La Pizzeria

We have dined there on several occasions. The food is great and the service is usually top notch, however, it was a miserable fail this visit… in fact, my food was burnt even the toast, (they still served it),then, it was recooked, raw. The wait staff was rude and more rude. Very unprofessional! If they would at least have apologized, and be accountable, everyone can have an off day! The service was throwing a plate at you and moving on. Sadly disappointed…

This was a very nice place, but slightly over priced. We would have expected the quality of the food to be just a bit better to correspond with the prices.
Don't get me wrong, the food was very good. And our server, Destiny, was very nice.
The servers should all be the same uniform, instead of jeans and t-shirts (again, something one would expect from the upscale feel of the place).
We will come again in the future.

Just got a All American Calzone from this place. Totally horrible, the crust is generic and dry breaking open the Calzone it was pepperoni uncooked and very, very bland. Nothing special...I'm very upset. I think this restaurant is cluess about actually creating something special.
The Calzone was way overpriced $17.00 for the poor quality I received. No wonder your ratings are 4.1 it really should be lower. I went Rotolo's in Carencro and the Calzone was $8 dollars and change best Calzone I ever had and half the price. I would not recommend and
please read the reviews 1st.

The Wedge Salad and Chicken Parmesan were both very good. Looking forward to trying it again.

This used to be one of my favorite spots but I stop coming for awhile when they switched owners because it wasn't as good. I decided to give it another try and was pleasantly surprised!

Staff was friendly and food was great, portions were huge! So glad I gave it another try will definitely make this a usual spot.

My favorite item was the Arancini, SO GOOD and crispy and the sauce was amazing definitely recommend!

My first time eating here. On a Sunday about noon. Got a little worried because upon entering the place was not bery busy. Service was prompt and attentive. Order spaghetti, eggplant parmasan, and a house salad with blue cheese. Spaghetti was perfect, eggplant was cooked exactly right. The salad was good and the blue cheese dressing was house made and although a little different than I expected, it was delicious.. now the bread, well it needs some work. Kind of hard like old bread. Would do better with breadsticks instead of garlic bread.

One of my “go to” places in Lafayette. Food is constantly good and service is always too notch!! Try the pork masala, it is amazing.
Personally believe they have the best pizza in Lafayette.

Excellent food!! Excellent service!! Everyone in our party ordered pizzas on the cauliflower crust! It was soooo delicious, we all assumed the kitchen made a mistake and sent regular crust!! Our waitress Madi ensured us it was cauliflower crust! It was one of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever tasted!! I’m curious to know the carb content! I’m thinking there must be some flour in the dough, making it more like Cauli-flour pizza dough!! 😁 In any event - the crust was light & fluffy with a heavenly taste!! Our server Madi, gave us stellar service! All around, we all had an excellent dining

Great food and service!! I’m a displaced NY’er, been living in Lafayette for 15 years. My pizza standards are high. And while this isn’t NY style, it is excellent!! My wife and I love sitting at an outside table; makes for a very nice experience.

The blue cheese bacon beet salad is amazing! The humus as always is on point. So good!!

I cannot live without the Garden of Eaten pizza!!

The worst pizza ever!!! It looks like they cooked it in a microwave. First time I ever order a pizza took one bit then trash the rest! Score 0.0.

The food and atmosphere are A+++ hidden gem spinach's and artichoke dip is a must every time

12/8/19 I ordered Ragin Cajun pasta. Menu stated it had a spicy Alfredo sauce. Does that look like any kind of Alfredo? It was entirely too spicy and can we say greasy? It was gross. My shrimp were buried under all that pasta in that grease. The only good thing was the cheesy garlic bread. I would not return to this establishment even if I were paid to go!

Horrible service. Called in an order for pick up and was told it would be ready in 25 Minutes. 50 minutes later with only 3 tables in the entire restaurant I get an attitude and a pizza. The other person waiting for a take out order waited 15 min longer than was told for their order as well.

Nothing to praise or recommend! Service was very, very slow. People at table next to us called out for a waitress to first help them after waiting 10 minutes. Grilled Four Season pizza is a great concept but crust was like thin cardboard, tough and tasteless. Chicken Marsala was so salty that I couldn't eat it. Place looks nice but everything else deserved zero stars

Easily some of the best pizza I've ever had. Now it is a little pricey but worth the price.

This was my first time and it was great!! Everything from the service, the wine, the entree and dessert... All wonderful!! Jillian, Brie and the other young ladies were so sweet! Will definitely be back! 😉

Pizza is nothing special at all. Tastes like it came from the frozen section at the grocery store. This place used to be a lot better several years ago but it's gone downhill since then. Sorry I wasted my money.

This place on Ambassador Caffery, they changed sandwich bread and the way they used to fix it, Not good any more!

Went for our anniversary. Ordered a strawberry margarita and a regular one. Both were excellent. The spinach artichoke dip was da bomb - cheesy and gooey and craveworthy. The Superiore and American calzones were hot and tasty. Lauren was the best waitress. Definitely ask for her section. Can't believe it's been years since I've been here. Can't wait to go back!

By far my favorite pizza place in Lafayette. The meat market has SO MUCH meat on it, it's crazy. The crab amore is also great. You also must try their spinach dip......takes 5 hours to make each batch, always fresh. They also offer a really good lunch special.
The owner is very sweet, along with the staff. I've been a regular for years and I don't plan on changing that.

Will definitely be back based off of my visit tonight. Naomi was our server and she was sweet & attentive. Food was awesome!! We got the Ragin Cajun Pasta and the Boudin Pizza (limited time for Mardi Gras season) Both delish.

Been a while since I've been here just don't order the burgers. Taste like a frozen patty just not quality. Also it took 40 minutes for this burger. Very disappointed with the service. Manager didn't even bother to offer any apologies either. Stick to the pizza or calzone you will be ok probably since that's what they are known for. But likely I won't be back.

I just had a semi healthy meal of griddled veggies (squash, zucchini, mushrooms, and tomatoes) and chicken. It also included pita wedges with hummus and salsa. I could have given myself a pat on the back if it would not have been sprinkled with cheese and accompanied with white wine. Nonetheless, I was proud of myself for not ordering pizza. My waitress was attentive and nice, my food was good, and I have enough leftovers for a couple of small meals. The restrooms were clean and tidy and there was plenty out outside seating to take advantage of the comfortable October evening. WIN!!!