Contact Sign In Add Your Business
Coffee Tyme Coffee Tyme
Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Local Coffee Shop in Cape May
We are a family-owned coffee shop serving the Cape May community since 2015. Our mission is to provide premium coffee and fresh-baked goods made daily on-site, combining quality ingredients with a welcoming atmosphere. With two convenient locations at The Beach and The Mall, we offer a diverse menu featuring eight specialty coffees, breakfast sandwiches, pastries, and desserts. Our team prioritizes customer satisfaction through friendly service and attention to detail, as evidenced by our recognition as the #1 Coffee Shop in Cape May on TripAdvisor and multiple 'Best Coffee' awards.

We use locally roasted coffee beans and maintain a clean, inviting environment where locals and visitors can connect. Our commitment to quality extends to our food preparation, which is done from scratch daily, and our flexible hours that accommodate early risers and weekend shoppers alike.
Services
Coffee Espresso Drinks Baked Goods Breakfast Sandwiches Pastries Desserts Catering Takeout Dine-In Merchandise
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned with multiple 'Best Coffee' awards since 2015
  • Locally roasted coffee beans and daily fresh-baked goods
  • Two convenient Cape May locations with extended weekend hours
  • Eight specialty coffee options and diverse breakfast selections
  • Welcoming environment with consistently friendly service
What people say
Great selection Tasty baked goods Friendly staff Perfect location Amazing ambiance
Update Listing
Services
Espresso Drinks
We serve eight specialty espresso-based drinks including cappuccino, latte, and mocha using premium Italian brewing methods. Our skilled baristas create perfect foam textures and flavor balances for each order. Customers enjoy both classic and innovative coffee preparations in a casual setting.
Baked Goods
Our kitchen produces fresh-baked goods daily featuring blueberry muffins, biscotti, and specialty desserts. All items use high-quality ingredients with options for dietary preferences like sugar-free and whole wheat. The aroma of freshly baked treats enhances our welcoming atmosphere.
Breakfast Sandwiches
We offer made-to-order breakfast sandwiches featuring the popular Wyatt sandwich with premium ingredients. Each sandwich combines quality proteins, cheeses, and breads for satisfying morning meals. Ingredients are prepared fresh daily to maintain optimal taste and texture.
Catering
Our catering service provides coffee, pastries, and breakfast items for local Cape May events and businesses. We offer customized menus with bulk ordering options and delivery to accommodate corporate functions and special occasions.
Merchandise
We sell branded coffee mugs and recommended home espresso machines to enhance customers' coffee experiences. Our merchandise selection includes practical items for daily use and perfect gifts for coffee enthusiasts seeking quality brewing equipment.
Questions
What coffee options do you offer?
We serve eight specialty coffees including espresso, cappuccino, latte, mocha, and macchiato using premium Italian brewing methods.
Are your baked goods made fresh daily?
Yes, all our pastries, muffins, and desserts are freshly baked on-site daily using quality ingredients.
Do you offer breakfast sandwiches?
Yes, we serve made-to-order breakfast sandwiches including our popular Wyatt sandwich with premium ingredients.
What are your hours on weekends?
We're open daily 7AM-7PM, with extended Saturday hours until 10PM at our Mall location.
Do you have catering options?
Yes, we offer catering services for local events with customized coffee and breakfast menus.
Where are your locations?
We have two convenient Cape May locations: 414 Washington St (The Mall) and 315 Beach Ave (The Beach).
Reviews (6)
Barbara S.
Oct 27, 2021 Report
I recently visited Cape May and went to Coffee Tyme. They make the best no sugar mocha Frappuccino. This is my new favorite store in Cape May.
Joanne S.
Sep 09, 2021 Report
Best coffee experience ever!! The staff started my day out with beautiful smiles and friendly service. I could have stayed all day!! Love the vibes!!
Giacomo Antonicello
Aug 20, 2021 Report
Coffee Tyme is a great spot! Its a good atmosphere with great customer service! Them girls are always workin hard and taking care of me. Will I ever get a steger discount? Couldnt tell ya. But shoutout to the girl behind the register ;)
Will Peach
Aug 13, 2021 Report
Nothing like a $6 plain bagel with one tiny piece of pork roll. This is a good example of a place that wouldnt survive without tourists stumbling in the door.
Cory W.
Aug 11, 2021 Report
I had gotten a iced vanilla latte and at first I thought they used an interesting set of coffee beans but in the end it worked out. The only problem was that I could not taste the vanilla even though it's a vanilla latte not a regular latte.
Lena F.
Jul 27, 2021 Report
If you want a delicious drink made fresh and quick, this is the placeeee! Not only were the staff really friendly, but they made four drinks in under 5 minutes. Just wanted to add that I really, REALLY enjoyed the pumpkin chai latte! It was sooo good.