Business Details
23 Years
experience
Authentic Pizza & Family Fun in Zebulon, GA
American Pie Pizzeria was founded in 2003 by brothers Mark, Joey, Billy, and Matt Lane, who shared a lifelong passion for pizza cultivated during childhood in southern California. Our commitment to quality ingredients, unique recipes, and a welcoming family atmosphere has driven our growth from a single Barnesville, GA location to six thriving pizzerias today. We prioritize customer satisfaction through handcrafted menu items like our signature butter balls and specialty pizzas, ensuring every visit delivers exceptional taste and value.Our dedication to continuous improvement and community engagement has solidified our reputation as a local favorite. Over two decades, we've maintained rigorous standards for food quality and service, reflected in our loyal customer base and expanding footprint. From classic pepperoni to innovative creations like our Baked Potato Pie, our menu caters to diverse tastes while upholding traditional pizza-making excellence. As a family-owned business, we remain focused on creating memorable dining experiences that keep customers returning.
Services
Pizza
Pasta
Wings
Calzones
Salads
Subs
Desserts
Details
- Year established: 2003
Highlights and features
- We offer handcrafted recipes developed over 20 years of pizza-making expertise
- Our menu features 18-inch specialty pizzas with premium toppings like grilled chicken and alfredo sauce
- Family deals provide exceptional value for groups with giant pizzas and sides
- Multiple locations ensure convenient access to fresh, hot meals across Georgia
- Signature items like buffalo-style butter balls showcase our culinary creativity
Services
Pizza
Custom and specialty pizzas with 20+ toppings including pepperoni, grilled chicken, and jalapeos. Available in six sizes from 7" personal to 24" party pies. Signature options like Five Meat Pie and Buffalo Chicken deliver bold flavors through house-made sauces and premium ingredients.
Wings
Freshly prepared chicken wings served in 6, 12, or 20-piece portions with choice of mild, hot, or BBQ sauce. Cooked to order with crispy exteriors and juicy interiors, complemented by house-made ranch or blue cheese dressings for dipping.
Pasta
Traditional Italian pasta dishes featuring house-made marinara and alfredo sauces. Options include Chicken Alfredo with grilled chicken and parmesan, Lasagna layered with meat and cheese, and spaghetti with four homemade meatballs.
Calzones
Hand-rolled dough filled with mozzarella cheese and customizable toppings. Served with marinara sauce for dipping, available plain or upgraded with pizza toppings like pepperoni, sausage, or vegetables.
Salads
Gourmet salads with crisp greens, fresh vegetables, and premium toppings. Choose from classic Caesar, veggie-packed Garden, or hearty options like the Betty Salad with grilled chicken and bacon.
People
Mark Lane
Co-Founder
Mark Lane co-founded American Pie Pizzeria in 2003 after decades of perfecting pizza recipes. His childhood experiences in California inspired the pizzeria's signature flavors and commitment to quality ingredients.
Joey Lane
Co-Founder
Joey Lane helped establish American Pie Pizzeria's family-friendly atmosphere. He focuses on maintaining operational excellence across all six locations while upholding the founders' original vision for authentic pizza.
Questions
What are American Pie Pizzeria's most popular menu items?
Our signature butter balls, especially the buffalo-style version, and specialty pizzas like the Five Meat Pie and Baked Potato Pie consistently rank as customer favorites.
Do you offer family meal deals?
Yes! Our family deal includes a giant pizza, butter balls, and drinks at a discounted price, perfect for feeding groups of all sizes.
Are there vegetarian pizza options available?
Yes, we offer multiple vegetarian options including our Veggie Pie with mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, and green peppers topped with mozzarella cheese.
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Monday-Thursday 11 AM-9 PM, Friday-Saturday 11 AM-10 PM, and closed on Sundays for regular service.
Do you have catering services for events?
While not explicitly stated, our large party pies and family deals make it easy to order catering quantities for special events and gatherings.
Reviews (7)
Gage Dobek
Jan 21, 2022
Report
Very good food and service... buutttt... very high in price. Maybe good for like a once in a blue moon pizza.
Tj Mizel
Jan 19, 2022
Report
Normal buffet pizza not amazing but good.staff asked if we wanted anything specific put out and we asked for bbq and buffalo chicken pizza and they had it out in minutes which is A+ service
Amelia
Nov 26, 2021
Report
Best pizza place in town to me honestly ! We always order the large 24 pizza with a cinnamon pizza and let me tell you the cinnamon pizza is the best !! Weve only had the pepperoni and Hawaiian pizza and theyre both good . Family oriented, friendly staff . Definitely check them out .
Jade Gordy
Nov 13, 2021
Report
THE ONLY PIZZA PLACE I EAT AT!!!!!!! the is AHHHHHMAZING, and everyone that works there is great, and super friendly. LOVE IT!! I highly recommend you try it if you haven't yet!!!
C. L. Holloway
Sep 02, 2021
Report
Monday is all you can eat night and I've been wanting pizza for weeks. So tonight was the perfect time to get some. The price has gone up since the last time I've been on all you can eat night but who hasn't gone up! There are several types of pizza to choose from. It's pizza! Good but not great but I will return! I recommend going! Have a great day
Collyn Archer
Jul 14, 2021
Report
Food is decent. Not a ton of options in the area. My husband and his friends like it. Id probably like it more if they paid attention in the kitchen... Ordering something vegetarian (veggie wrap or asking specifically for no bacon on my pizza) apparently means sprinkle ALL the bacon on my food. 2/3 visits this has happened to me. Im reaching my limit. Not to mention during this last visit my wrap came out 13 minutes after my husbands pizza I had to check to see if they forgot to make it.
Selena Nicholson
May 30, 2021
Report
It was good as far as pizza places go. Our son ordered a calzone, it had very little meat or taste. The same can be said for the rest of the good that we ordered. On a side note, while we waited almost 30-45 minutes for our food to be brought out to us and I understand that it is a pizza place and everything is cooked and made when you order it, I watched one employee go out of the kitchen several times to deliver food to cars&tables,retrieve boxes from the store room,go back into the kitchen and handle food without ever changing his gloves once. He never changed his gloves or washed his hands