Business Details
42 Years
experience
Custom Trophies & Engraving Services in Neenah, WI
All-Sport Trophy & Engraving has been a trusted provider of custom awards and recognition items in Neenah and the Fox Valley since 1984. Founded by Dean Kaufert, who balanced running the business with a full-time job in his early years, we've grown from a small shop to a larger facility on Cecil Street while maintaining our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Our team brings decades of combined experience to crafting personalized trophies, medals, plaques, and engraved items for individuals, schools, businesses, and government organizations. Jon Vanderheyden, owner since 1999, emphasizes the importance of exceeding customer expectations through meticulous attention to detail and creative solutions. Judy Menning, a team member since 1990, highlights our strong relationships with local businesses and organizations as a cornerstone of our success.We specialize in creating meaningful recognition pieces for sporting events, professional achievements, and commemorative occasions. Our engraving expertise spans multiple materials including glass, metal, and wood, ensuring precision and durability. With a history of serving notable clients like the State of Wisconsin and Kimberly Clark, we combine tradition with modern customization techniques. Our physical store in Neenah allows for personalized consultations while maintaining quick turnaround times for urgent requests. Through three decades of operation, we've remained dedicated to helping clients celebrate excellence through tangible, lasting awards.
Services
Trophies & Medals
Plaques & Awards
Gifts
Engraving
Signs & Name Tags
Details
- Year established: 1984
Highlights and features
- 30+ years of specialized experience in custom award creation
- Expert engraving on multiple materials including metal and glass
- Proven track record serving government organizations and major corporations
- Quick turnaround times for urgent award needs
- Personalized service from experienced local business owners
Services
Trophies & Medals
We create custom trophies and medals for all sports and competitions. Our extensive selection includes options for baseball, soccer, football, and niche activities like archery and billiards. Each piece is crafted to celebrate athletic achievement with lasting quality.
Plaques & Awards
Professional achievement and commemorative plaques are our specialty. We design personalized recognition pieces for businesses, government organizations, and special events. Our expertise ensures each plaque perfectly captures the significance of the occasion.
Custom Engraving
Our engraving services work with multiple materials including plastic, glass, metal, and wood. We provide precise, durable engravings for awards, signs, and personalized gifts. This service transforms ordinary items into meaningful keepsakes with professional quality.
Gifts
We offer custom gift solutions for special occasions. From wine accessories to housewarming and wedding gifts, our team helps find unique, memorable presents. Each item can be customized through engraving or other personalization techniques.
Signs & Name Tags
Our sign creation includes name tags, monument plaques, and flag boxes. We produce professional identification solutions for businesses and organizations. These durable products serve both functional and decorative purposes across various settings.
People
Jon Vanderheyden
Owner
Owner since 1999 with 20 years of experience. Passionate about exceeding customer expectations through creative custom award solutions. Prioritizes quality craftsmanship and client satisfaction in every project.
Judy Menning
Team Member
Part-time employee since 1990. Values long-standing relationships with local businesses and organizations. Provides continuity in customer service and product knowledge through decades of experience.
Questions
What types of custom awards do you create?
We specialize in trophies, medals, plaques, and engraved items for sports, corporate recognition, and commemorative events. Our selection includes options for both common and niche activities.
Can you engrave on different materials?
Yes, we engrave on plastic, glass, aluminum, stainless steel, brass, acrylic, and wood with professional precision and durability.
Do you offer quick turnaround times?
We prioritize timely delivery while maintaining quality. Our experience allows us to handle urgent requests efficiently while meeting client expectations.
What local businesses have you worked with?
We've served the State of Wisconsin, Kimberly Clark, Neenah and Menasha city governments, and numerous local school districts over our 30+ year history.
How do you handle custom requests?
We work closely with clients to understand their vision. Our team provides expert guidance to create personalized awards that exceed expectations through creative solutions.