Business Details
19 Years
experience
Authentic Italian-American Pizza in Savannah
Since 2007, Screamin' Mimi's has been a family-owned cornerstone of Savannah's culinary scene, delivering authentic Italian-American pizza and subs rooted in generations of tradition. Our recipes are forged from decades of experience in Atlantic City, NJ, and Philadelphia, PA, blending northern culinary heritage with southern hospitality. Every productfrom hand-tossed, brick-oven pizzas to house-made hoagie rollsis crafted daily with meticulous care, using premium ingredients like fresh dough, locally sourced produce, and hand-selected cheeses. Our commitment to quality extends beyond food: we cultivate a welcoming environment where customers are greeted by name, treated like family, and immersed in a rotating showcase of local art.With accolades from Google, Yelp, and Urban Spoon, we take pride in maintaining the legacy established by founders Louis 'Big Lou' Cobello and Scarlet Mimi Cobello, now carried forward by their children Louie and Tara. Our operational expertise, honed through years of trial and error, informs every aspect of our businessfrom equipment sourcing to menu developmentensuring consistency and excellence in every bite.
Services
Pizza
Subs
Pasta
Salads
Catering
Details
- Year established: 2007
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 2007 with generational pizza-making expertise
- Fresh dough and ingredients made daily in-house
- Extensive menu featuring 18 pies, 11 hoagies, and pasta dishes
- Award-winning recipes from Atlantic City and Philadelphia traditions
- Recognized by Google and Yelp reviewers as Savannah's best pizza
What people say
Best pizza in savannah
Huge slices
Amazing pizza
Fresh toppings
Great staff
Services
Pizza
Our hand-tossed pizzas feature house-made dough baked in brick ovens, topped with premium ingredients. From classic cheese slices to custom creations with fresh toppings, each pizza embodies Italian-American tradition. The Margherita pizza highlights our commitment to quality with house-made sauce, fresh basil, and top-grade mozzarella.
Subs
Eleven varieties of hoagies use house-baked rolls filled with premium meats, cheeses, and toppings. The Philly Cheese Steak features authentic Philly steak and melted cheese with grilled veggies. Cold and hot options showcase traditional recipes perfected over generations. Each sub offers hearty portions at value pricing.
Pasta
House-cooked pasta dishes include Baked Ziti with Mimis sauce, meatballs, and focaccia bread. Our recipes originate from Atlantic City and Philadelphia traditions, using daily-fresh ingredients. Portions balance generosity with quality, ensuring each bite reflects our commitment to culinary authenticity and customer satisfaction for dine-in or takeout.
Salads
Freshly prepared salads feature crisp vegetables and house-made dressings. The Greek Salad combines tomatoes, olives, onions, and feta cheese with a bed of lettuce. Ingredients are sourced daily to maintain peak freshness, offering lighter meal options that still reflect our dedication to northern culinary traditions and Savannah service standards.
Catering
Custom catering packages serve events of all sizes with pizza, subs, pasta, and salads. Orders use the same quality ingredients and recipes as our restaurant. Bulk pricing available for parties, corporate events, or family gatherings. Catering maintains our commitment to fresh, made-daily food and exceptional service experiences.
People
Louis Big Lou Cobello
Founder
Established Screamin' Mimi's in 2007, sharing Philadelphia and Atlantic City pizza traditions in Savannah. Developed secret dough formula over 40 years. Now mentors next generation in family business operations while maintaining quality standards.
Scarlet Mimi Cobello
Co-Founder
Brought Italian-American culinary heritage to Screamin' Mimi's as namesake and original operator. Trained staff in traditional cooking methods from northern kitchens. Maintains involvement in daily operations while passing knowledge to children Louie and Tara.
Louie Cobello
Operator
Second-generation leader continuing family legacy after working in all roles since 2007 opening. Oversees menu development and quality control while maintaining father's equipment and ingredient standards. Focuses on balancing tradition with Savannah locals' needs.
Tara Cobello
Operations Manager
Manages front-of-house operations and customer relations while ensuring family values extend to staff and patrons. Implemented art program to connect with local creatives. Trained directly by parents in business fundamentals from high school onward.
Questions
What makes Screamin Mimis' pizza unique?
Our hand-tossed pizza uses a secret dough formula developed over 40 years, baked in brick ovens with premium cheese and fresh toppings made daily. Recipes originate from Atlantic City and Philadelphia traditions.
Are catering services available?
Yes, we offer custom catering with full menu options. Orders use the same quality ingredients as our restaurant, with pricing structured for events of all sizes.
Why doesn't Screamin Mimis use third-party delivery?
We maintain quality control by handling orders directly through our phone system or in-person, ensuring food arrives at peak freshness without third-party markups or delays.
What menu specials do you offer?
Our lunch special includes two cheese slices and a drink for $5.95. Seasonal items rotate based on ingredient availability while maintaining core recipes from our original menu.
Does Screamin Mimis accept reservations?
We operate on a first-come, first-served basis for dining room and courtyard seating to maintain a casual, spontaneous atmosphere. Wait times peak during lunch and dinner hours.
How does licensing work for new locations?
Our licensing program provides complete operational blueprints including equipment lists, recipes, and training. Contact form submissions receive personal follow-up within 72 hours to discuss expansion opportunities.
Reviews (6)
Cmac McMac
Jan 01, 2022
Report
Update: Dropping from 5 stars to 4 stars. I went here 3 times and 2 out of 3 were good... but one of the times it was like it was a completely different pizza! So I think it's a hit or miss, but when it HITS, it HITS.
Delicious. I love these classic slices. Great prices too. Awesome people.
Delicious. I love these classic slices. Great prices too. Awesome people.
Michelle Magee
Nov 30, 2021
Report
We arrived on a Saturday night and we had a large group with multiple orders. The staff was incredibly friendly and patient with us. The food came out fast and it was delicious. Great pizza, wonderful Italian sub, and very affordable prices. Thank you for a wonderful experience!
S. McOsker
Nov 28, 2021
Report
Went for the first time last night, not sure why we haven't been there before as we have lived here for over a year...we have been missing out! This place is our new favorite for pizza. Great clean pizza flavors with hand-tossed dough that is just the right kind of thin, classic New York/New Jersey style. The garlic cheese bread was on point. And the employees are our kind of unpretentious people. Love it!
Zahrah K. Maynard Jd Llm
Nov 09, 2021
Report
Best pizza in Savannah! We love the New York style thin crust! You get that snap when you fold it. And great, friendly, welcoming staff. Definitely the place to be after Black Friday shopping.
Matt DeWitt
Sep 11, 2021
Report
Excellent crust with both crunch and chew. Tasty sauce and toppings. Baked properly in a slate oven. Definitely a fair price for the product. We will be back.
Jared Shaheen
Sep 09, 2021
Report
Staff was pretty nice. The pizza was really good with a crispy crust . Inside and outside seating. And they are LEO friendly which was nice!! Glad we came by.