Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
31 Years
experience
Custom Jewelry & Engagement Rings in New Oxford, PA
Scott and Co Fine Jewelers and Co Fine Jewelers has served the New Oxford community for 25 years, combining New York City luxury with hometown care. Our industrial-style showroom features fine, designer, and bridal jewelry alongside a dedicated event space. With a full-time workshop staffed by bench jewelers boasting 60+ years of combined experience, we deliver precision repairs and custom creations. A Certified Gemologist on staff provides expert appraisals and gem identification.

Our commitment to exceptional service extends to complimentary jewelry cleaning, gift wrapping, and personalized consultations. We prioritize lasting relationships through honesty, craftsmanship, and integrity, ensuring every customer celebrates life's milestones with confidence. Our warranties and financing options reflect our dedication to accessible luxury and long-term satisfaction.
Services
Custom Jewelry Design Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Jewelry Repair Appraisals Insurance Services Gift Wrapping Financing Options Estate Jewelry Watch Sales
Details
  • Year established: 1995
Highlights and features
  • We offer 25 years of experience in custom jewelry design and repair services
  • Our workshop features 60+ years of combined experience from master bench jewelers
  • A Certified Gemologist provides expert appraisals and gem identification services
  • We guarantee all purchases with lifetime and four-year warranty options
  • Our in-house financing and layaway plans make luxury jewelry accessible
Associations and certifications
  • International Jewelers Organization (IJO)
What people say
Wonderful job Extremely accommodating Friendly and knowledgeable Great customer service Beautiful store
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Our master craftsmen transform your ideas into unique jewelry pieces. Using family heirlooms or new materials, we create one-of-a-kind designs with precision. The process includes consultation, digital rendering, and collaborative refinement to ensure your vision becomes reality.
Jewelry Repair
Professional repair services for platinum, gold, and silver jewelry performed in our on-site workshop. Our experienced jewelers handle pearl restringing, metalwork, and restoration with modern equipment. Repairs maintain your jewelry's beauty and structural integrity for generations.
Engagement Rings
Curated collection of designer and classic engagement rings featuring diamonds from 1.5ct to 2.1ct. Options include solitaires, three-stone settings, and custom designs. Certified gemologists guide you through selecting the perfect symbol of commitment.
Appraisals
Expert valuation services for insurance replacement and estate purposes conducted by Certified Gemologists. Detailed documentation includes gemstone analysis, metal purity verification, and current market value assessment for accurate insurance coverage.
Financing Options
Flexible payment plans with quick approval for purchasing dream jewelry. Options include layaway programs up to six months and various financing terms. Our staff helps customers find budget-friendly solutions without compromising quality.
People
Scott
Owner
With 25 years of experience in the jewelry industry, Scott and Co Fine Jewelers and Co Fine Jewelers leads our team with a commitment to quality craftsmanship and customer satisfaction. His expertise in fine jewelry ensures every client receives personalized attention and exceptional service.
Karen
Jeweler
A skilled bench jeweler with extensive experience in custom design and repairs. Karen's attention to detail and technical expertise contribute to the precise execution of every custom jewelry project and restoration work.
Amanda
Sales Associate
Amanda assists customers in finding perfect jewelry pieces while providing knowledgeable guidance about our collections. Her friendly approach and product expertise create comfortable shopping experiences for all clients.
Kate
Customer Service
Kate ensures smooth operations and client communication, drawing from years of experience in luxury retail. Her dedication to customer care helps maintain our reputation for exceptional service and community engagement.
Karen Tanner
Gemologist
Certified Gemologist with expertise in diamond grading and gemstone identification. Karen provides professional appraisal services and educates customers about jewelry characteristics to help make informed purchasing decisions.
Questions
What jewelry services do you offer in New Oxford?
We provide custom design, repairs, appraisals, insurance services, and luxury jewelry sales including engagement rings and wedding bands.
How does your custom jewelry design process work?
Our process begins with consultation, followed by digital design creation, material selection, and collaborative refinement until your vision is perfected.
Do you offer financing options for jewelry purchases?
Yes, we provide flexible financing plans and layaway options up to six months to make luxury jewelry accessible for all budgets.
What warranty protections do you provide?
All purchases include lifetime and four-year warranty options covering manufacturing defects and required maintenance services.
Can you repair heirloom jewelry pieces?
Our experienced jewelers specialize in restoring vintage and heirloom jewelry while preserving original craftsmanship and sentimental value.
How can I schedule an appointment with your jewelers?
Call (717) 624-1444 during business hours or use our online booking system to reserve a consultation time that works for you.
Reviews (7)
Jessica
Dec 24, 2021 Report
Wonderful and family friendly. i went in for a ring upgrade. they were not pushy and i got what i wanted. amanda even played with my daughter to make her feel included. i would recommend to anyone who asks.
Laura Dickson
Dec 23, 2021 Report
Ive never had a better experience at a jeweler. The ring they created for my mother is absolutely beautiful and was done earlier than expected. The folks there are very friendly and knowledgeable. Thank you so much.
Michelle Heiser
Dec 21, 2021 Report
Everyone was attentive and helpful in my search for a new wedding band. When the band I wanted to buy was sold an hour before I was going in to purchase it, I was very disappointed. However, I was accommodated very quickly and a new one was ordered. I was expecting to wait 6-8 weeks for it, but after only a week, I got a phone call saying it was in. During this busy shopping season before Christmas, I was able to find and get the perfect ring.
Phyllis Doyle
Dec 05, 2021 Report
My visit was very pleasant. Linda was very helpful and knowledgeable. I was not only looking to have a pearl necklace repaired, I needed a watch battery, jewelry cleaned and was inquiring about diamond studs. Linda helped me select a pair of blue diamond studs. Beautiful. Thanks Linda. I would recommend Scot & Co as your jewelry store.
Paula Deithorn
Nov 27, 2021 Report
More than your chain jewelry store, Scott & Co is a true fine jeweler. I needed to get my diamond wedding band repaired because it had broken in half. The jewelry store where my husband had bought it was permanently closed due to the pandemic, looked on the internet and found Scott & Co and decided to give them a try. Extremely satisfied with the repair in fact my ring looked better than when we first bought it. Would definitely go there again whether purchasing a new piece of jewelry or having a piece repaired.
Cathy M. Kamsler
Nov 20, 2021 Report
My custom work is perfect! Amanda created a new pendant, a work of art, using older jewelry from my mother and a few pieces of mine. Everything old is new again. Scott and Company have again been gracious and loving during this process. Thank you for my gorgeous Waterfall Pendant.
Susan Dillman
Nov 16, 2021 Report
Salesperson was very friendly and professional. She made sure to show me all the beautiful designs in the jewelry I asked to see. Jewelry choices were so beautiful and hard to pick from. I was very pleased with what I chose. Thank you for being the best place around! Always recommend your place to everyone!