Business Details
21 Years
experience
Gourmet Brick-Oven Pizza & Catering in Cornelius, NC
Since 2005, Prosciutto's Pizza has been a family-owned cornerstone of the Cornelius community, dedicated to serving gourmet New York-style brick-oven pizzas and Italian-inspired cuisine. Founded by Joel and Kelly Pfyffer, our establishment combines decades of culinary expertise with a commitment to using premium ingredients, ensuring every dish reflects our passion for authenticity and quality. Our menu features handcrafted pizzas, calzones, pastas, and salads, complemented by catering services for weddings and events. We prioritize creating a welcoming atmosphere where guests experience both exceptional food and the warmth of family tradition.With options like gluten-free cauliflower crusts and zucchini noodle substitutions, we cater to diverse dietary needs while maintaining our focus on flavor. Our team takes pride in delivering personalized service, whether through daily operations or large-scale catering, ensuring every customer feels valued. Recognized for our community involvement, we strive to exceed expectations through consistent quality, transparency, and a dedication to customer satisfaction that has sustained us for nearly two decades.
Services
Brick-Oven Pizzas
Gourmet Calzones
Catering Services
Italian Pastas
Salads
Sandwiches
Wings & Tenders
Desserts
Beverages
Party Platters
Details
- Year established: 2005
Highlights and features
- We offer handcrafted New York-style pizzas made with premium ingredients since 2005.
- Our family-owned operation ensures personalized attention to every customer and event.
- We provide gluten-free and vegetarian options without compromising authentic Italian flavor.
- Our catering team specializes in customized menus for weddings and special occasions.
- We maintain consistent quality through direct oversight from founding owners Joel and Kelly.
What people say
Phenomenal service
Excellent barbecue pizza
Great pizza
Worth the price
Friendly service
Services
Brick-Oven Pizzas
Our signature New York-style pizzas are baked in traditional brick ovens at high temperatures, ensuring a perfectly crisp crust with a chewy interior. We use imported Italian ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella, offering both classic and innovative combinations. Customers appreciate the consistent quality and attention to detail that make each slice memorable.
Catering Services
We specialize in full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties with customizable menus featuring our most popular dishes. Our team handles everything from setup to cleanup, offering both on-site preparation and delivery options. Clients value our flexibility in accommodating dietary restrictions and creating unique dining experiences tailored to their vision.
Gourmet Calzones
Handmade calzones filled with premium ingredients like shaved steak, prosciutto, and fresh vegetables provide a satisfying, portable meal option. Each calzone uses the same high-quality dough as our pizzas, baked to golden perfection with melted cheese and savory fillings. Regular customers highlight these as a standout menu item that exceeds typical takeout expectations.
Italian Pastas
From traditional spaghetti with meatballs to specialty dishes like Florentine pasta with spinach and white wine cream sauce, our pasta menu showcases authentic Italian flavors. We use fresh ingredients and house-made sauces, with options for gluten-free and vegetarian diets. Diners appreciate the generous portions and rich flavor profiles that elevate classic comfort food.
Wings & Tenders
Fresh jumbo wings and tenders are available in 12 unique flavors from classic buffalo to Caribbean jerk, served with house-made dipping sauces. We offer portion sizes ranging from 5-piece appetizers to large catering trays, with options for boneless tenders to suit different preferences. Reviewers consistently mention these as some of the best wings in the Lake Norman area.
People
Joel Pfyffer
Co-Owner
Joel co-founded Prosciutto's Pizza in 2005 with his wife Kelly, bringing decades of hospitality experience to ensure consistent quality and customer satisfaction.
Kelly Pfyffer
Co-Owner
Kelly Pfyffer co-owns Prosciuttos with Joel, overseeing daily operations and maintaining the family-oriented atmosphere that defines the restaurant's community reputation.
Questions
What type of pizza does Prosciuttos offer?
We specialize in New York-style brick-oven pizzas with both traditional and innovative toppings, including gluten-free cauliflower crust options.
Do you cater events outside the restaurant?
Yes, our catering team provides on-site service for weddings and special events with customizable menus featuring our most popular dishes.
Are there vegetarian or gluten-free options available?
We offer zucchini noodle substitutions, gluten-free cauliflower crust pizzas, and multiple vegetarian-friendly menu items to accommodate dietary needs.
What catering sizes do you accommodate?
Our catering services range from small gatherings to large events, with party platters and full-service options serving dozens of guests.
Do you offer takeout or delivery services?
Yes, we provide both pickup and delivery options for our full menu, including family-style platters and individual meals.
Reviews (7)
Jane Z.
Aug 29, 2021
Report
Best calzone I've ever had! The crust was exceptional, and the ricotta and spinach filling was delicious.
Rusty J.
Jul 24, 2021
Report
This place did a lot things right during our visit. The food was good and the service very good. I'll go back! We chose this place because they participate in a coupon fundraising book. The pictures and menu made us want to try it out We were not disappointed. We entered and were told to pick a table anywhere. Our server took our drink orders and answered a few food related questions. Gabrielle ended up being a fantastic server with a pleasant personality. I ordered a cocktail. The bartended didn't know the drink but came out to our table and we pulled up a recipe on
Michael N.
Jun 16, 2021
Report
"Pros" is a Cornelius gem. Great Italian, salads, pizza and the best wings around. More wing sauce choices than anywhere. Great atmosphere for families and just as good for sports events.
Tom M.
Jan 30, 2021
Report
Awful food, decent drink prices but the drinks were mediocre at best. We ordered the pizza (bar tender recommended the pizza). I've had at least a half a dozen frozen pizzas that were better than this pizza. Really cheap ingredients, poorly cooked, bad dough.
Lisa D.
Jan 24, 2021
Report
How can 1 place serve such a different pizza. This was our second time ordering from here. 1st time was fantastic... today was awful!!! 1 large pie with pepperoni. How thin and tough can pizza actually be? I've never seen anything so thin. It tasted like they had made it hours before and threw pepperoni on it and reheated it!!! This definitely turned us off from ever going back!!!
Khalil S.
Jan 16, 2021
Report
Heather was amazing! The restaurant felt safe and clean. Went with the Boston Cheesesteak Pizza. Turned out pretty good. Perfect temp and balance of ingredients. I didn't discover this business is a fan of the New England Patriots. As an Indianapolis Colts fan I'm confused about whether or not I'm allowed to like the dining experience at this point. I can't front though it was very good. I'd definitely come back the next time I'm in town.
Duncan M.
Jan 12, 2021
Report
Sometimes when you're out looking for a new place for pizza, you get lucky. This afternoon, we did. There is a small, strip mall in Cornelius that has several restaurants plus an Orvis fly fishing shop and a consignment shop with pretty good furniture items. The gem is the restaurant called Prosciuto's Pizza.
It's a pretty standard bar with tables, socially distanced, some beer and wine (good options on both), and an exceptional pizza menu. That said, this is thin crust and everyone won't like that but if you do......you have tremendous options for your pizza. Start with red
It's a pretty standard bar with tables, socially distanced, some beer and wine (good options on both), and an exceptional pizza menu. That said, this is thin crust and everyone won't like that but if you do......you have tremendous options for your pizza. Start with red