (4)
Joelin C.
Dec 28, 2021 Report
I loved Joeys pizza!!! I would always get a tray with wings- perfect western NY meal. I got a tray and wing special today (Dec. 27th) and there was multiple hairs found throughout the pizza. One hair can be overlooked but multiple hairs is absolutely disgusting! I will never go back there again- it really makes me leery of there quality control and cleanliness in the kitchen.
Amir Agharezaee
Nov 04, 2021 Report
The food was great, staff were good, but it was not clean. The plates, were stained heaviy. No paper tissue on the table.
Paul F.
Aug 17, 2021 Report
"Our extensive menu is available for eat-in, takeout, or delivery." This is copied from their website and when I called for a pizza they said they don't deliver. Why would you do that?
Eric Massey
Jul 22, 2021 Report
Called up there about 3pm on July 26th. Whoever answered the phone needs to learn how to answer a phone and some customer service skills 1st red flag.I asked if the dimning room was open he said. "Yeah in a very rude way" . 2nd red flag. So I drive over there with my family go in and am told dinning isn't open till 5. This was 10 min after I had called and got a different answer. I shouldn't of gaven them a chance after the whole phone ordeal but I did and I regret it..