Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
37 Years
experience
Trusted Jewelry Store in Evergreen, CO | Morning Star Jewelers
Established in 1989, Morning Star Jewelers has been serving the Evergreen community with a commitment to trust, integrity, and personalized service. Our award-winning designer, John Varner, brings decades of expertise to custom creations, blending artistry with innovative techniques. With in-house repair services and direct diamond sourcing from Antwerp, we ensure exceptional quality while eliminating middlemen.

Our team prioritizes customer satisfaction through attentive care, offering same-day services like jewelry cleaning and watch battery replacement. Recognized as Evergreen's best jewelry store, we combine 35 years of local heritage with global industry standards to create timeless pieces for every occasion.
Services
Custom Design Jewelry Repairs Diamond Selection Gift Jewelry Watch Battery Replacement Pearl Restringing Gold Purchase Eyeglass Repair Engagement Rings Wedding Bands
Details
  • Year established: 1989
Highlights and features
  • We offer 35 years of experience in custom jewelry design and repair services.
  • Our award-winning designer creates personalized, one-of-a-kind pieces with global expertise.
  • We provide in-house repairs with advanced equipment for faster turnaround times.
  • Our diamonds are ethically sourced through direct relationships in Antwerp.
  • We combine local service with international quality standards for customer satisfaction.
Associations and certifications
  • Kimberley Process
What people say
Amazing service Beautiful work Highly recommend Excellent service Knowledgeable staff
Services
Custom Design
Create unique, personalized jewelry pieces tailored to individual preferences. Our award-winning designer combines artistic vision with technical precision to transform ideas into wearable art. Ideal for engagement rings, heirloom restorations, or signature accessories that reflect personal stories and milestones.
Jewelry Repairs
Expert restoration of damaged or worn jewelry using advanced equipment and techniques. Services include resizing, stone setting, cleaning, and structural reinforcement. Our craftsmen preserve the integrity of cherished pieces while ensuring lasting durability and aesthetic appeal.
Diamond Selection
Hand-selected diamonds from Antwerp's premier suppliers, offering exceptional quality and ethical sourcing. We provide guidance through the 4Cs (cut, color, clarity, carat) to help customers find perfect stones for engagement rings, investments, or luxury collections.
Gift Jewelry
Curated collection of fine jewelry for special occasions, including anniversary bands, birthday pendants, and holiday gifts. Our staff assists in selecting meaningful pieces that balance style, quality, and sentimental value for both men and women.
Watch Battery Replacement
Quick, reliable battery changes for luxury and everyday watches. Our technicians use precision tools to maintain water resistance and functionality while extending timepiece longevity. Complimentary inspections ensure optimal performance during each service visit.
People
John Varner
Owner & Award-Winning Designer
With over 35 years in jewelry design, John Varner has earned multiple industry awards for his innovative creations. He personally oversees custom projects and diamond sourcing, ensuring exceptional quality and customer satisfaction through hands-on expertise.
Cindy Varner
Owner
Cindy Varner collaborates directly with clients on engagement rings and special commissions. Her attention to detail and commitment to ethical practices help maintain the store's reputation for trust and excellence in the Evergreen community.
Questions
What services does Morning Star Jewelers offer?
We provide custom jewelry design, diamond selection, repair services, watch battery replacement, pearl restringing, and luxury gift options for men and women.
How long does custom jewelry creation take?
Typically 8 weeks, but we've completed urgent projects like engagement rings in 3 weeks with advanced planning.
Are your diamonds ethically sourced?
Yes, all diamonds follow the Kimberley Process and are conflict-free, with direct sourcing from Antwerp suppliers.
Do you repair inherited or damaged jewelry?
Yes, our experts restore heirlooms and damaged pieces using precision techniques while preserving their original character.
What are your store hours?
Tuesday-Friday 10:30 AM-5:30 PM, Saturday 10 AM-4 PM, closed Sunday & Monday.
Reviews (4)
Claudia Cragg
Oct 03, 2021 Report
They are superb in the store. I was having a bit of an issue with my watch, as the clasp wouldnt stay properly shut and I was afraid of losing it. The very kind jeweler and owner downed his tools, from where he was in the back of the shop, and came out to see my watch and fix it in an instant. He went out of his way, even though I wasnt even buying anything. His store does have a very impressive stock of beautiful items, so if you want to buy some beautiful jewelry from really nice people, this is the place to come. Highly recommended.
Pat Jacobs
Jul 28, 2021 Report
Very pleased with Morning Star Jeweler! They have unique and awesome jewelry. I elected to have them place angel charms on a bracelet and Copper was a delight to work with on this project! They are located in Evergreen and what fun to take a short trip to the area where Mom and Dad took us (four children) fishing in the summer and ice skating in the winter! Thank you for being genuine and taking care of your clients!
Donna Love
May 27, 2021 Report
Such wonderful, honest people! Beautiful quality work! Looking forward to my "reset" earrings
Olivia Melson
Apr 13, 2021 Report
I brought in numerous pieces of jewelry to have worked on, and they did a flawless job on every. single. piece. Beautiful work, highly recommend!