Business Details
Tony's Pizzeria / Sports Bar / Sports Bar - Fresh Pizza & Wings in Washington Mills
Tony's Pizzeria / Sports Bar / Sports Bar has been serving Washington Mills, NY with fresh, high-quality food since our establishment. We specialize in handcrafted pizzas, savory wings, hearty subs, and classic Italian dishes made from the freshest ingredients available. Our menu features a wide variety including house specials like grilled reuben sandwiches, fish fry, baked ziti, and calzones. We offer convenient delivery across a broad service area covering Sauquoit, Casville, New York Mills, and surrounding neighborhoods. Our sports bar atmosphere provides the perfect setting for game days or casual dining with friends and family.We maintain strict quality control over every dish we serve, from our homemade sauces to our crispy golden fries. Our experienced team takes pride in delivering exceptional customer service, whether you're ordering takeout or dining in. We've built our reputation on consistency, using time-tested recipes that keep customers returning. Our luncheon catering options make us a reliable choice for events and gatherings. We operate seven days a week with extended hours to accommodate busy schedules, closing only three days annually for major holidays.
Services
Pizza
Wings
Subs
Pasta
Calzones
Catering
Delivery
Highlights and features
- We use fresh, high-quality ingredients in all our Italian dishes
- Our menu features 20+ specialty items including house-made calzones
- We deliver to 8+ neighborhoods across Washington Mills and surrounding areas
- Our sports bar atmosphere enhances game day dining experiences
- We maintain consistent quality across 30+ menu options
What people say
Fantastic, phenomenal place
Awesome food
Great prices
Excellent service
Second order guarantee
Services
Pizza
Our pizza menu features classic and specialty options made with house-prepared dough and sauces. Each pie uses premium toppings and is baked to golden perfection. Customers appreciate our consistent quality across traditional favorites and unique creations.
Wings
We serve crispy, golden-brown wings available in multiple sauce varieties. The NFL game special offers 10 wings for $5.99 with a choice of sauces. Our wings consistently receive praise for their flavor and portion sizes.
Subs
Our sub menu includes both cold and hot options featuring premium meats and fresh ingredients. Popular selections range from classic turkey and roast beef to specialty items like meatball parm and chicken parm. All subs use house-baked bread.
Pasta
We prepare traditional Italian pasta dishes including baked ziti, manicotti, and ravioli. Each order features house-made sauces and quality ingredients. Our pasta portions consistently satisfy regular customers seeking authentic Italian flavors.
Calzones
Our calzones feature crispy dough filled with premium ingredients like sausage, chicken, and pepperoni. These handheld meals maintain freshness whether eaten in-house or delivered. Regular customers praise their generous fillings and golden crusts.
Questions
What types of pizza do you offer?
We serve classic cheese, pepperoni, and specialty pizzas like our house-made baked ziti pie using fresh ingredients.
Do you deliver to Sauquoit?
Yes, our delivery range includes Sauquoit and surrounding areas during regular business hours.
What are your operating hours?
We're open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, closing only for Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter.
Do you accept credit cards?
We accept all major credit cards for both in-person and online orders.
What catering options do you have?
Our luncheon catering includes pizza, subs, and pasta dishes for events of various sizes with advance ordering.
Reviews (6)
Trevor Simzer
Jan 18, 2022
Report
Horrible place to get food, ordered online for delivery they had no problem taking my money, but when I call they said delivery is closed my order was basically never placed because of it, never notified me and still took my money
Modern Day Apostle
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Very sorry to report that the chicken tenders were literally raw. I am only posting this in hopes of preventing this from happening to another customer and help them improve their cooking methods.
Mike Amante
Oct 11, 2021
Report
A very nice deal I found here lately$5.99 for 10 wings during any NFL game! You cant beat those prices anywhere in the area and the menu features a wide variety of sauces to choose from as well!
Chris Tarbox
Sep 29, 2021
Report
$1.25 slices Mondays and Tuesdays, great selections always available. My favorite is buffalo chicken or garlic broccoli. Lots of other great choices.
Michelle Wiggins
Aug 23, 2021
Report
Tony's Pizzeria in Washington Mills went above and beyond for our order! I missed the delivery driver's call inquiring about exact location to deliver to. After checking my messages,I returned his call. He made a second trip to deliver our food. The food was awesome(and hot). I believe Tony's made a second exact order for us!
Sarah Carpenter
Aug 11, 2021
Report
Just ordered pizza and wings & the pizza was inedible. You can see in the picture the crust is so thin and dry it was cracking. Tasted like gritty cardboard. We have ordered from here numerous times, not sure if there has been a recent change in ownership but it feels as though they stuck a frozen pizza in the microwave and charged $12 for it. Wings were okay, but not at all the quality we are used to.