Our New York authentic pies are built to order using homemade recipes from our family archives. My Pie is a place where each guest has the opportunity to custom build their own dining experience. At My Pie we pride ourselves in being your neighborhood pizzeria. Our New York authentic pie are built to order using homemade recipes from our family archives.
Our motto is local, fresh, fast! We love to source our produce locally, we make all of our doughs and sauces fresh daily and our pies cook up in a New York minute. Our dough and sauces are made fresh, daily using only the best ingredients. Once you taste a My Pie you'll be hooked! Our quality and flavor far surpass the competition and we're sure you'll feel the same way.
Our motto is local, fresh, fast! We love to source our produce locally, we make all of our doughs and sauces fresh daily and our pies cook up in a New York minute. Our dough and sauces are made fresh, daily using only the best ingredients. Once you taste a My Pie you'll be hooked! Our quality and flavor far surpass the competition and we're sure you'll feel the same way.
Services
Distinguished by quality ingredients and flavor, it's an art form for real New Yorkers, passed down from generations. With homemade recipes and strong family values, you can taste the passion put into each pie. My Pie brings the flavor of NY right to your neighborhood, all in a New York minute. New York is about CONVENIENCE and SPEED!
Reviews (23)
Bill Radke
Jan 09, 2022
Report
Tim Ray
Oct 17, 2021
Report
Richard Phan
Oct 02, 2021
Report
Victor Mann
Sep 30, 2021
Report
A New York style neighborhood Pizzeria with Classic pies, My Pies, and create your own. Nice fresh ingredients and a friendly staff they also offer wings, calzones and some sweet treats. We had a Pizza Margareta and a Pesto my chicken prices range from $7.00 to $14.00 and it's yummy good. Thanks Yelp for the Elite Experience please support our local businesses.
Mike Gutierrez
Sep 29, 2021
Report
Seychelle Morchell
Sep 22, 2021
Report
Great local pizza place where you can get your pie made your way. Or choose from their classic options. They offer an assortment of fresh ingredients, including vegan cheese and pepperoni! Also you can get garlic knots, chicken wings, salads and warm chocolate chip cookies. Bonus happy hour is all day for wine and beer. The wait time for a pizza is generally less than ten minutes. Definitely a great spot to eat outside or inside.
John Fleeger
Sep 19, 2021
Report
Laura Cafiso
Sep 17, 2021
Report
Yay - thrilled to check out My Pie Pizza via the exclusive Yelp Elite Experience! As a first timer, MPP initially reminded me of another pizza chain with a similiar set up (not a fan of), but the food here far surpasses that one.
I adored the cheese on my Classic New York Roni. Um, yes adored it b/c it was gooey, stringy & tasted delicious. The pepperoni slices are gigantic so I didn’t have to order extra. I ordered the “regular” crust, but appreciate the selection of cauliflower, gluten-free, & wheat. The crust is thin. I get that having a thinner crust is what makes it easier for these
I adored the cheese on my Classic New York Roni. Um, yes adored it b/c it was gooey, stringy & tasted delicious. The pepperoni slices are gigantic so I didn’t have to order extra. I ordered the “regular” crust, but appreciate the selection of cauliflower, gluten-free, & wheat. The crust is thin. I get that having a thinner crust is what makes it easier for these
K. L.
Sep 06, 2021
Report
It is acceptable pizza. Not bad, not good, but average. Bit pricey when you consider that the pizzas are individually sized, but looking at it as a lunch, it is affordable (~11 for a pizza and drink). I wouldn't call it NY style, though. The ordering process was novel and kids in line behind us seemed to enjoy it.
Sasha L.
Jul 02, 2021
Report
Excellent, excellent pizza. Thin crust, and just the right amount of toppings. Love the sauce. One pizza easily feeds two, maybe three people. Finally found a great pizza joint in Alabama. Reasonable prices. Moved from Conn 2 yrs ago and missed a decent pizza. There are one or two others but more expensive.
Amber Cordoba
Jun 25, 2021
Report
Delicious pizzas that are like 1.5 personal pizzas! Great vegan options (both vegan cheese and vegan pepperoni now!). And totally reasonable cost! ($9-11). Greet loyalty program.
Make your own pizza so you can choose your sauce and all the toppings you want. The marinara is fantastic.
Garlic knots are also amazing. They also do calzones and salads. Beer, Wine, Truly. Indoor and outdoor seating.
And super friendly service!
Make your own pizza so you can choose your sauce and all the toppings you want. The marinara is fantastic.
Garlic knots are also amazing. They also do calzones and salads. Beer, Wine, Truly. Indoor and outdoor seating.
And super friendly service!
Samantha H.
Jun 24, 2021
Report
Kayla C.
Apr 09, 2021
Report
Jessica P.
Mar 07, 2021
Report
Savior S.
Mar 07, 2021
Report
I had an AMAZING cauliflower crust veggie pizza with Alfredo sauce instead of marinara. It was so flavorful. The cauliflower crust didn't take away from the usual "bready" flavor you'd expect from regular pizza. I ordered take-out. They do not currently offer curbside pick-up, so I went inside to pick up my order. Social distancing guidelines are in place. The employees wear masks, and their are hand sanitizer stations set up. The pizza was inside of a recyclable box, so that was a plus. I highly recommend people to visit My Pie Pizza if you want to be able to enjoy pizza in
Adam G.
Sep 03, 2020
Report
Janice O.
Aug 15, 2020
Report
Don't wast your time or your money. I've trained to many restaurant servers to know how to treat customers.
Waited 15 minutes in an empty line. I had to ask 3 different employees if we could order. I got ignored, told there were people in dinning room had been waiting longer than we had and of course the straight out "no". The pizza marginally better than the service. Limp and forgettable.
Waited 15 minutes in an empty line. I had to ask 3 different employees if we could order. I got ignored, told there were people in dinning room had been waiting longer than we had and of course the straight out "no". The pizza marginally better than the service. Limp and forgettable.
Maddieclaire M.
Jul 04, 2020
Report
Okay first of I want to say the food is good but still the service in there was terrible 1. They burnt both our pizzas while they were on there phones 2. Even though they burnt out pizzas they charged us for 4 pizzas when we only got two 3. When they where giving us our drinks the girl just looked disgusted at I feel like was slightly judging us so just keep this in mind when you want to go to this place
Shawn B.
Jun 30, 2020
Report
Look!
I have eaten pizza all over. I know pizza.
Unfortunately, I am a diabetic and pizza and me have a love hate relationship these days, but then I ran across My Pie Pizza! Friendly service at a level 10!
For me this is the greatest day ever!
They got a cauliflower crust and even better than just having it, it taste amazing!
New routine just started!
Great pizza no matter who you are.
You can't go wrong going with My Pie Pizza!
I have eaten pizza all over. I know pizza.
Unfortunately, I am a diabetic and pizza and me have a love hate relationship these days, but then I ran across My Pie Pizza! Friendly service at a level 10!
For me this is the greatest day ever!
They got a cauliflower crust and even better than just having it, it taste amazing!
New routine just started!
Great pizza no matter who you are.
You can't go wrong going with My Pie Pizza!
Mikey M.
Jun 18, 2020
Report
Tried it a couple weeks after they first opened and it's became me and my fiancé's favorite pizza place. They have really good sized pizzas and calzones and you can't beat the price. I like the fact they also have cauliflower crust for anyone with gluten sensitivity. Hands down my favorite pizza place in Dothan!!
Joyce B.
May 10, 2020
Report
I decided to give my pie a second chance with a free pizza. It was sufficient for two people. I ordered mama meatza, expecting it to be loaded with meat, it was not. However, it was tasty. I put two pieces together and it made a nice size bite. The crust was thin and chewy. It was a little on the greasy side as my shirt can attest to. I was pleased all in all until later in the evening when my gut disagreed with my meal. Before I close I do want to say that they answered the phone promptly this time, courteously and professionally. I was given a pick up time and my food was ready when I got there
Molly C.
Apr 09, 2020
Report
Yo this place is so good at first i was like on the fence but like really in my heart of hearts this place is the best pizza place. i'm talking gluten free crust. i'm talking vegan cheese. i'm talking about the cauli. flower. crust. i wouldn't be disappointed to see this at the marriage supper of the lamb right next to the chick fil a nuggets
Rhonda J.
Apr 08, 2020
Report
We decided to try "the new place", I am so glad we did. My first experience was a good one. I ordered on line for curbside pickup since we are in the midst of this COVID mess. Everyone asks for a phone number but no one ever calls, I got a phone call from the person making my pizzas because I forgot to choose a cheese for one of my pizzas- they called just to verify - well of course I had wanted cheese lol so glad they chose to call. When I picked up my pizza they were hot and ready. This is probably now my favorite pizza in Dothan. Fresh toppings and friendly staff - hope to see delivery
