Business Details
Authentic Italian Pizza & Deli in New Hartford, NY
Tony's Pizzeria & Deli Pizzeria & Deli has been serving the Utica-Rome area with authentic Italian cuisine since our founding. Our commitment to using premium ingredients and time-honored recipes ensures every meal maintains the quality and tradition our customers expect. With two convenient locations in New Hartford and Whitesboro, we offer both dine-in experiences and extensive catering services for events of all sizes. Our menu features hand-tossed pizzas, specialty calzones, fresh subs, and house-made entrees crafted to satisfy diverse palates.The family-friendly atmosphere includes spacious seating arrangements and a dedication to exceptional service that has earned us recognition as the region's Best of the Best. Through consistent quality and community focus, we continue building lasting relationships with our loyal patrons while maintaining rigorous food safety standards across all operations.
Services
Pizza
Wings
Catering
Calzones
Subs
Entrees
Salads
Desserts
Fish Fry
Online Ordering
Highlights and features
- We use premium ingredients in all our handcrafted Italian dishes
- We offer extensive catering menus for events of all sizes
- Our online ordering system provides convenient delivery options
- We maintain consistent quality across both New Hartford and Whitesboro locations
- Our spacious dining areas accommodate family gatherings and groups
What people say
Amazing pizza
Wicked friendly staff
Super clean
Hot and fresh
Top nothing service
Services
Pizza
Our hand-tossed pizzas feature fresh dough, house-made sauce, and premium toppings. Choose from classic combinations or create custom creations with over 20 topping options. Available in 12-inch and 16-inch sizes with gluten-friendly cauliflower crust options.
Wings
We offer boneless and traditional wings in multiple heat levels and specialty sauces. Wings come in 10-piece increments up to 50-piece orders with sides of bleu cheese, celery, and ranch dressing available.
Catering
Our catering menu includes tray-sized portions of ziti, lasagna, chicken riggies, and antipasto. Available for pickup or delivery with options for both hot and cold platters to serve events from 10 to 100+ guests.
Calzones
Handmade calzones filled with mozzarella and your choice of toppings. Served with marinara sauce for dipping. Buffalo chicken calzones feature fried chicken tossed in hot sauce with mozzarella cheese.
Subs
Freshly made subs with hot and cold options including Italian meats, grilled chicken, and specialty wraps. Choose from 8-inch and 12-inch sizes with customizable toppings and premium add-ons available.
Questions
What are Tony's Pizzeria & Deli Pizzeria & Deli catering options for large events?
We offer tray-sized portions of ziti, lasagna, chicken riggies, antipasto, and more. Full catering menus with pricing available for events of all sizes.
Do you offer online ordering for pickup or delivery?
Yes, our website provides full online ordering for both pickup and delivery options at both New Hartford and Whitesboro locations.
What specialty pizza options do you have available?
We feature specialty pizzas like Chicken Wing, BBQ Chicken, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Spinach & Ricotta, Meat Lovers, and Stuffed Pizzas.
Are there gluten-friendly menu options?
Yes, we offer a gluten-friendly cauliflower crust pizza with regular and premium topping options available.
What are your current business hours?
New Hartford: Mon 10am-9pm, Tue-Sat 10am-10pm, Sun 10am-9pm. Whitesboro: Mon-Fri 10am-8pm, Sat 11am-8:30pm, Sun 10am-8pm.
Reviews (6)
J.
Jan 02, 2022
Report
This is the best out of the Tonys Pizzas. Consistent food and service. Downgraded to 2 stars the pizza was over sauced which is a common mistake at all Tonys pizzas. The cheese slides of and it becomes a sloppy mess.
Teela Ogline
Dec 04, 2021
Report
I got a cheese pizza. It was amazing and one of the best pizzas I've had in along time. I didn't have to wait long for it to be done.
Nancy Marafioti
Dec 02, 2021
Report
Reliable. Very good pizza. Good quality cheese. I'm starting to buy garlic slices & they're so good. Their salads are super fresh. Hard working young people behind the counter. Attentive. Good eye contact. Pleasant. Accurate. Hard working.
Philip Ogopogo
Oct 12, 2021
Report
The staff was knowledgable and wicked friendly. Pizzeria was super clean and well lit. Pizza was amazing! Hot and fresh even after my 10 minute drive home.
Frank Cotrupe
Oct 03, 2021
Report
Amazing Pizza! Just had that pizza with some everything sauce and I couldn't stop eating it. Top nothing service too! Walk in and see the owners working, thats how you know its local! Thank you
Cj Pritchard
Aug 29, 2021
Report
Best around. From pizza to subs. Always great food. Staff and owners are always friendly and make things right! 5/5
