Business Details
Your Trusted Partner for Medicare and Health Insurance Solutions
At The Health Insurance Store, we specialize in providing personalized guidance for Medicare, health insurance, and life insurance solutions. Our approach prioritizes education and trust-building, ensuring clients make informed decisions without pressure to enroll. With a focus on community roots, we offer face-to-face support and long-term relationships, distinguishing ourselves from agencies that prioritize sales over client needs. Our team of licensed agents delivers clear answers and expert advice tailored to individual circumstances, serving Pennsylvania and New Mexico. We pride ourselves on transparency, offering no-cost consultations and maintaining availability for ongoing support.Our 'Ask the Medicare Specialist' column addresses complex topics, empowering clients to navigate coverage options confidently. With over 15,000 clients, we have built a reputation for honest guidance and dependable service. Our multi-location presence ensures accessibility, whether through in-person meetings, phone calls, or virtual consultations. We emphasize individualized solutions, recognizing that one-size-fits-all approaches rarely meet unique healthcare needs. Our commitment extends beyond enrollment, as we remain a trusted resource for policyholders throughout their coverage journey.
Services
Medicare Supplements
Medicare Advantage Plans
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Medicare Guidance
Highlights and features
- We provide personalized, no-pressure insurance consultations tailored to individual needs.
- Our team offers face-to-face support with deep community knowledge in Pennsylvania and New Mexico.
- We maintain long-term client relationships beyond one-time transactions for ongoing support.
- Our 'Ask the Medicare Specialist' column breaks down complex insurance topics for clarity.
- We serve over 15,000 clients with a proven track record of honest, dependable guidance.
Services
Medicare Supplements
Medicare Supplement Insurance helps cover gaps in Original Medicare, including deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance. These plans work nationwide with any provider accepting Medicare, offering predictable out-of-pocket costs. Our agents help clients compare standardized plan options to find the best financial protection based on individual health needs and spending patterns.
Medicare Advantage Plans
Medicare Advantage Plans combine Parts A and B coverage with additional benefits like dental, vision, and prescription drug coverage. These plans often include HMO or PPO networks requiring in-network care. We analyze plan formularies, provider networks, and total value propositions to help clients balance premium costs against potential out-of-pocket expenses.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance solutions provide financial security for loved ones through term and permanent coverage options. We help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts based on income replacement needs, debt obligations, and future expenses. Our agents compare policies across multiple carriers to find competitively priced options that align with long-term financial goals.
Health Insurance
We assist individuals and businesses in selecting health insurance plans that balance premium costs with coverage adequacy. Our expertise includes Marketplace plans, employer-sponsored solutions, and short-term medical coverage options. We ensure proper enrollment to avoid tax penalties while helping clients understand network limitations, deductible structures, and prescription coverage details.
Medicare Guidance
Our specialized Medicare counseling helps clients navigate enrollment timelines, plan comparisons, and annual review processes. We explain Part A/B basics, late enrollment penalties, and special circumstances affecting coverage choices. Through educational resources and personalized consultations, we empower clients to make confident decisions about their healthcare coverage.
People
Aaron Zolbrod
President / Founder
As founder of The Health Insurance Store, Aaron combines 20+ years of insurance expertise with community-focused service. He leads client education initiatives and develops strategic partnerships to expand accessible coverage options.
Loni Nedrow
Office Manager
Loni oversees daily operations at our Connellsville location, ensuring seamless client experiences. With 15 years in insurance administration, she coordinates team workflows and maintains compliance with regulatory requirements.
Denise Litman
Admin Assistant
Denise provides critical support for client documentation and policy processing. Her attention to detail ensures accurate record-keeping and timely submission of insurance applications across all product lines.
Jennifer Chaney
Office Manager
Jennifer manages administrative operations at our Connellsville office. She trains new staff members and implements process improvements to enhance client service efficiency and policy management accuracy.
Sadie Humphreys
Licensed Agent
Sadie assists clients with Medicare and health insurance selections. Her client-centered approach focuses on explaining complex coverage details in accessible terms while maintaining strict compliance with licensing requirements.
Questions
What's the difference between Medicare Supplements and Advantage Plans?
Medicare Supplements cover gaps in Original Medicare with predictable costs, while Advantage Plans replace Medicare Parts A/B with additional benefits but may limit provider networks.
How do I determine which Medicare plan works best for me?
Our licensed agents evaluate your health needs, budget, and preferred providers to recommend customized solutions that balance coverage and affordability.
Do you offer services outside Pennsylvania?
We serve New Mexico residents in addition to Pennsylvania, with virtual consultation options available for clients nationwide.
What are your consultation fees?
All consultations are completely free with no obligation, as we believe in accessible, transparent insurance guidance for all clients.
Can I switch plans after enrollment?
Yes, we assist with plan changes during annual enrollment periods or qualify life events to ensure continued coverage alignment with your needs.
Videos
Reviews (5)
William Ansell
Dec 05, 2021
Report
Very polite, professional, and informative. They don't try to push anything you don't need. They explain answers to any questions you may have and make sure you understand.
Rose Zuckerman
Nov 15, 2021
Report
I spoke to Aaron, the owner, about moving Medicare insurance to his company, because I'd made a bad choice with a non-responsive agent this past year. He was very kind and offered help, answered my questions, and assured me that I could call again if I needed more help, even though I cannot switch agents. Offering to help me anyway... that's above and beyond. Very impressive, punctual, and knowledgeable agent.
Grateful for his time and professionalism. I wish I had found Aaron first, and was disappointed to learn that we're stuck with an agent when we first sign up for insurance. Wish I'd
Grateful for his time and professionalism. I wish I had found Aaron first, and was disappointed to learn that we're stuck with an agent when we first sign up for insurance. Wish I'd
Michael A. Morgan
Sep 05, 2021
Report
Recently met with Aaron to discuss some complications regarding insurance options due to possibly changing carrier and relocating. Aaron proposed various options which would pertain to the scenarios which I had offered as possibilities. He actually made contact with providers as we spoke to get clarity and immediate answers. The meeting was scheduled without delay and was cordial, professional, and informative. I will not hesitate to take advantage of Aaron's expertise in the future.
Anjbennett
Aug 20, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Responsiveness
Tony was very professional and helpful. He was patient and talked me through the process in an orderly and detailed way. Thanks Tony!!
Tony was very professional and helpful. He was patient and talked me through the process in an orderly and detailed way. Thanks Tony!!
Rebekah Jean Seese
Jul 20, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Tony was an amazing insurance broker and helped every step of the way to get me the best insurance for an incredible price. I will highly recommend him to anybody that will listen.
Tony was an amazing insurance broker and helped every step of the way to get me the best insurance for an incredible price. I will highly recommend him to anybody that will listen.
