Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Custom Rebuildable Mattresses | Comfort Option
Comfort Option was founded in 1952 with a mission to revolutionize the mattress industry by prioritizing personalized comfort over one-size-fits-all solutions. With over 70 years of combined expertise in foam and bedding, our team crafts customized, rebuildable mattresses tailored to individual sleep preferences. Our locally handcrafted products, made in Indiana, emphasize transparency, durability, and innovative design. We guide customers through a personalized process, from in-store testing to final delivery, ensuring satisfaction at every step.

Our commitment to quality materials and customer-centric service has made us a trusted name in sleep solutions. We offer free shipping, returns, and financing options to enhance accessibility. By focusing on education and hands-on experience, we empower customers to make informed decisions about their sleep health.
Services
Custom Mattresses Alpha Mattresses Pillows Toppers Replacement Covers
Details
  • Year established: 1952
Highlights and features
  • We offer 70+ years of combined expertise in foam and bedding innovation.
  • Our mattresses are locally handcrafted in Indiana for quality assurance.
  • We provide free shipping, returns, and in-store customization trials.
  • Our team guides you through a personalized comfort test for perfect fit.
  • We prioritize transparency in materials and pricing with no hidden fees.
What people say
Best mattress I've ever had Custom build your mattress Knowledgeable, responsive team Life-changing pillow Stress-free experience
Services
Custom Mattresses
Our custom mattresses are engineered to match individual sleep preferences, including firmness, density, and pressure relief. Using high-resilience and hybrid foams, we ensure durability and comfort. Ideal for side, back, or stomach sleepers seeking personalized support.
Alpha Mattresses
The Alpha series offers pre-configured mattresses optimized for balance between cost and quality. These models use memory foam and conventional foam layers to deliver consistent comfort at accessible price points.
Pillows
Our pillows complement customized mattresses with adjustable support for neck alignment. Available in multiple densities, they enhance sleep posture for side, back, and stomach sleepers through adaptive foam technology.
Toppers
Toppers add an extra layer of comfort to existing mattresses using high-resilience foam. They improve pressure relief and temperature regulation, extending the lifespan of your current bedding with minimal investment.
Replacement Covers
Replacement covers provide hypoallergenic protection against spills and wear. Designed for easy removal and cleaning, they maintain hygiene while preserving the integrity of custom or Alpha series mattresses.
Questions
How does the mattress customization process work?
We use a comfort test to determine your sleep preferences, then let you test configurations in-store until you find your perfect match.
Do you offer trial periods for mattresses?
Yes, we provide free in-store trials with no time limit to ensure your complete satisfaction before purchase.
Are financing options available?
Yes, we offer financing plans to make customized mattresses more accessible without compromising quality.
What areas do you serve?
We serve Indianapolis, IN, with local manufacturing and nationwide shipping for all products.
What are your store hours?
Our Indianapolis retail store is open Monday-Saturday 10am-7pm and Sunday 12pm-5pm.
Reviews (5)
Elizabeth Arehart
Dec 31, 2021 Report
We found Comfort Option through mattress review enthusiasts online yes, thats a thing so we had no idea what to expect. Ian and the other folks we talked to were super nice and happy to take time to help us understand the products.
Shipping was a breeze, and when we realized we needed a different layer, the company was very accommodating. They made appropriate suggestions and now we have a comfortable mattress thats just right. Its a little scary to order a mattress online, but the people at Comfort Option made all the difference, with no pushy sales tactics.
Nik Tay
Dec 30, 2021 Report
This is the most comfortable mattress weve ever owned and cost 1/3 of our previous ones. Its so insanely well made that after almost a year, not one stitch has unraveled not one flat spot or weird lump popped up on my big guys side like Temperpedic! The fact that you can customize it is a huge plus and their customer service is top notch!! Great company, great people! Will be putting another order soon.
Levi
Dec 27, 2021 Report
A Casper hurt my back. Two of the high-end Tempur-Pedics were better but still put too much pressure on my shoulders and hips. Comfort Option's softest option was the best I'd tried thus far, but still wasn't quite there. I was sent a new layer immediately and have been happy ever since. I never expected to find a mattress I actually loved, but it seems I have. Thanks very much for being so communicative and accommodating.
Kathryn Waite
Dec 04, 2021 Report
Absolutely LOVE our mattress! We chose Comfort Option because of the versatility in the mattress options but we were pleasantly surprised by how wonderful our experience was with the customer service team! They promptly answered our initial questions during the buying process, quickly worked to fix an issue we had with our delivery, and made time to follow up with us to make sure our new mattress was to our liking. Biggest piece of advice: if you are someone who sleeps warm - get the Cool Coat!!! The mattress keeps you snug and warm so the coating helps! I would recommend this brand to anyone on
DaveW
Nov 18, 2021 Report
Having never previously purchased a mattress online before, I limited my search to those that could be modified to be softer or firmer if the original mattress ordered was less than ideal. I read good things about the foam quality used by Comfort Option, and after exploring their website decided to use their email option to inquire as to what might be the best comfort layer options might be best for both myself and spouse. Ian promptly emailed me back and asked a lot of questions about my preferences and sleeping characteristics. He ended up recommending a combination I would never have ordered