Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Welcome to Modern Snack Bar - North Forks Beloved Restaurant Since 1950
Since 1950, Modern Snack Bar has been a cornerstone of the North Fork dining scene, rooted in the Wittmeier family's commitment to serving quality home-cooked meals at fair prices. What began as a modest snack bar with six counter seats has evolved into a full-service restaurant seating 125 guests, while maintaining its original ethos of treating patrons like family. Our menu, shaped by decades of customer favorites, features iconic dishes like Crescent Farms duck, bay scallops, and award-winning lobster salad, alongside Wanda Wittmeier's legendary mashed turnips.

With over 70 years of continuous operation, we blend generational expertise with locally sourced ingredients, including partnerships with nearby farms like Crescent Farms. Our historic Neimeyer Sign Company sign, installed in 1956, stands as a testament to our enduring presence and dedication to preserving traditional cooking methods. We prioritize fresh, seasonal ingredients and time-honored recipes, ensuring every meal reflects our deep connection to the North Fork community and its agricultural heritage.
Services
Full-Service Dining Takeout Orders Catering Services Holiday Meal Prep Local Sourcing Wine & Beer Classic Cocktails Specialty Menus Family Recipes North Fork Catering
Details
  • Year established: 1950
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 70 years of experience in home-cooked meals.
  • Our menu features locally sourced ingredients from Crescent Farms.
  • We preserve traditional recipes passed down through generations.
  • Our historic North Fork landmark provides a unique dining atmosphere.
  • We maintain consistent quality with time-tested cooking methods.
Services
Full-Service Dining
Since 1950, we've offered a full-service dining experience with two spacious rooms seating 125 guests. Our menu features classic American dishes made from fresh, local ingredients, including Crescent Farms duck and North Fork bay scallops. Guests enjoy a nostalgic atmosphere while savoring generations of culinary tradition.
Takeout Orders
We provide convenient takeout options for our most popular dishes, including fresh-baked pies and specialty sandwiches. Customers can order ahead for pickup or browse our full menu online. Our to-go packaging ensures meals maintain quality during transport, allowing patrons to enjoy home-cooked flavors anywhere.
Catering Services
Our catering service brings Modern Snack Bar's signature dishes to private events and gatherings. We offer customizable menus featuring roasted meats, seafood specialties, and homemade desserts. With decades of experience serving North Fork events, we provide reliable delivery and setup for occasions of any size.
Holiday Meal Prep
We prepare complete holiday meals featuring traditional favorites like roast turkey, glazed ham, and homemade stuffing. Our Thanksgiving and Christmas menus include pre-order options with specific pricing lists. Customers can reserve meals in advance for pickup, ensuring festive dining without the kitchen work.
Local Sourcing
We maintain partnerships with local farms and producers, including Crescent Farms across the street. This commitment ensures fresh, high-quality ingredients for our dishes. By supporting regional agriculture, we preserve traditional farming practices while offering patrons authentic North Fork flavors year-round.
Questions
Is Modern Snack Bar open year-round?
We operate seasonally, typically closing for the winter around mid-December. Our exact dates vary annually, so check our website for current seasonal hours.
Do you offer catering services for private events?
Yes, we provide catering for North Fork events, featuring our signature dishes like Crescent Farms duck and homemade pies. Contact us for custom menus and event planning.
What are your most popular menu items?
Guests consistently favor our Crescent Farms duck, bay scallops, award-winning lobster salad, and Wanda Wittmeier's famous mashed turnips, available since the 1950s.
Do you use locally sourced ingredients?
Yes, we partner with nearby farms like Crescent Farms across the street to ensure fresh, local ingredients in our dishes, supporting regional agriculture and sustainability.
Can I order meals for pickup or delivery?
We offer takeout options with our full menu available for pickup. Delivery isn't available, but our to-go packaging ensures meals maintain quality for off-site enjoyment.
What is your history with the North Fork community?
Since 1950, we've been a family-owned North Fork landmark. The Wittmeier family established us as a snack bar that grew into a full-service restaurant, maintaining community ties through generations.
Reviews (6)
Ns Gleason Nsg
Dec 14, 2021 Report
It's a real pleasure going to Modern Snack Bar. Service is terrific, food is always comforting & so good...best duck dinner around! It feels like home without lifting a finger.
Faiza K.
Dec 08, 2021 Report
ASK FOR TRACEY!!! Great food that tastes homemade, generous portions, for a fair price, served with smiles, great covis, and amazing service. We ate here back in August and absolutely loved everything. If you're a parent who once in a while like to enjoy a meal at a restaurant with your kids, this place is the place to take them. My kids are pretty well behaved but toddlers will be toddlers and they get excited and loud once in a while. The snack bar had those wax strips you can bend and make things out of. We loved making bracelets and necklaces. Everyone was so nice and made us feel
Ronald Friedman
Nov 29, 2021 Report
Everything a good roadside place should be. We dropped by for lunch. Great menu, warm diner-type service. Food was just right, large portions. Prices seem to be a bit high, but has become a universal matter, after all.
Liza L.
Nov 26, 2021 Report
They feed us healthcare workers with their delicious pies every Thanksgiving. Something to be thankful for
S. Kelly
Nov 24, 2021 Report
Excellent fare, especially the hot turkey meal. Excellent service, especially server Rosetta and all servers whose names escape. Excellent ownership, who really seem to care about the customers. Will absolutely miss Modern Snack Bar over the winter, but wish entire staff a good rest.
Stefan W.
Nov 02, 2021 Report
Far from "modern", this friendly spot is delightfully stuck in the 60s. Soft shell crabs are done right, as is the clam chowder and lobster bisque. Lemon Merengue pie is pure perfection. Service is on point and helpful. A great stop to make.