Business Details
13 Years
experience
Your Home for Fresh-Baked Goods and Comfort Food in Perrysville
We are a family-owned restaurant and bakery rooted in Amish traditions, serving Perrysville and the surrounding community since 2013. Our journey began in 2008 when Sarah, co-owner, started baking from our home kitchen using her mothers cherished recipes. With a background in supervising bakery operations at Der Dutchman Restaurant, Sarah honed her skills in cake decorating and baking, which now define our signature offerings. Our menu features traditional home-style cooking, including breakfast served all day, hearty lunches, and comforting dinners, all crafted with homemade recipes passed down through generations. We pride ourselves on creating a welcoming atmosphere where families and friends can gather over meals made with care. Our bakery produces fresh pastries, pies, and bread daily, including glazed donuts, cream-filled cream sticks, and custom cakes.Located in a historic blue building on State Route 39 in Perrysville, Ohio, we offer both intimate seating and a large group dining area. Every item on our menu reflects our commitment to quality, authenticity, and the values of hard work and hospitality instilled in us through our upbringing. We source ingredients locally when possible and bake everything from scratch to ensure the highest standards. Our team, led by co-owners Daniel and Sarah Wengerd, approaches every service with dedication to customer satisfaction and community connection. Whether youre stopping in for a morning pastry or reserving our group table for a special occasion, we aim to make every visit memorable through genuine service and delicious food.
Services
Breakfast All Day
Homemade Baked Goods
Group Dining
Wedding Cakes
Takeout Orders
Details
- Year established: 2013
Highlights and features
- We use generations-old Amish baking techniques for authentic flavors.
- Our bakery produces daily fresh pastries, pies, and custom cakes.
- Family-owned since 2005 with deep local community ties.
- Breakfast served all day with made-to-order omelets and pancakes.
- Large group dining area seating up to 20 guests available.
What people say
Amazing homemade pies
Cozy family-friendly vibe
Breakfast all day
Generous portions
Skilled cake decorator
Services
Breakfast All Day
Enjoy hearty breakfast options served throughout the day, including made-to-order omelets, pancakes, and Amish-style baked goods. Our menu blends traditional favorites with homemade touches using family recipes. Perfect for early risers or late brunch enthusiasts seeking comforting flavors.
Homemade Baked Goods
Discover daily-baked pies, cookies, cakes, and specialty breads made from scratch using time-honored techniques. Our bakery offers both classic and seasonal items, including cream-filled cream sticks and fry pies. All products use high-quality ingredients for authentic taste and texture.
Group Dining
Reserve our secluded group area featuring a round table for six or a long table seating up to 20 guests. Ideal for family gatherings, birthdays, or business meetings in a warm, home-style setting. Menus can be customized to accommodate group preferences.
Wedding Cakes
Order handcrafted wedding cakes decorated with precision and artistic flair. Our bakery specializes in intricate designs using techniques perfected during Sarahs tenure at Der Dutchman Restaurant. Available in multiple tiers and flavor combinations to match your special days theme.
Takeout Orders
Place advance takeout orders for fresh-baked goods or hot meals, with confirmation required via phone. Our to-go service ensures you can enjoy home-style cooking at home or on the go. Popular for busy families and event catering needs.
People
Sarah Ann Wengerd
Co-Owner & Head Baker
Sarah learned baking from her Amish mother, who supplied major retailers. She supervised bakery operations at Der Dutchman Restaurant before founding Wedgewing Family Restaurant. Her expertise includes cake decorating and developing recipes that blend tradition with innovation.
Daniel Wengerd
Co-Owner & Business Manager
Daniel provides business leadership and strategic direction, complementing Sarahs culinary skills. He transitioned from Amish life in 2005 to build a family-centered enterprise focused on community engagement and quality-driven service.
Questions
What are your holiday hours?
We close for major holidays like Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve through New Year’s Day, and Labor Day. Check our website for specific dates and schedule changes.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide catering for events with advance notice. Choose from our breakfast, lunch, or dinner menus, and we’ll deliver fresh, home-cooked meals to your location.
Can I order custom cakes?
Absolutely! We create custom wedding and birthday cakes with intricate designs. Consult with Sarah to discuss flavor options, tiers, and decorative details.
Are group reservations available?
Yes, we have two private dining areas seating 6 and 20 guests. Reserve in advance for family gatherings, meetings, or special celebrations.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept cash, credit cards, and mobile payments. Please confirm large group orders by phone at 419-938-0888 for best availability.
Reviews (4)
Michelle Lindsay
Dec 23, 2021
Report
Food was great and our waitress was really sweet. Get there early for best selection of donuts, pies, and other treats to take back home with you--everything we've had there has been delicious!
Patty Secrist
Dec 06, 2021
Report
We had a excellent breakfast my husband loved 😍 their pancakes! I loved their homemade bread!
Meg Seoul Shaker Bazan
Sep 20, 2021
Report
We were staying in town for the Inkarceration festival and initially we try to go for breakfast. We ended up getting there for lunch (1pm) and have an amazing experience. I got the chili with the turkey club, and a meatloaf sandwich. THE FRIES WERE GREAT! All the foods were delicious home cooked flavors. I ended up ordering a chili to take home for dinner too. If you get the chance, go here. ANYTIME of day is a good time.
Robert Woodward
Sep 15, 2021
Report
Oil needs changed, has funky taste to fries and chicken fingers. Hamburger is just a frozen patty cooked up, not freshly made. Waitress was wonderful however.