Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Authentic Wood-Fired Pizza in Kittery, Maine
When Pigs Fly Pizzeria has been crafting exceptional wood-fired pizzas since 2025, combining traditional Neapolitan techniques with modern culinary innovation. Our kitchen utilizes all-natural ingredients, including mozzarella made fresh daily, to create pizzas with chewy, smoky crusts in a distinctive brick oven environment. Located in Kittery, Maine, our 160-seat establishment features multiple dining options including a screened-in farmer's porch, outdoor seating area, and a dedicated beer and wine bar.

We maintain strict quality control across our menu offerings, which include over fifteen pizza varieties, artisanal starters, and signature desserts. Our staff prioritizes customer satisfaction through attentive service while maintaining operational transparency regarding reservations and seating policies. The adjacent Company Store extends our culinary expertise to retail products, offering classic and artisan breads for take-home enjoyment.
Services
Wood-fired pizza Craft beer service Wine bar Takeout orders Outdoor dining Company store Lunch service Dinner service
Details
  • Year established: 2025
Highlights and features
  • We use fresh mozzarella made daily in-house
  • Our wood-fired ovens create distinctive smoky crusts
  • We offer 15+ unique pizza selections with rotating specials
  • Our menu features house-made breads and artisanal ingredients
  • We maintain strict ingredient quality control standards
What people say
Exceptional wood-fired pizzas Unique smoky flavor Ample seating options Fresh ingredients Knowledgeable staff
Services
Wood-Fired Pizza
Our Neapolitan-style pizzas feature handcrafted dough cooked in wood-fired ovens at 800F. Fresh mozzarella, house-made sauces, and premium toppings create distinctive flavor profiles. The high-heat cooking process produces a charred crust with chewy texture while preserving ingredient freshness.
Craft Beer Service
We offer a curated selection of craft beers served in our dedicated beer and wine bar area. The menu features local and regional brews complementing our pizza offerings. Our knowledgeable staff provides pairing recommendations for optimal flavor combinations.
Outdoor Dining
Our outdoor space includes a screened-in farmer's porch and open-air seating with picnic tables. The climate-controlled porch allows year-round enjoyment while the open area provides casual dining options. Reservations aren't accepted for outdoor seating.
Company Store
Adjacent to the restaurant, our retail store sells artisan breads and prepared foods for take-home consumption. Customers can purchase the same quality products used in our kitchen, including signature bread varieties and specialty ingredients.
Takeout Orders
We provide online ordering for takeout service with pickup at our Kittery location. The menu includes full restaurant offerings with packaging designed to preserve food quality. Picnic tables are available in the parking lot for immediate consumption.
Questions
What type of pizza does When Pigs Fly Pizzeria make?
We specialize in Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizzas cooked at 800°F in brick ovens, featuring handcrafted dough and fresh ingredients.
Do you offer gluten-free options?
Yes, we can prepare many menu items gluten-free, though some selections may not be suitable for celiac customers.
Can I make reservations at your Kittery location?
We don't accept reservations, but parties of 8+ can call 20 minutes prior to arrival to join our wait list.
Are pets allowed at the restaurant?
Due to legal requirements, dogs aren't permitted in our roped outdoor dining area, but you may order takeout and use our parking lot picnic tables.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards and mobile payment options for both dine-in and takeout orders.
Do you sell retail products from your bakery?
Yes, our Company Store offers the same artisan breads and specialty products used in our restaurant for take-home enjoyment.
Reviews (5)
Shane L.
Jan 27, 2022 Report
I thought that this establishment has always been welcoming and inviting to all guests traveling to and from the outlets and NH areas. The food is always fresh and the service is always spot on. You would think that with the fact that this is a semi-touristy place, that it would take away from the experience but it really does not hamper the small town scratch baking and cook feel and we love coming here. Another plus about this place is the beer list. I feel that there are different types from all over the New England area. This time that I came here I had the brussel sprouts as an app and
Tim A.
Jan 26, 2022 Report
Ordered the pizza again. If you haven't been there yet you need to go. The pizza is crazy good and fresh. Perfect crust. All their food is really good. Service is excellent. Great family atmosphere.
Sara S.
Jan 22, 2022 Report
Delicious wood-fired pizzas, salads, sandwiches and a great selection of local beers. On Sundays you can order brunch pizza, with eggs and bacon! Large capacity dining room with enclosed porch, and plenty of outdoor seating in summer. Stop into the adjoining store for fresh-baked breads and cookies. Don't miss the blueberry-lemon bread pudding. (It freezes well.) There are also jams, vinegars, olive oil, mustards, glassware and soap.
Dan Gaucher
Jan 20, 2022 Report
Pictures are two separate occasions over this last weekend.
First, their tenders are absolutely amazing. I know, I know. Tenders, how special can they be? Well theirs are absolutely delicious, even for adults. The second thing we got was their Gyro which was on special. It was so ridiculously good! Definitely would have that again. Second trip we shared their Chicken Bacon Ranch Buffalo pizza, and the Ruben with a cup of Squash Bisque. The pizza was phenomenal, they don't skimp out on any of the toppings. The bisque was fresh and hit the spot. The Ruben was as good a Ruben as I've ever had.
Carly E.
Jan 13, 2022 Report
SO REFRESHING! I've never had a pizza and sandwich that was so refreshing and tasty. I come from Hawaii, so we are definitely big on our food and how it makes us feel. My dad is from Kittery, so we would come up here to visit sometimes. This is the first time I've ever had When Pigs Fly, and it is incredible! The bread on the sandwich had berries, which I have never had. Now, I feel like I need this bread with every sandwich I make! The pizza is hearty and delicious, and it was just a short distance away from where we were staying. If you're in the mood for great pizza and sandwiches