Business Details
Authentic New York Brick Oven Pizza in Columbus
Cerrone's Brick Oven Pizzeria was founded by fourth-generation Italian-Americans who sought to bring authentic New York brick oven pizza to Columbus. Our family heritage traces back to Giovanni and Carmello Cerrone, who immigrated through Ellis Island in the early 1900s, carrying with them culinary traditions that have been preserved across generations. We spent months perfecting our recipes in New York before introducing Columbus to our handcrafted pizzas made from fresh imported Italian ingredients and domestic produce. Our wood-fired brick oven, transported from New York, ensures traditional preparation methods that have earned us international recognition. We maintain a commitment to quality through daily preparation of all menu items, from our house-made dough to our hand-pinched sausage.Our passion for authentic Italian cuisine extends beyond pizza to include classic pasta dishes, calzones, and desserts like Brooklyn-style cannoli. The restaurant's atmosphere reflects our dedication to family values and hospitality, creating an environment where guests experience genuine Italian culture. Our team combines technical expertise with decades of hands-on experience in traditional pizza-making techniques. We prioritize customer satisfaction through consistent quality, transparent ingredient sourcing, and exceptional service standards. This dedication has resulted in multiple awards at the International Pizza Challenge, validating our commitment to culinary excellence.
Services
Brick Oven Pizza
Calzones
Pasta Dishes
Appetizers
Desserts
Craft Beer Selection
Highlights and features
- We offer fourth-generation Italian-American pizza-making expertise
- Our wood-fired oven and New York ingredients ensure authentic preparation
- Multiple international pizza competition awards validate our quality
- Daily fresh preparation of all menu items from scratch
- Family heritage combined with modern culinary techniques
What people say
Best pizzas ever tasted
Superb cooking style
Excellent staff
Amazing dinner experience
Authentic pasta
Services
Brick Oven Pizza
Authentic New York-style pizzas cooked in a wood-fired brick oven transported from New York. We use imported Italian ingredients and traditional preparation methods passed down through four generations. Each pizza features hand-stretched dough and fresh toppings prepared daily.
Calzones
Handcrafted calzones filled with premium ingredients using the same dough as our award-winning pizzas. Available in specialty varieties or custom combinations with traditional Italian fillings. Served with house-made marinara for dipping.
Pasta Dishes
Classic Italian pasta preparations featuring house-made spaghetti and traditional recipes from the Abruzzo region. Dishes include meatballs prepared from family recipes and specialty sauces made daily using fresh ingredients and time-honored techniques.
Appetizers
Hand-crafted appetizers featuring garlic cheese bread, meatballs cooked in brick oven marinara, and fresh caprese salad with burrata mozzarella. All starters use house-made components and traditional Italian preparation methods passed through generations.
Desserts
Authentic Italian desserts including Brooklyn-imported cannoli shells filled with house-made ricotta cream and cinnamon knots with butter cream icing. All desserts follow traditional recipes and preparation methods from our family's Italian heritage.
Questions
What makes your pizza authentic New York-style?
Our pizza uses a wood-fired brick oven from New York with imported Italian ingredients and traditional recipes perfected over four generations.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide catering for events with our award-winning pizzas, pasta dishes, and Italian specialties for gatherings of all sizes.
Are there gluten-free options available?
We offer gluten-free pizza crusts and select menu items to accommodate dietary restrictions while maintaining authentic Italian flavors.
What awards have you won?
We've placed in the International Pizza Challenge multiple times, including 3rd place in the Southeast and 10th globally in our division.
Do you deliver outside Columbus?
Delivery is available within Columbus through our online ordering platforms, with pickup and local delivery options for all menu items.
Reviews (7)
Floyd Moon
Dec 18, 2021
Report
My party had the cauliflower (gluten-free) crust, and it was delicious! Both the taste and texture were like "real" thin-crust pizza. They have a wide selection of toppings, and the high quality is apparent. The staff were very friendly and courteous. I would definitely go back for another!
Zach Steinsberger
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Cerrones hands down has the best New York style pizza. You can tell that the ingredients they use are quality ingredients. Hands down recommend to anyone traveling through or to anyone thats been in the town a while. Great job guys.
Chris Collier
Aug 28, 2021
Report
Ate here Aug 16, 2021 and the pizza was the Best! The service was absolutely great as always but the pizza was definitely on Point! Had the Buffalo Chicken pizza and a cheese bread. It's always a great experience supporting a small business like this!
Angie White
Jul 17, 2021
Report
I ordered online through their website. I got there a little early but they were extremely busy. My food was ready at the exact moment that my confirmation email said it would be ready. I ordered the meatballs and a Supreme pizza. Let me tell you, it was no less than amazing. The meatballs were HUGE and so tasty. And the pizza was delicious. My husband doesn't like bell peppers but he said it was so good, even with bell peppers. Definitely 5 stars.
Noel Lucas
Dec 31, 2020
Report
Stopped by for lunch with my son today while letting him play hooky from school and let him have a fun day. We have been wanting to try it out for a while, but always forgot about it. When we walked in, you could tell it was going to be something special, just from the "vibe" and looks of the place. If you are a pizza connoisseur, the menu will be a pleasant surprise alone, based on the wide variety.
I've always been a huge fan of Mellow Mushroom's Buffalo Chicken pizza with bacon. So, with that high standard, I ordered a small version of it here, and my son went with the old reliable small pepperoni
I've always been a huge fan of Mellow Mushroom's Buffalo Chicken pizza with bacon. So, with that high standard, I ordered a small version of it here, and my son went with the old reliable small pepperoni
Resting Sad Face
Jul 30, 2020
Report
My family and I have been coming here for about three years now, and for good reason. we absolutely love it. I can say without a doubt that this is our favorite pizza place, easily that best pizza Ive had in my life. my mother and I come here weekly to eat and relax, and the environment does provide the atmosphere. we love the staff and always feel welcome. incredibly friendly and open. 10/10 would recommend :)
ps. Shauns the real og
We will miss you guys. There is no other Pizza like yours
ps. Shauns the real og
We will miss you guys. There is no other Pizza like yours
Michele Kendall
Jun 04, 2020
Report
Great authentic NY style pizza! We had the spicy Hawaiian. You can taste the freshness of all of the ingredients and can tell that the dough and sauce are from scratch. Best pizza we've had in a very long time!