Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
47 Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Omaha Since 1979
Established in 1979, 14 Karat has grown from a wholesale gold jewelry operation into Omaha's premier luxury jewelry destination. Founded by Robert Osterholm, our business was built on the principles of quality craftsmanship and competitive pricing. In 1998, John Osterholm joined the team, expanding our offerings to include semi-precious and precious stones, pearls, and loose diamonds. Our 2009 showroom opening at The Shops of Legacy marked a new era of accessibility while maintaining our commitment to personalized service. With six GIA-trained associates and three part-time representatives, we've earned multiple Best of Omaha awards through our dedication to exceptional customer experiences.

Our inventory features white, yellow, and rose gold, sterling silver, and an extensive selection of gemstones including rubies, sapphires, and emeralds. We specialize in engagement rings and wedding bands from renowned designers like Sylvie and Gabriel & Co. Our low-overhead model allows us to offer industry-leading returns on gold trade-ins, with our everyday rate of 80% value being unmatched locally. Customer testimonials consistently highlight our team's expertise, personalized approach, and the perfect balance of selection and service that defines our 45-year legacy in the jewelry industry.
Services
Jewelry Sales Engagement Rings Bridal Jewelry Jewelry Repair Gemstone Collection
Details
  • Year established: 1979
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1979 with 45 years of jewelry industry expertise
  • Six GIA-trained associates providing professional gemological expertise
  • Exclusive designer collections from Sylvie and Gabriel & Co
  • Unmatched 80% return rate on gold trade-ins, verified by competitors
  • Award-winning customer service recognized by multiple Best of Omaha honors
What people say
Perfect match for my Fiance Over the moon with results Amazing customer service Care about their customers Best in town
Services
Engagement Rings
Our engagement ring collection features exclusive designs from industry leaders like Sylvie and Gabriel & Co. Each piece combines superior craftsmanship with ethically sourced diamonds. Our experts provide personalized guidance to help customers select the perfect symbol of commitment.
Gemstone Jewelry
We offer an extensive selection of rubies, sapphires, emeralds, and birthstones expertly set in white, yellow, or rose gold. Our inventory includes both classic and contemporary designs to suit various tastes and occasions.
Jewelry Repair
Our skilled technicians provide comprehensive repair services for all types of fine jewelry. From simple resizing to complex restorations, we use advanced techniques to maintain the integrity and beauty of valuable pieces.
Gold Trade-In
We offer competitive returns for gold jewelry trade-ins, with an industry-leading 80% value guarantee. Our experts provide transparent evaluations for yellow, white, and rose gold items of any condition.
Diamond Consultation
Our GIA-trained professionals provide comprehensive diamond education covering cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. Customers receive personalized assistance in selecting the perfect diamond for their specific needs and budget.
People
John Osterholm
Owner
John Osterholm joined the family business in 1998, expanding its offerings to include diamonds and precious stones. He oversees operations and maintains the company's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.
Diana Alderson
Office Manager/Accounting
Diana Alderson manages financial operations and office administration, ensuring smooth day-to-day functioning. Her expertise contributes to maintaining the business's debt-free status and efficient operations.
Renae Mazur
Sales Associate
Renae Mazur provides personalized jewelry consultations, helping customers find perfect pieces for special occasions. Her product knowledge enhances the shopping experience for engagement and bridal jewelry customers.
Roxanne Larson-Roberts
Sales Associate
Roxanne Larson-Roberts specializes in designer collections, offering expert guidance on contemporary and classic jewelry selections. Her approachable style helps create comfortable shopping experiences for all customers.
Brittney Akerson
Marketing Director
Brittney Akerson leads marketing initiatives that maintain the store's position as Omaha's best-kept jewelry secret. She develops campaigns that highlight the business's heritage and product excellence.
Questions
What types of jewelry do you specialize in?
We specialize in engagement rings, bridal jewelry, and fine jewelry featuring diamonds, gemstones, and precious metals. Our collection includes designer pieces from renowned brands like Sylvie and Gabriel & Co.
Do you offer jewelry repair services?
Yes, we provide comprehensive jewelry repair services including resizing, stone replacement, and restoration of damaged pieces using professional techniques and equipment.
Can I trade in my gold jewelry?
We accept yellow, white, and rose gold trade-ins with industry-leading returns. Our standard payout is 80% of melt value, verified through transparent evaluation processes.
Are your diamonds certified?
We offer certified diamonds with documentation from recognized grading institutions. Our GIA-trained staff provides detailed explanations of diamond quality characteristics during consultations.
What are your store hours?
Our showroom is open Monday-Thursday 10am-6:30pm, Friday 10am-6pm, and Saturday 11am-4pm. We're closed on Sundays for private appointments only.
Do you have a price match policy?
While we don't formally price match, our low-overhead model allows competitive pricing. We'll work with customers to explore options within their budget while maintaining quality standards.
Reviews (4)
Kristi Murdoch
Aug 03, 2021 Report
Can not recommend 14 Karat enough! My fianc worked with John and Alyssa on my engagement ring and its better than I could have ever dreamed up! They are so great to work with and went out of their way to find the exact diamond Ive always wanted. Alyssas custom designs are insanely beautiful. She helped me pick out a beautiful band to compliment my ring and Im just so happy. Dont go anywhere else in Omaha! 14 Karat is hands down the absolute best!
Daniel Cromer
Jun 15, 2021 Report
Alyssa was wonderfully professional and helpful, and found the perfect stone and setting within my budget, she was very communicative all through the process, and the ring was ready well within my timeframe.
Mitchell Hanna
May 18, 2021 Report
We cannot say enough good things about our experience at 14 Karat and finding the perfect engagement ring. We worked closely with Alyssa, who not only made great suggestions, but also we felt went above and beyond in helping us. Having done extensive research before our meeting with her, we both were extremely particular in finding the perfect diamond. Alyssa was incredibly patient and kind to us, and met with us multiple weekends in a row to help us find the one. After our first meeting with her, my fianc and I knew we did not want to go anywhere else. Alyssas knowledge, expertise,
Katt R.
May 09, 2021 Report
Oh my gosh! I cannot recommend Alyssa at 14 Karat enough. She listened to everything we wanted, listened to our budget, and worked with us every step of the way. I cannot believe that she made this ring, custom for me, and I get to wear it for the rest of my life!! If you want someone who is so supportive and sweet and will work with you & listen to everything you want, make the trip over to 14 Karat! I will 100% be going back and asking Alyssa to make more jewelry for me. She is seriously a professional and amazing at what she does!