Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
8 Years
experience
Authentic New York Style Pizzeria in East Stroudsburg
Since 2018, Brothers Pizzeria has been serving East Stroudsburg with authentic New York-style pizza crafted from family recipes perfected over two generations. Our founders, Louie and Lavdim, grew up immersed in the pizzeria business, learning every aspect from dough preparation to sauce formulation under the mentorship of their artisan pizza-making family. We pride ourselves on using quality ingredients to create Italian-inspired dishes that cater to diverse tastes, including pasta, calzones, and specialty pizzas.

Our commitment to excellence is reflected in our Google reviews, which highlight our delicious food, exceptional customer service, and adherence to safety standards. We offer free delivery for orders over $30 and maintain consistent operating hours six days a week to accommodate our customers' needs. Our team takes pride in personally handling every order, ensuring each customer receives a freshly baked, flavorful meal that keeps them returning for more.
Services
New York Style Pizza Pasta Dishes Catering Services Free Delivery Gluten-Free Options
Details
  • Year established: 2018
Highlights and features
  • Two generations of pizza-making expertise
  • Family recipes perfected over decades
  • Free delivery for orders over $30
  • Consistently praised for food quality and service
  • Committed to customer safety and satisfaction
What people say
Amazing food Phenomenal service Clean atmosphere Only delivery option Worth the wait
Services
New York Style Pizza
Our signature New York-style pizzas feature hand-stretched dough topped with premium ingredients and baked to perfection. Available in classic and specialty varieties, each pizza showcases our family's generations-old recipes. Customers consistently praise the thin, crispy crust and generous toppings that make every bite memorable.
Pasta Dishes
We offer a variety of traditional Italian pasta dishes including Penne Alla Vodka, Carbonara, and Bolognese. Each entre includes salad and garlic bread with optional meat or seafood additions. Our pasta is made fresh daily and paired with house-made sauces that highlight authentic Italian flavors.
Catering Services
Brothers Pizzeria provides catering for events of all sizes with custom menus featuring our popular pizzas, pastas, and appetizers. We accommodate special dietary needs and offer delivery for orders over $30. Our team works closely with clients to ensure their event has the same quality and authenticity as our restaurant experience.
Free Delivery
We offer complimentary delivery for orders exceeding $30 within our service area. Our drivers maintain food temperature and quality during transport, with a minimum order requirement of $20. Customers appreciate the convenience of enjoying our restaurant-quality meals without leaving home.
Gluten-Free Options
We provide gluten-free pizza crusts and pasta alternatives for customers with dietary restrictions. Our kitchen staff follows strict protocols to prevent cross-contamination while maintaining the same great taste. This service allows more customers to enjoy our Italian cuisine while meeting their specific dietary needs.
People
Louie
Co-Owner
Louie grew up working in family pizzerias, mastering pizza-making techniques from an early age. He co-founded Brothers Pizzeria in 2018 to share authentic New York-style pizza with East Stroudsburg residents. His hands-on approach ensures every pizza meets family standards.
Lavdim
Co-Owner
Lavdim learned pizza-making fundamentals working alongside family members from childhood. As co-owner, he focuses on maintaining recipe authenticity and customer satisfaction. His dedication to quality ingredients and traditional methods defines Brothers Pizzeria's culinary approach.
Questions
What areas do you deliver to?
We deliver throughout East Stroudsburg with a $20 minimum order. Free delivery is available for orders over $30.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide catering with custom menus featuring our popular pizzas, pastas, and appetizers for events of all sizes.
Are gluten-free options available?
Yes, we offer gluten-free pizza crusts and pasta alternatives while maintaining strict preparation protocols to prevent cross-contamination.
What are your operating hours?
We're open Monday-Saturday 11am-9pm and Sunday 12pm-9pm for dine-in, takeout, and delivery orders.
How is food prepared during busy times?
Every pizza is baked to order, with typical wait times around 20 minutes. Our kitchen prioritizes accuracy and quality over speed.