Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Authentic Italian Pizza & Dining in Shippensburg, PA
Alfredo's Pizza & Italian Restaurant is a family-owned establishment dedicated to delivering authentic Italian cuisine with a focus on quality and customer satisfaction. Our menu features handcrafted pizza, subs, pasta dishes, calzones, stromboli, and salads, all made with fresh ingredients and dough prepared from scratch daily. We prioritize customer experience by offering competitive pricing, gift certificates, and a welcoming atmosphere with TVs in our dining room. Serving Shippensburg and Cumberland County, we ensure every guest feels valued and enjoys a meal that meets their expectations. Our commitment to excellence extends to delivery and pickup services, with a $15 minimum order for deliveries. With decades of experience in the food industry, we combine traditional recipes and modern service standards to provide a dining experience that reflects our passion for Italian cuisine.

Our team of culinary experts takes pride in preparing every dish with care, ensuring consistency and flavor in every bite. We actively engage with our community, including expressing gratitude to local troops, and strive to maintain our reputation as a trusted neighborhood pizzeria. Our operating hours are designed to accommodate both casual diners and those seeking quick takeout options, with extended evening service on weekends. By focusing on quality ingredients, attentive service, and a comfortable environment, we aim to be the preferred choice for Italian food in the region.
Services
Pizza Subs Pasta Dishes Calzones Stromboli Salads
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned with a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.
  • Fresh ingredients and scratch-made dough for superior taste.
  • Competitive pricing without compromising on quality.
  • TVs in the dining room for a relaxed atmosphere.
  • Serving Shippensburg and Cumberland County with reliable delivery.
Services
Pizza
Our pizzas feature scratch-made dough topped with fresh ingredients and house-prepared sauces. Available in multiple styles including cheese, specialty, and custom-topped options. Perfect for sharing or enjoying as a hearty meal, our pizzas combine traditional Italian flavors with modern creativity to satisfy every palate.
Subs
Hot and cold subs filled with premium meats, cheeses, and vegetables on freshly baked bread. Served with a choice of sides including fries or onion rings. These hearty sandwiches cater to classic tastes while offering unique combinations that showcase our culinary expertise in sandwich preparation.
Pasta Dishes
Handcrafted pasta served with house-made sauces ranging from traditional marinara to specialty blends. Options include baked dishes and sauted preparations featuring fresh ingredients. Each plate demonstrates our commitment to authentic Italian cooking techniques and flavor profiles that transport diners to Italy.
Calzones
Oven-baked dough pockets filled with savory ingredients like meats, cheeses, and vegetables. These portable meals offer a delicious alternative to traditional pizza with the same quality ingredients. Our calzones showcase our kitchen's skill in creating perfectly balanced, flavorful handheld dishes.
Stromboli
Layered meats and cheeses rolled in fresh dough and baked to golden perfection. This Italian-American classic features generous fillings and crisp crusts that highlight our attention to detail. Stromboli provides a satisfying option for those seeking a substantial, flavorful meal with authentic preparation methods.
Questions
What areas do you deliver to?
We deliver to Shippensburg, Cumberland County, and surrounding areas including Orrstown, Newburg, and Scotland. Check our service areas list for full details.
Do you offer lunch specials?
Yes! Enjoy deals like 2 cheese slices with soda for $6.99 or 12" subs with sides and soda starting at $15.99 during our lunch hours (11 AM-3 PM).
Are your ingredients fresh?
Absolutely. We use fresh ingredients daily and make our dough and bread from scratch to ensure quality and flavor in every dish.
What are your operating hours?
We're open Tuesday-Thursday 11 AM-9:30 PM, Friday-Saturday 11 AM-10 PM, and Sunday 11 AM-9 PM. Closed Mondays.
Do you have TVs in the dining room?
Yes, our dining room features TVs for guests to enjoy while dining, creating a relaxed atmosphere for casual meals.
Reviews (7)
Siyanko
Jan 18, 2022 Report
Made a call over the phone. Repeated my order. Was repeated correctly. Picked it up for carry out. Order was wrong. Very disappointed.
Blake Witter
Dec 13, 2021 Report
Absolutely horrible delivery service. Waited awhile for our food which isnt a big deal to us but decided to call and they proceed to lie to us and say its on its way. We live 8 min from the restaurant and its been an hour from the last call.
Sally R.
Nov 15, 2021 Report
Breaded cauliflower. $6.99 not including tax, delivery fee and tip. Not impressed at all. I've had family order this before and they got enough, three people could have shared it. Won't order it again. Bummer
Update... I received a reply from the owner today as he was out of town when I messaged him about this. He is giving me a credit and apologized. New fry cook apparently didn't know the portion size. I realize mistakes happen and we are usually happy with the food we order here, so I'm satisfied and will recommend this restaurant.
Andrew Markel
Aug 22, 2021 Report
Mixed feelings. In my opinion, when small restaurants have this many food options, the quality of the food suffers. This is exactly the case. The good, my crab cake sub was good, not great. The breading was a little too greasy. The chicken ceasar wrap was on point. The bad....their boardwalk fries. They were soggy, unsalted, and it SHOULD BE A CRIME to offer boardwalk fries without having malt vinegar or apple cider vinegar. Tsk freaking tsk. Their regular fries were the most plain fries I've ever had. The bathroom was clean. Maybe get a new urinal because that one has seen better days.
Hugh Mad Bro
Aug 02, 2021 Report
Sooooo GOOD! & the prices are always right, if you want a place Ive ordered from atleast 5 times & have never been dissatisfied this is a must! The Mac & Cheese bites & jalapeo poppers are amazing
Ron Sandifer
Jun 02, 2021 Report
Full menu is not available online. Their 2XL pizza special is $40+ if you order online, not counting delivery fee and tip. But if you order by phone it is $28
2 large pizzas online is $46 total. Never will buy again for delivery and won't make a special trip for their pizza.
Brothers, Red Roster, etc.... all cheaper delivery and all have full menu available.
George Williams
Mar 04, 2021 Report
Nice surprise, the crust has a great texture of chewy and crisp. 14' inch pizza is a great size. Ingredients are fresh and sauce has a good flavor.