Business Details
34 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining & Private Events in Garden City, NY
Seventh Street Cafe has been a cornerstone of authentic Italian cuisine in Garden City, NY since 1992. Owned by Victor Scotto, our establishment has maintained a steadfast commitment to regional Italian flavors while evolving with modern culinary trends. In 2017, Mr. Scotto returned to direct operations personally, initiating a comprehensive renovation in 2018 that enhanced our dining spaces while preserving our European ambiance. Our culinary team imports specialty ingredients from Italy daily, including fresh seafood and artisanal products, complemented by organic and gluten-free options. We offer a dynamic menu featuring traditional favorites alongside innovative dishes, supported by a newly expanded bar area and comfortable seating arrangements.Our private and semi-private dining rooms accommodate events up to 80 guests, providing the same exceptional service that made our larger venues renowned. With decades of combined experience in hospitality management, we ensure every guest receives attentive service rooted in Italian tradition. Our team maintains rigorous quality standards through regular menu updates and staff training programs. We prioritize customer satisfaction through transparent communication and flexible event planning options. Our establishment continues to earn recognition for maintaining culinary excellence while adapting to contemporary dining expectations.
Services
Private Dining
Catering Services
Lunch Service
Dinner Service
Weekend Brunch
Take-Out Orders
Event Planning
Gluten-Free Options
Organic Dishes
Wine Pairing
Details
- Year established: 1992
Highlights and features
- We've specialized in authentic Italian cuisine for over 30 years
- Daily fresh seafood flown in from Italian coastal regions
- Private dining rooms accommodate events up to 80 guests
- Imported specialty ingredients from Italy's premier producers
- Award-winning service maintained by experienced hospitality professionals
What people say
Spectacular food
Perfectly coordinated reception
Daily fresh seafood
Beautiful private rooms
Authentic Italian flavors
Services
Private Dining Rooms
Our elegantly designed private and semi-private rooms accommodate events from 20 to 80 guests. The Victoria Room offers complete privacy for 80, while the Garden Room features natural light for 64. The 20-Table facilitates intimate group interaction for parties up to 26 guests.
Italian Catering
We provide full-service catering for weddings and corporate events featuring our renowned Italian cuisine. Options include plated meals, buffets, and custom menus with gluten-free and vegetarian selections. Our team coordinates all event details from menu planning to table settings.
Daily Dining
Enjoy lunch Tuesday-Friday 11:30am-4pm, dinner Tuesday-Sunday starting at 4pm, and weekend brunch Saturday-Sunday 10am-3pm. Our menu features traditional Italian dishes made with imported ingredients and daily fresh seafood flown in from coastal regions.
Take-Out Orders
Order our full menu for take-out through our website or DoorDash. Available options include family-style trays serving 4-6 people, cold/hot appetizers, salads, and main courses. Special pricing available for pre-packaged meal trays.
Gluten-Free Options
We offer comprehensive gluten-free dining options including pasta, entrees, and desserts. Our kitchen maintains separate preparation areas to prevent cross-contamination. Gluten-free alternatives available for all menu items upon request.
People
Victor Scotto
Owner
Victor Scotto has owned Seventh Street Cafe since 1992 and returned to direct operations in 2017. With decades of experience in the hospitality industry, he oversees daily operations and maintains culinary standards through regular menu updates and staff training programs.
Questions
What are your regular operating hours?
We're open Tuesday-Sunday: Lunch 11:30am-4pm, Dinner from 4pm, and Weekend Brunch 10am-3pm. Closed Mondays.
Do you offer private event spaces?
Yes, we have four private and semi-private rooms accommodating 20-80 guests with customized catering options available.
Are gluten-free options available?
Yes, we provide comprehensive gluten-free alternatives for all menu items including pasta, entrees, and desserts.
Can I order take-out or delivery?
Yes, full menu take-out available through our website or DoorDash. Family trays and pre-packaged options serve 4-6 people.
What makes your Italian cuisine authentic?
We import specialty ingredients daily from Italy, use traditional recipes, and maintain culinary techniques passed down through generations.
Do you cater weddings and large events?
Yes, we specialize in intimate weddings and corporate events with customized menus, table settings, and full-service coordination.
Reviews (4)
Ben Bilder
Jan 27, 2022
Report
The 4 of us went for a mid week lunch. First time there, no one had anything negative to say. Can't wait to go back.
Rachel Doherty
Jan 16, 2022
Report
Lovely Christmas Eve meal. Cafe was cozy and nicely decorated for the holidays. Service was good. Food was above average. Only complaint was there were some fruit flies buzzing around our wine glasses which took away from the experience a little bit.
Kacper Czajkowski
Nov 17, 2021
Report
Awful Customer service. We had made a reservation for my mothers bday. When we arrived we were told it wasnt ready it would be 10-15 minutes. 30 minutes later we were still not seated after being told multiple Times few minutes. After 40 minutes we told them thank you we were leaving. The gentleman in charge of seating people gave my wife and sister in law an attitude like they were doing us a favor by dining here at this establishment. Extremely rude and unprofessional. If you dont know how to treat customers and dont enjoy your job dont work in this industry and save yourself and everyone
Milosz Balcerzak
Nov 02, 2021
Report
Disappointing Experience overall. Held 7th Street Cafe in high regard for many years. For a high end Italian restaurant it did not deliver as expected. Paid over $500 for a 7 member family event. I understand staffing is a problem but staff was not professional. No check backs and rude. Food was okay. Fresh Mozzarella was definitely not made freshly. And over the years Ive had great Mozzarella there. The plate presentation was lackluster at best. Most likely we will be taking our family someplace else going forward.
