Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
18 Years
experience
Trusted Bathtub & Tile Refinishing Services in New York
At The Painted Otter Refinishers, we are dedicated to delivering affordable, top-tier refinishing solutions for bathtubs, tiles, sinks, and countertops. Our commitment to quality is reflected in our use of premium, uncut materials applied with meticulous preparation techniques that exceed industry standards. We pride ourselves on innovation, having developed a proprietary primer system and UV curing technology that ensure durability and immediate usability of surfaces. With a focus on environmental responsibility, our processes minimize waste and eliminate harmful solvents, aligning sustainability with exceptional results.

Backed by a 5-year warrantythe best in the industrywe serve residential, commercial, and hospitality clients across six states. Our teams combined expertise, exceeding 300 years in the field, guarantees personalized service and a dedication to customer satisfaction that has earned us a reputation as a trusted leader in fixture refinishing.
Services
Bathtub Refinishing Tile Refinishing Full Bathroom Renovations Sink Refinishing Commercial Services
Details
  • Year established: 2008
Highlights and features
  • We offer a 5-year warranty on all refinishing work.
  • Our UV curing technology allows immediate use of fixtures.
  • Eco-friendly processes with zero VOC emissions.
  • Team with over 300 years of combined industry experience.
  • Serving 6 states with personalized, customer-centric service.
Associations and certifications
  • Professional Bathtub Refinishers Association (PBRA)
What people say
Outstanding craftsmanship Professional and courteous 5-year warranty Eco-friendly solutions Immediate fixture usability
Services
Bathtub Refinishing
Our bathtub refinishing restores cast iron, steel, acrylic, and fiberglass tubs to like-new condition using durable, non-porous coatings. The process includes thorough surface preparation, bonding agents, and a 5-year warranty. Clients save up to 80% compared to replacement while retaining vintage fixtures.
Tile Refinishing
Tile refinishing updates worn bathroom or kitchen tiles with a seamless, waterproof finish in any color. Our Stone-Fleck option mimics granite or stone textures. The process eliminates grout lines, reducing mold risk and offering a 5-year warranty against peeling or adhesion failure.
Sink Refinishing
We restore pedestal, farmhouse, and inset sinks with a scratch-resistant, non-porous finish that resists stains and wear. Our process includes repairing chips and rust, with a 2-year warranty. Clients often change colors to match updated decor while preserving original fixtures.
Full Bathroom Renovations
Our full bathroom renovations combine refinishing with fixture upgrades, including vanities, lighting, and flooring. The process avoids demolition, reducing costs by up to 80% and completing projects in 35 days. UV-cured coatings allow immediate use of renovated spaces.
Commercial Services
We provide rapid, cost-effective refinishing for hotels, motels, and apartment complexes, restoring fixtures with minimal downtime. Services include tubs, tiles, countertops, and sinks, with competitive rates and a focus on maintaining property value and tenant satisfaction.
People
Nathan Oettinger
Owner
Nathan Oettinger leads The Painted Otter Refinishers with over 15 years of industry experience. His expertise in chemical bonding processes and commitment to customer satisfaction have earned numerous testimonials praising his professionalism and attention to detail.
Jessica Oettinger
Co-Owner
Jessica Oettinger collaborates on client consultations and project management, ensuring seamless service delivery. Her focus on client communication and quality control has strengthened the companys reputation for reliability and excellence in fixture refinishing.
Questions
What services does The Painted Otter Refinishers offer?
We specialize in bathtub, tile, sink, and countertop refinishing, full bathroom renovations, and commercial fixture restoration using eco-friendly materials.
How much does refinishing cost compared to replacement?
Refinishing costs up to 80% less than replacement, with bathtub services starting at $300–$500 and tile projects varying by scope.
What is the warranty on your work?
We offer a 5-year warranty covering material defects and adhesion failure, the longest in the industry.
How long does refinishing take?
Most projects complete in 3–5 hours for single fixtures or 3–5 days for full bathrooms, with immediate use post-service.
Are your materials environmentally friendly?
Yes, our UV-cured coatings emit zero VOCs and reduce landfill waste by avoiding fixture replacement.
Reviews (3)
Jennifer Barton
Jul 20, 2021 Report
This company postponed my first appointment, didn't show up for the second, and never called to reschedule. Would not deal with again, very unprofessional.
**Edit to respond to owner's comment below**
You didn't call me Thursday, I called you when no one showed up to do the work. You said you'd call me later that day, yet I didn't hear from you until two days later after you'd read my negative online review. It doesn't matter what the emergency was. You needed to call me, at least the next day, to make things right. My negative review stands, and I am no longer interested in patronizing your
Jose Fabre
Nov 30, 2020 Report
Positive:Professionalism
Nathan from the Painted Otter helped me convert my old, ugly bathtub into a sparkling white bathtub with his re-finishing services. No need for any demolition work!
Service:Painting
Angela
Sep 30, 2020 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Punctuality,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Nathan did a great job resurfacing my 100 year old tub. Over a decade, still looks great. Very professional and talented. Will def use them again
Service:Refurbishment