Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
We founded Kemper 1st Choice Payroll to provide businesses with a superior payroll experience built on deep accounting expertise. Our team leverages a solid CPA background and an in-house technology division to deliver accurate payroll processing, tax filing, and workforce management solutions. We specialize in serving diverse industries including manufacturing, professional services, transportation, hospitality, and healthcare with tailored compliance knowledge. Our certified payroll professionals bring decades of combined experience, including 29 years from our lead specialist Ginger, to resolve complex payroll challenges. We ensure precise handling of shift differentials, piece rates, tip calculations, per diem structures, and premium earnings for non-exempt employees. Our integrated platform supports time and attendance, employee self-service, 401(k) administration, ACA reporting, and garnishment processing seamlessly.

We prioritize responsiveness and personal service, maintaining direct availability for client questions and proactive compliance updates. Our long-term client relationships, some spanning over ten years, reflect our commitment to reliability and satisfaction. We operate from Evansville, Indiana, adhering to strict professional standards and transparent communication throughout every engagement. Our mission is to simplify payroll complexity while giving business owners confidence in their compliance and financial accuracy. We continuously invest in technology and training to stay ahead of regulatory changes and evolving workforce needs. Choose us for a partnership that combines CPA-level expertise with dedicated, accessible support.
Highlights and features
  • We offer 29+ years of certified payroll expertise.
  • Our CPA background ensures accurate tax compliance.
  • We provide integrated workforce management and benefits administration.
  • Our team resolves complex multi-industry payroll challenges daily.
  • We maintain long-term client relationships exceeding ten years.
Services
Payroll Processing
We handle comprehensive payroll processing including shift differentials, piece rates, incentive bonuses, and weighted average overtime calculations for diverse industries. Our CPA-backed team ensures accurate tax withholding, direct deposit, and compliance with federal and state regulations. Clients gain confidence through error-free payroll cycles and dedicated support for complex earnings scenarios.
Workforce Management
Our workforce management tools integrate time keeping, employee self-service, leave management, and incident reporting into a single platform. We customize solutions for manufacturing, transportation, and hospitality clients to streamline scheduling and attendance tracking. Businesses reduce administrative burden while improving labor cost visibility and regulatory adherence.
Tax Compliance
We manage payroll tax payment and filing for all jurisdictions, including multi-state and interstate transportation requirements. Our experts stay current on changing regulations to prevent penalties and ensure timely submissions. Clients avoid compliance risks through proactive monitoring and accurate reporting of wages, tips, and fringe benefits.
Benefits Administration
We provide integrated support for 401(k) administration, health benefit management, ACA reporting, and garnishment processing. Our system automates deductions, eligibility tracking, and year-end compliance documentation for employers. This service reduces HR workload while ensuring accurate benefit contributions and regulatory compliance.
Time & Attendance
Our time and attendance solutions capture hours via integrated clocks, mobile apps, and POS imports for seamless payroll integration. We configure rules for overtime, shift premiums, and meal breaks specific to healthcare, hospitality, and manufacturing sectors. Employers gain real-time labor data and reduce manual entry errors significantly.
Reviews (7)
Mike Nelson
Feb 03, 2021 Report
As a small business owner, I cannot say enough about the fantastic support and guidance Kemper 1st Choice Payroll provides. They know the in's and out's of state and federal requirements which allows me to focus on my core business. I have full faith and trust in the services they provide and confidence that they have my interests' at heart. If you are overwhelmed managing your own books and payroll, give them a call. One of our best decisions in the 6 years of business.
Cheryl Sorgius
Dec 23, 2020 Report
I have had a very positive experience working with Karen Lyerla as well as Ginger Hart. They are prompt, efficient, and always willing to help. I am very satisfied with the service we receive from Kemper 1st Choice Payroll.
Ashley Jordan
Nov 20, 2020 Report
Kemper 1st Choice is a company that provides timely service & excellent customer care. Our representative Karen has been very helpful with accounting procedures for payroll.
Sara Ruding
Nov 18, 2020 Report
I have always had nothing but the best customer service with Kemper Choice. Whether its to help fix an issue or learning how or why, I have only gotten the best, prompt response from a team that really knows their stuff! I wouldn't use anyone else!
Kathryn L.
Nov 14, 2020 Report
We made the switch to Kemper 1st Choice Payroll several years ago and it has been the best decision! It has saved so many hours of processing our payroll. Kim has been phenomenal to work with. She has responded promptly to all of our needs and answers any questions we have with the information we need. Kim and the whole group at Kemper Payroll has been a valuable asset to our company by allowing us to continue to grow and we know our payroll is being handled which allows us more time to do other tasks.
Nancy Anderson
Oct 21, 2020 Report
We have been with Kemper for many years and they have always stepped up to help me with any problem/situation I have had. Any questions I have had (which has been many) they answer and help me with such kindness. Thank you for everything you all do, I would highly recommend them!
Chris Robinson
Oct 13, 2020 Report
Kemper is so helpful when I have questions and very timely. They are great to work with especially my contact, Karen. She does a fantastic job.