Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50 Years
experience
Your Trusted Italian Restaurant in Gatlinburg Since 1976
Since 1976, Best Italian has been dedicated to serving authentic New York-style Italian cuisine in Gatlinburg. Our commitment to traditional recipes and high-quality ingredients ensures every dish reflects the heart of Italian culinary heritage. From golden garlic knots to homemade strawberry cheesecake, we blend classic flavors with modern twists to create memorable dining experiences. Our family-friendly atmosphere welcomes guests to enjoy hearty meals while building connections with the community. With two Parkway locations and catering services, we extend our passion for Italian cuisine to diverse occasions.

Our team takes pride in perfecting signature dishes like oversized calzones and slow-simmered marinara sauces, ensuring each visit celebrates Italian tradition. Decades of experience guide our approach to hospitality, emphasizing fresh ingredients, skilled preparation, and warm service. Whether dining in or ordering catering, customers experience a legacy of flavor that has made us a local favorite for generations.
Services
Italian Restaurant Catering Services Dine-In Takeout Event Catering
Details
  • Year established: 1976
Highlights and features
  • We've perfected New York-style Italian cuisine since 1976
  • Offer catering services for events of all sizes
  • Family-friendly atmosphere with generous portions
  • Homemade recipes using traditional Italian techniques
  • Two convenient Parkway locations in Gatlinburg
Services
Italian Restaurant
Best Italian offers authentic New York-style Italian cuisine with classic dishes like garlic knots, calzones, and homemade cheesecake. Our family-friendly restaurants feature generous portions and traditional recipes perfected since 1976. Guests enjoy both dine-in and takeout options at our two Gatlinburg Parkway locations.
Catering Services
We provide full-service catering for events with menu options including lasagna, baked ziti, and fettuccini alfredo. Our catering includes delivery (with minimum orders), disposable serving ware, and equipment rentals to ensure successful events in Gatlinburg.
New York-Style Pizza
Our signature thin-crust pizzas feature traditional combinations like Margarita and Spicy Italian, plus custom creations with premium toppings. Available in personal, medium, and large sizes with gluten-friendly and cauliflower crust options.
Pasta Dishes
Classic Italian pasta dishes include marinara spaghetti, fettuccini alfredo, and stuffed shells. All pasta meals come with garlic rolls and feature house-made sauces using recipes perfected over four decades of serving Gatlinburg customers.
Appetizers
Start meals with our popular appetizers like mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms, and calamari. These shareable starters feature fresh ingredients and traditional Italian preparation methods, perfect for groups dining together in our restaurants.
Questions
What Italian dishes do you specialize in?
We specialize in New York-style pizzas, garlic knots, calzones, and homemade cheesecake using traditional recipes since 1976.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide catering for events with options like lasagna, baked ziti, and fettuccini alfredo. Minimum orders apply.
Are there kid-friendly menu options?
Yes, our kids menu includes spaghetti marinara, chicken fingers, and personal pizzas starting at $6.99.
What are your restaurant locations?
We have two Parkway locations in Gatlinburg: 710 Parkway and 968 Parkway.
Do you deliver food orders?
Delivery available with 20% charge and $1000 minimum order through our catering services.
Reviews (5)
Shelby
Dec 31, 2021 Report
I would come here for the garlic knots alone, they're so good. The pizza is pretty nice but I preferred the lasagna this time. The cheese bread is a pass for me. Mainly just bread, Hardly cheese.
Andres F. Rodriguez C.
Dec 19, 2021 Report
I expected more from this restaurant. Restrooms were very dirty, service was very slow (not crowded), pizza came cold and not so good, 2 pizza order took more than 1hr and didn't come at the same time (10min delay between pizzas), the carpet in the floor was dirty. Price was very expensive for the quality that we received. I don't recommend this restaurant with all the options that you have in the zone. For sure, not returning here.
Eileen Mata
Nov 17, 2021 Report
We chose this place last minute on a Friday evening. It was not as packed as we thought it would be but the line was a tad bit long, but the food was amazing. The staff as well was very attentive and kind, we were a big group ordering a lot of food and everything was delicious. Would definitely go again.
SaS Campbell
Nov 14, 2021 Report
The food was delicious and the bloody Mary's were outstanding! Same bartender fixing them home made for 25 years, reasonably oriced
Bridgett Bohanon
Oct 17, 2021 Report
The place is kinda small, but you order and seat yourself. Staff is friendly. I got the chicken fettuccine alfredo and is was amazing!! The garlic bread that comes with it had too much garlic for me, but it was still good!! Highly recommended if you are craving Italian!