Business Details
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Zanesville, OH
At Sarah Wickerham, we prioritize personalized service tailored to each client's unique needs. With over 60 years of combined experience, our team specializes in Auto, Homeowners, Life, Health, and Business insurance solutions. We serve Southeastern Ohio, focusing on Muskingum, Licking, Perry, and Guernsey counties, offering 24/7 availability through in-person meetings, phone calls, and virtual consultations. Our commitment to community is reflected in our support of local organizations like Big Brothers Big Sisters and Eastside Community Ministry. Led by Sarah Wickerham, a Muskingum County resident since 2010, we blend local expertise with the strength of the State Farm network.Our approach emphasizes transparency, integrity, and a dedication to helping clients protect what matters most. We provide no-obligation quotes and ongoing policy reviews to ensure coverage evolves with clients' changing needs. Our team's longevity, including Mary Touvell with over 15 years of service, underscores our commitment to consistent, reliable support. We actively engage in community education through initiatives like National Cybersecurity Awareness Month and Fire Prevention Month. By living in the communities we serve, we maintain a deep understanding of local risks and priorities.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Pet Insurance
Renters Insurance
Condo Insurance
Boat Insurance
Health Insurance
Personal Articles Insurance
Highlights and features
- We provide personalized insurance solutions based on your unique needs and circumstances
- Our team has over 60 years of combined experience in insurance services
- We offer 24/7 availability through multiple communication channels
- Our agency actively supports local community organizations and initiatives
- We conduct annual policy reviews to ensure coverage evolves with client needs
What people say
Great service
Knowledgeable staff
Competitive rates
24/7 availability
Personalized attention
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect against financial loss from accidents, theft, or damage. We offer customizable coverage options including liability, collision, and comprehensive protection. Our agents help clients understand state requirements and select appropriate coverage limits while identifying potential discounts for safe driving records or multi-policy bundling.
Homeowners Insurance
We provide comprehensive homeowners insurance covering dwelling damage, personal property loss, and liability protection. Our policies include coverage for natural disasters like fires and storms, with optional endorsements for high-value items or specific risks. Annual policy reviews ensure coverage keeps pace with property value changes and evolving client needs.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance solutions offer financial protection for dependents through term and permanent policy options. We help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts based on income replacement needs, outstanding debts, and future expenses like education costs. Policies can be customized with riders for critical illness or disability income protection.
Business Insurance
We design business insurance packages protecting against property damage, liability claims, and operational disruptions. Our commercial policies include general liability, property insurance, and business interruption coverage tailored to specific industries. We serve local businesses in Southeastern Ohio with risk management strategies that adapt to company growth and changing regulations.
Pet Insurance
Our pet insurance plans help cover veterinary expenses for accidents, illnesses, and routine care. We offer customizable coverage levels with reimbursement options for unexpected medical costs. The plans include coverage for chronic conditions and hereditary issues while allowing pet owners to choose their preferred veterinary providers.
People
Sarah Wickerham
Agent
Sarah Wickerham founded the agency in 2010, bringing extensive insurance expertise and community leadership. She actively supports local charities and holds OH-1039044 agent license.
Mary Touvell
Multiple Line Representative
Mary has served State Farm policyholders since 2008 with expertise in home, auto, and business insurance. She specializes in life insurance and paycheck protection plans, holding license #758507.
Mikayla Nash
Multiple Line Representative
Mikayla joined the team in 2022 after obtaining her Property and Casualty license. She focuses on new business appointments and coverage reviews, holding license #1447620.
Reagan Dygert
Office Manager
Reagan serves as Office Manager and licensed property and casualty representative. She specializes in claims assistance and customer service, holding license #1533747 since 2023.
Marlie Baker
Marketing Assistant
Marlie joined the team in 2025 as a part-time marketing assistant while completing high school. She coordinates annual policy review appointments and supports client communications.
Questions
What insurance products do you offer?
We offer auto, home, life, business, pet, renters, condo, boat, and health insurance policies tailored to individual and business needs.
Do you provide 24/7 insurance support?
Yes, our team is available 24 hours a day via phone, text, or email for emergencies and policy inquiries.
How can I get a personalized insurance quote?
Contact us through our website, call (740) 454-3276, or visit our Zanesville office for a no-obligation quote tailored to your needs.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Southeastern Ohio including Muskingum, Licking, Perry, and Guernsey counties.
Can I meet with an agent virtually?
Yes, we offer virtual meetings through Zoom or other platforms for your convenience and safety.
What makes your agency different?
Our combination of local expertise, 60+ years of team experience, and personalized service approach sets us apart in the insurance industry.
Reviews (5)
William Walker
Jan 08, 2022
Report
Sarah provided a professional and responsive experience. Her insurance knowledge is superb. I am new to State Farm and if Sarah is any indication of the quality service I will be receiving then I will be a long time State Farm customer. Hope was very professional in scheduling my appointments, calling and giving me a reminder and was generally pleasant. I highly recommend this State Farm office.
Kurtis Campbell
Dec 29, 2021
Report
Critical:Professionalism,Responsiveness
If you like fluctuations in ur rates every 3-6 months and enjoy being blamed for them not entering the information you gave them into the computer right this State Farm office is for you. If you enjoy a hassle free insurance agent look elsewhere.
If you like fluctuations in ur rates every 3-6 months and enjoy being blamed for them not entering the information you gave them into the computer right this State Farm office is for you. If you enjoy a hassle free insurance agent look elsewhere.
Tracy Talbott
Dec 02, 2021
Report
Sarah Wickerhams team is awesome !!! I greatly appreciate how theyre all very kind, professional and very responsive to my questions and situations. My overall excitement is my great rates, I love seeing them coming down instead of increasing which I experienced with my last agent even with zero claims. Ty so much for everything Wickerham team!!!!!
Nina A.
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Great team! Everyone there I have worked with has been professional, efficient, and kind. I highly recommend.
Great team! Everyone there I have worked with has been professional, efficient, and kind. I highly recommend.
Kimberly Williams
Nov 14, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism
I was so surprised and pleased by the quick response and friendliness of this office. Mary T was the most helpful. She was able to give me amazing, much better coverage than I had for a lot less. I would recommend (and have) to everyone!!
I was so surprised and pleased by the quick response and friendliness of this office. Mary T was the most helpful. She was able to give me amazing, much better coverage than I had for a lot less. I would recommend (and have) to everyone!!
